Estimate Instantaneous Velocity

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves estimating the instantaneous velocity of a ball thrown into the air, modeled by the equation y = 48t − 16t². The original poster seeks to find the average velocity over specific time intervals starting from t = 2 and then estimate the instantaneous velocity at that point.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss calculating average velocity using the formula for change in position over change in time, with specific values of h to approach the instantaneous velocity. There are questions about the correct substitution into the height function and the interpretation of results as h approaches zero.

Discussion Status

Some participants have provided guidance on evaluating the average velocity and the importance of using small values for h to estimate instantaneous velocity. There is an ongoing exploration of the calculations and clarifications regarding the substitution process in the equations.

Contextual Notes

Participants express confusion about the use of specific values for h and the implications of those choices for estimating instantaneous velocity. There are also mentions of potential typos in the equations being discussed, which may affect understanding.

FritoTaco
Messages
132
Reaction score
23

Homework Statement


If a ball is thrown into the air with a velocity of 48 ft/s, its height in feet t seconds later is given by y = 48t − 16t2.
(a) Find the average velocity for the time period beginning when t = 2 and lasting for each of the following.

(i) 0.5 seconds

(ii) 0.1 seconds

(iii) 0.05 seconds

(iv) 0.01 seconds

(b) Estimate the instantaneous velocity when t = 2.

Homework Equations



Average Velocity =\dfrac{\triangle y}{\triangle t} (Change in position over change in time)

m=\dfrac{y_{2}-y_{1}}{x_{2}-x_{1}}

The Attempt at a Solution



Set: t = 2 and t = 2 + h (let h be the time difference) \ne 0

t = 2 is y_{1},x_{1} and t = 2 + h is y_{2},x_{2}

Average Velocity = \dfrac{y(2+h)-y(2)}{(2+h)-2}

Now with y=48t-16t^2, we will replace t with 2 and 2 + h.

\dfrac{48(2+h)-16(2+h)^2-[48(2)-16(2)^2)]}{h}

\dfrac{96+48h-16(4+4h+h^2)-96+64}{h}

\dfrac{48h-64-64h-16h^2+64}{h}

\dfrac{-16h^2-16h}{h}

\dfrac{h(-16h-16)}{h}

Average Velocity =-16h-16

Then I plug in (i) 0.5 into the equation like this: -16(0.5)-16=24
I do this for the rest of them and get correct answers according to the online "WebAssign" website. Now I'm stuck on (b) "Estimate the instantaneous velocity when t = 2." You can look at my picture, I tried plugging in values near 2 like 2.1 and 2.01, etc, into y=48t-16t^2 What am I doing wrong? So as I get closer to 2 I get closer to the slope of 31.999 which then you make an educated guess (by rounding) and get 32. But this is wrong. I don't know why? Also, I heard there is another method for finding average velocity, my book doesn't have it--anyone know it? Much appreciation.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0123.JPG
    IMG_0123.JPG
    22.4 KB · Views: 1,472
Physics news on Phys.org
FritoTaco said:

Homework Statement


If a ball is thrown into the air with a velocity of 48 ft/s, its height in feet t seconds later is given by y = 48t − 16t2.
(a) Find the average velocity for the time period beginning when t = 2 and lasting for each of the following.

(i) 0.5 seconds

(ii) 0.1 seconds

(iii) 0.05 seconds

(iv) 0.01 seconds

(b) Estimate the instantaneous velocity when t = 2.

Homework Equations



Average Velocity =\dfrac{\triangle y}{\triangle t} (Change in position over change in time)

m=\dfrac{y_{2}-y_{1}}{x_{2}-x_{1}}

The Attempt at a Solution



Set: t = 2 and t = 2 + h (let h be the time difference) \ne 0

t = 2 is y_{1},x_{1} and t = 2 + h is y_{2},x_{2}

Average Velocity = \dfrac{y(2+h)-y(2)}{(2+h)-2}

Now with y=48t-16t^2, we will replace t with 2 and 2 + h.

\dfrac{48(2+h)-16(2+h)^2-[48(2)-16(2)^2)]}{h}

\dfrac{96+48h-16(4+4h+h^2)-96+64}{h}

\dfrac{48h-64-64h-16h^2+64}{h}

\dfrac{-16h^2-16h}{h}

\dfrac{h(-16h-16)}{h}

Average Velocity =-16h-16

Then I plug in (i) 0.5 into the equation like this: -16(0.5)-16=24
I do this for the rest of them and get correct answers according to the online "WebAssign" website. Now I'm stuck on (b) "Estimate the instantaneous velocity when t = 2." You can look at my picture, I tried plugging in values near 2 like 2.1 and 2.01, etc, into y=48t-16t^2 What am I doing wrong? So as I get closer to 2 I get closer to the slope of 31.999 which then you make an educated guess (by rounding) and get 32. But this is wrong. I don't know why? Also, I heard there is another method for finding average velocity, my book doesn't have it--anyone know it? Much appreciation.
For the instantaneous velocity near t = 2, look at the change in position divided by the change in time.

Look at ##\frac{y(2 + h) - y(2)}{2 + h - 2}##, for some values of h that are close to 0, say h = .1, h = .01, h = .001.
You should get a value close to -16 ft/sec.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FritoTaco
My teacher also said use values like 0.1, 0.01, etc. Why? I don't get why we're using those values? Also, how do we make the equation where we can plug in those values? from using \dfrac{y(2+h)-y(2)}{(2+h)-(2)}
 
Last edited:
FritoTaco said:
My teacher also said use values like 0.1, 0.01, etc. Why? I don't get why we're using those values?
Because you want the time interval to be very short so as to get a closer estimate of the instantaneous velocity.
FritoTaco said:
Also, how do we make the equation where we can plug in those values? from using \dfrac{y(2+h)-y(2)}{(2+h)-(2)}
You have the equation: ##y(t) = 48t - 16t^2##
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FritoTaco
Mark44 said:
Because you want the time interval to be very short so as to get a closer estimate of the instantaneous velocity.

This is where I don't understand. It says find instantaneous velocity when t = 2. Okay, so don't we want to use values close to 2? Like 2.1, 2.01. So if it was like, "find instantaneous velocity closer to when t = 5", would I still use 0.1, 0.01, etc? Because that means we are 0.1 from 5 or 0.01 from 5?

Mark44 said:
You have the equation: y(t)=48t−16t2

When I plug 48(t)-16(t)^2 into \dfrac{y(2+h)-y(2)}{(2+h)-2}, I don't understand how to do it. Am I actually plugging in 48(t)-16(t)^2 into the y values of the other equation? Something like this:

\dfrac{48t-16t^2(2+h)-48t-16t^2(2)}{2+h-2}? Then distribute and simplify it down more?
 
FritoTaco said:
This is where I don't understand. It says find instantaneous velocity when t = 2. Okay, so don't we want to use values close to 2? Like 2.1, 2.01. So if it was like, "find instantaneous velocity closer to when t = 5", would I still use 0.1, 0.01, etc? Because that means we are 0.1 from 5 or 0.01 from 5?
Yes. If h = .01, then 2 + h = 2 + .01 = 2.01
FritoTaco said:
When I plug 48(t)-16(t)^2 into \dfrac{y(2+h)-y(2)}{(2+h)-2}, I don't understand how to do it. Am I actually plugging in 48(t)-16(t)^2 into the y values of the other equation? Something like this:
\dfrac{48t-16t^2(2+h)-48t-16t^2(2)}{2+h-2}? Then distribute and simplify it down more?
No, you are "plugging in" 2 + h and 2, respectively, into your height function y(t) = 48t - 16t2
For y(2 + h), replace t in your formula with 2 + h.
For y(2), replace t with 2.
Then simplify the result.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FritoTaco
Mark44 said:
No, you are "plugging in" 2 + h and 2, respectively, into your height function y(t) = 48t - 16t2
For y(2 + h), replace t in your formula with 2 + h.
For y(2), replace t with 2.
Then simplify the result.

48(2+h)-16(2)^2

96+48h-64

48h-32

Am I doing this right?
 
FritoTaco said:
48(2+h)-16(2)^2
I don't know what you're doing above.
FritoTaco said:
96+48h-64

48h-32

Am I doing this right?
No. This is what you should be evaluating: ##\frac{y(2+h)-y(2)}{(2+h)-2}##, using ##y(t) = 48t - 16t^2##. The quotient here gives you the average speed between time t = 2 + h and time t = 2.
Edit: Fixed a typo I had in the y(t) formula.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FritoTaco
Mark44 said:
No. This is what you should be evaluating: y(2+h)−y(2)(2+h)−2y(2+h)−y(2)(2+h)−2\frac{y(2+h)-y(2)}{(2+h)-2}, using y(t)=48t−32t2y(t)=48t−32t2y(t) = 48t - 32t^2. The quotient here gives you the average speed between time t = 2 + h and time t = 2.

How did you get y(t)=48t-32t^2?

Also, in above when you said "For y(2 + h), replace t in your formula with 2 + h. For y(2), replace t with 2." Isn't that what I did and got the 48h - 32?
 
  • #10
FritoTaco said:
How did you get y(t)=48t-32t^2?
I miswrote 32t2 instead of 16t2. I have fixed my typo.

FritoTaco said:
Also, in above when you said "For y(2 + h), replace t in your formula with 2 + h. For y(2), replace t with 2." Isn't that what I did and got the 48h - 32?
Whatever you did isn't right. y(2 + h) gives you two terms, and y(2) also gives you two terms. Also, you have 2 + h - 2 in the denominator.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FritoTaco
  • #11
FritoTaco said:
Also, in above when you said "For y(2 + h), replace t in your formula with 2 + h. For y(2), replace t with 2." Isn't that what I did and got the 48h - 32?
Let's back up a few steps. You need to evaluate ##\frac{y(2 + h) - y(2)}{2 + h - 2}##, using ##y(t) = 48t - 16t^2##.

What do you get for y(2 + h)?
What do you get for y(2)?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FritoTaco
  • #12
Am I placing 48t-16t^2 into the y part of both y(2+h) and y(2)?

Like this maybe:

\dfrac{48(2+h)-16(2+h)^2-[48(2)-16(2)^2]}{(2+h)-2}

\dfrac{96+48h-16(h^2+4h+4)-96+64}{(2+h)-2}

\dfrac{96+48h-16h^2-64h-64-96+64}{(2+h)-2}

\dfrac{-16h^2-16h}{(2+h)-2}

I'm pretty sure something isn't right but I gave it a go here.
 
Last edited:
  • #13
FritoTaco said:
Am I placing 48t-16t^2 into the y part of both y(2+h) and y(2)?

Like this maybe:

\dfrac{48(2+h)-16(2+h)^2-[48(2)-16(2)^2]}{(2+h)-2}

\dfrac{96+48h-16(h^2+4h+4)-96+64}{(2+h)-2}

\dfrac{96+48h-16h^2-64h-64-96+64}{(2+h)-2}

\dfrac{-16h^2-16h}{(2+h)-2}

I'm pretty sure something isn't right but I gave it a go here.
This is correct, but you should simplify the denominator.

When you've done that, estimate the velocity at a few times close to 2 sec., such as 2.1 (h = .1), 2.01 (h = .01), and however more you need to do.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FritoTaco
  • #14
Mark44 said:
This is correct, but you should simplify the denominator.

When you've done that, estimate the velocity at a few times close to 2 sec., such as 2.1 (h = .1), 2.01 (h = .01), and however more you need to do.

Will it just be \dfrac{-16h^2-16h}{h}?
 
  • #15
FritoTaco said:
Will it just be \dfrac{-16h^2-16h}{h}?
And simplfy that...
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FritoTaco
  • #16
Like this:

\dfrac{-16h(h+1)}{h} Factor

16(h+1) Cancel out the h
 
  • #17
FritoTaco said:
Like this:

\dfrac{-16h(h+1)}{h} Factor

16(h+1) Cancel out the h
Where did the minus sign go?

When you get that straigtened out, pick a few (small) values of h, as described in parts i) through iv) of the first post, and then estimate the velocity at t = 2 seconds.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FritoTaco
  • #18
Oh, I forgot about that. It should've been there as -16(h+1)

i.)0.5

-16(0.5+1) = -24 ft/s​

ii.)0.1

-16(0.1+1) = -17.6 ft/s​

iii.)0.05

-16(0.05+1) = -16.8 ft/s​

iv.)0.01

-16(0.01+1) = 1-6.16 ft/s​

b.) Estimate the instantaneous velocity when t = 2.

-16(0.1+1) = -17.6 ft/s

-16(0.01+1) = -16.16 ft/s

-16(0.001+1) = -16.08 ft/s

Estimate: -16 ft/s.

I entered that in and got it right! Thank you very much for your help!
 
  • #19
FritoTaco said:
iv.)0.01

-16(0.01+1) = 1-6.16 ft/s
Surely, you mean -16.16 ft/sec
FritoTaco said:
b.) Estimate the instantaneous velocity when t = 2.

-16(0.1+1) = -17.6 ft/s

-16(0.01+1) = -16.16 ft/s

-16(0.001+1) = -16.08 ft/s

Estimate: -16 ft/s.

I entered that in and got it right! Thank you very much for your help!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FritoTaco
  • #20
Oh, oops. Yeah, -16.16ft/s.
 

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
3K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
1K