# Error in Mathematical Methods for Physicist by Arfken, et al

• I
Mathematical Methods for Physicist: A Comprehensice Guide (Seventh Edition) by George Brown Arfken, Hans Jürgen Weber, Frank E. Harris

I am studying it.
Up to now I read to page 35 and have found 3 errors.

Chapter 1 Mathematical Preliminaries
1.1 Infinite Series
More Sensitive Tests
Equation 1.15 (Page 8)
≤ is incorrect, < is correct.

Exercises 1.1.7 (Page 11)
It must be given to prerequisite that p > 0 and q > 0

1.3 Binomial Theorem
Equation 1.66 (Page 34)
If n > m, m(m - 1)...(m - n + 1) = 0
In other words, whether n → ∞ or not, the remainder is always 0.
Furthermore, the radius (interval) of convergence is not -1 < x < 1.
Because m(m - 1)...(m - n + 1) = 0, ratio test fail.
As far as either m or x does not approach infinity, the power series is convergent.

Orodruin
Staff Emeritus
Homework Helper
Gold Member
2021 Award
I don’t get the point of this thread. Do you have questions regarding these issues? Otherwise errors in textbooks are nothing new as it is essentially impossible to write an error-free text. In particular one with the size of Arfken.

Maybe the errors are deliberate. Put there to make sure you're paying attention.

Orodruin
Staff Emeritus
Homework Helper
Gold Member
2021 Award
Maybe the errors are deliberate. Put there to make sure you're paying attention.
Being a textbook author myself, I seriously doubt this. It would be quite non-pedagogical.

Doc Al
Mentor
I imagine the edition I used (back in the day) had even more errors. (No wonder I'm so confused!)