Electron's energies and charge density in plate-capacitor

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around the energies of an electron in a plate capacitor setup, focusing on calculating voltage and charge density. The context includes the motion of an electron between two charged plates, with specific values for distance, mass, and charge provided.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants explore the relationship between kinetic energy and electric potential energy, questioning the assumptions about initial conditions and the conservation of energy principle. There are discussions about the signs of charge density and electric field strength, as well as the implications of setting potential energy to zero at one of the plates.

Discussion Status

Some participants have confirmed calculations regarding voltage and charge density, while others express uncertainty about the signs of values and the interpretation of potential energy. The discussion is ongoing, with various interpretations being explored but no explicit consensus reached.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that the potential energy can be set arbitrarily, and the importance of potential differences is emphasized. There is also mention of confusion regarding the negative sign in electric field strength and charge density, reflecting the complexity of the concepts being discussed.

late347
Messages
300
Reaction score
15

Homework Statement



Tasks to do:
a.)give voltage
b.)give the absolute value of charge density for plates

Presumably the absolute values of charge densities for plates is equal between the two of them.
An electron is accelerated in a homogenic electric field, inbetween two oppositely charged plates. Presumably the electron moves from one plate to the other plate.

The distance between plates = d = 0,01m

The starting velocity of the electron is assumed to be ##0= v_0##

The end velocity of the electron is ##1,9 * 10^7 m/s = v_1##

mass of electron ##m_e = 9,1*10^{-31} kg##

charge of electron ##q_e = -1,6*10^{-19} C##

Homework Equations



electric potential energy ##E_p = q*V##, where V=potential q= charge
##E_k=0,5*mv^2##
potential V, distance d, strenght of field E ##V= E*d##
conservation of energy

The Attempt at a Solution


[/B]
It could be assumed that minus plate = potential 0, I guess...
electron's kinetic and potential electric energies.jpg
Well, in conventional gravitational potential energy and kinetic energy type of problems the good idea would be to try to use the conservation of energy principle.

from the electron's movement we know (I think?)
that:

E_{k0} =0 joules
E_{k1} = can be calculated with the given values

E_{p0}= this must be at the value of 0 joules if the formulas are true, because I suppose the electron does start from rest from the position of the negatively charged plate towards the positively charged plate. We can assume that at at the negative plate, the potential V=0

##E_{p0} = q_e * V##, where we can see that V=0, and we know that q_e = some negative charge
so the ##E_{p0}## = 0 if that formula is true... (because mathematically qV=0, when V or q are 0)

I calculated that the final kinetic energy ##E_{k1} = 1,64255* 10^{-16}## Joules, by using the kinetic energy formula E=0,5*mv^2

conservation of energy principle
##E_{k1} + E_{p1} =E_{k0} + E_{p0}##
##E_{k0}=0##
##E_{p0}=0##
<=>
##E_{k1} + E_{p1} =0##
<=>
##E_{k1} = -E_{p1}##

I'm little bit uncertain if this is above mentioned portion is true for the relationship between electron's kinetic energy and the electric potential energy of that same electron?My teacher talked about another formula which could be useful at this stage of the problem
##ΔE_{p}= q*ΔV= qU## where U = voltage

if that formula is true then it would seem that this follows:
##(E_{p1}-0)= q* (V_1-0)##
##(-1,64255*10^{-16} J = -1,6*10^{-19}C * V_1##

therefore essentially
voltage U = 1026,5937 VoltsI think the second part b.) was more confusing for me a little bit, especially the negative sign and positive sign issues.

Supposedly ΔV = U = voltage
then there should be a formula such as:
ΔV = -Ed
That formula describes change of potential in the same line as the electric field lines(?). E is the electric field strength and d is the distance moved.

if the voltage truly is about 1000Volts then:
1000V= -E*d
100000 V/m = -E
E= -100 000 V/m

(question: why is the electric field strength negative value at this point? now I am confused as heck)

With the Electric field strength one can use the formula to find out the charge density σ
E= σ/ε_{0}

=>

σ= - 8,85 *10^{-7} C/(m^2)

(question, again the negative sign is a little bit confusing at this stage
although admittedly one of the plates should have a negative value for the chage density and the other one should have the positive value)

so that essentially I think the idea was to calculate absolute value of charge density |σ|

But I think that those should be just about the correct answers.
For b.) the more accurate answer from my calculation without the rounding of variables inbetween calculation was something more like

##σ= -9,09 * 10^{-7} \frac{C}{m^2}##
 
Physics news on Phys.org
late347 said:
I'm little bit uncertain if this is above mentioned portion is true for the relationship between electron's kinetic energy and the electric potential energy of that same electron?
What else?
late347 said:
voltage U = 1026,5937 Volts
Correct.
late347 said:
(question: why is the electric field strength negative value at this point? now I am confused as heck)
That just depends on the direction you look at (from minus to plus or from plus to minus). It doesn't matter.
late347 said:
although admittedly one of the plates should have a negative value for the chage density and the other one should have the positive value)
Right.
late347 said:
##σ= -9,09 * 10^{-7} \frac{C}{m^2}##
Right apart from the sign - the absolute value is positive.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: late347
mfb said:
What else?Correct.That just depends on the direction you look at (from minus to plus or from plus to minus). It doesn't matter.
Right.
Right apart from the sign - the absolute value is positive.

I was initially confused a little bit about the idea that my teacher had.

E_kin1= -E_p1

But I managed to draw out that same conclusion from using the conservation of energy formula so it suddenly made sense again...

Was I correct also that the electric potential energy of the electron while it begins its journey from the negative plate, should be 0 because... the potential is 0 at that location ?

Well... at any rate you have to pick a zero point for the potential somewhere probably one of the charged plates (usually the negative one)
 
late347 said:
Was I correct also that the electric potential energy of the electron while it begins its journey from the negative plate, should be 0 because... the potential is 0 at that location ?
The potential energy is arbitrary, you can set it to whatever you want. Only potential differences between points have a physical meaning.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: late347

Similar threads

Replies
11
Views
4K
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 26 ·
Replies
26
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 42 ·
2
Replies
42
Views
8K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K