Entropy Change For Van Der Waals Gas

  • Thread starter laser1
  • Start date
5 replies · 1K views · last reply
laser1
Messages
170
Reaction score
23
Homework Statement
description
Relevant Equations
description
Typeset exam question: one mole of a van der Waals gas with equation of state P = RT/(V - b) - a/V^2, with a and b constants; part (a) asks for the entropy change when the gas expands isothermally until its volume doubles, with a Maxwell relation hint and [5 marks].


I have two different methods giving different results

Handwritten derivations side by side, labelled #1 and #2, of the entropy change ΔS for a van der Waals gas from V to 2V, both boxed at the final result.


Why is this the case? (Left method was answer in solutions, right method was my answer before checking the solutions). Also yes pretend V was V_1 or something ignore my dummy variables :)
 
Chestermiller said:
The first method is correct. Why do you feel the 2nd method is correct?
I don't see any flaws in logic. I simply substitute for P and integrate.
 
laser1 said:
I don't see any flaws in logic. I simply substitute for P and integrate.
Your equation for the effect of pressure on entropy in the first cast is correct. Where did you get the starting equation for the effect of pressure on entropy in the 2nd case from?
 
Chestermiller said:
Your equation for the effect of pressure on entropy in the first cast is correct. Where did you get the starting equation for the effect of pressure on entropy in the 2nd case from?
The question states "isothermal", which implies ##U=0##. So by the first law, this must mean that ##dQ=PdV##. Following this, the definition of the change in entropy is $$\Delta S = \int_i^f{\frac{dQ}{T}}$$ and I substitute ##dQ=PdV## to get the starting equation for #2.
 
laser1 said:
The question states "isothermal", which implies ##U=0##. So by the first law, this must mean that ##dQ=PdV##. Following this, the definition of the change in entropy is $$\Delta S = \int_i^f{\frac{dQ}{T}}$$ and I substitute ##dQ=PdV## to get the starting equation for #
Isothermal does not imply that du is equal to 0 for a Vdw gas.
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes   Reactions: MatinSAR, Lord Jestocost and laser1