Doubt Calculating the Total Displacement for this Person Walking

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating total displacement when given two movements: 1.3 km North and 2.5 km South. The formula for displacement, Δd = df - di, requires careful attention to the signs of the displacements. The correct approach is to treat North as positive and South as negative, leading to a total displacement of -1.2 km, which can also be expressed as 1.2 km South. Distance, being a scalar, is simply the sum of magnitudes, resulting in a total distance of 3.8 km. Understanding the distinction between displacement and distance is crucial for accurate calculations.
Remle
Messages
12
Reaction score
8
Homework Statement
You start walking home from school. After walking 1.3 km North, you get a phone call on your cell from your mom asking if you can meet her at the mall. You will have to turn around and walk 2.5 km South. Determine your distance and displacement to get to the mall.
Relevant Equations
d=df-di
I having a little bit of problem with ##\Delta d = d_f - d_i##. When substituting fo ##d_f## and ##d_i##, should I follow the signs rule (positive or negative)?
For example,
The problem shows that the displacement is ##1.2~\rm{km}, south## by solving ##\Delta d = -2.5 + 1.3## and I get that, but if I use the formula above the equation would appear like this ##\Delta d = -2.5 - 1.3## which gives me ##-3.8~\rm{km}## or ##3.8~\rm{km}, south##.

What am I missing?

source: http://www.studyphysics.ca/2007/20/01_kinematics/08_velocity.pdf
 
Physics news on Phys.org
There are two displacements, one is 1.3 km North and the other is 2.5 km South. The overall displacement is the sum of the two. Note that the displacements have opposite directions so you are adding a positive and a negative number.
 
kuruman said:
There are two displacements.
THIS is what I needed. So first displacement is ##\Delta d = 1.3 - 0## and the second is ##\Delta d = 0 - 2.5## so to speak.
 
Remle said:
THIS is what I needed. So first displacement is ##\Delta d = 1.3 - 0## and the second is ##\Delta d = 0 - 2.5## so to speak.
If you are given two points (a start point and an end point), then the dispalcement is the position vector of the end point minus the position vector of the start point.

But, in this case you are given the displacements, so there is no need for any subtraction:
$$\Delta d_1 = 1.3km, \ \Delta d_2 = - 2.5km$$
 
@Remle -- what did you get for the distance answer?
 
berkeman said:
@Remle -- what did you get for the distance answer?
Sorry for the late response. For the distance since is a scalar just had to add all the numbers. ##d = 1.3 + 2.5 = 3.8~\rm{km}##.
 
  • Like
Likes hmmm27 and berkeman
Remle said:
Sorry for the late response. For the distance since is a scalar just had to add all the numbers. ##d = 1.3 + 2.5 = 3.8~\rm{km}##.
No, distance is not a scalar, it is a magnitude. Scalars have sign.
Taking North as positive you can find displacement using scalars: 1.3km+(-2.5)km N = -1.2km N, or 1.2km S.
For distances you add the magnitudes |1.3|+|-2.5|=3.8.
 
Back
Top