Find P(B) and P(A/B) by considering the given probability question

  • Thread starter Thread starter chwala
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Probability
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on calculating probabilities P(B) and P(A/B) using a Venn diagram approach. Participants critique the initial attempt, pointing out errors in shading and the interpretation of intersections. A corrected method is presented, using the formula P(B/A) = P(B) * P(A/B) / P(A) to derive values. The final calculations lead to determining P(B) as 0.75, which simplifies further probability assessments. The conversation emphasizes the importance of careful analysis in probability problems.
chwala
Gold Member
Messages
2,825
Reaction score
413
Homework Statement
Find ##P(B)## and ##P(A/B)## by considering the given problem below(attached)
Relevant Equations
conditional probability
1618555975147.png

i managed to find the values...i am seeking alternative approach to the problem. See my attempt below.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
1618556112507.png
 
You need to be more careful about each step. The first equality of your attempt is wrong. The Venn Diagram only has B' shaded, so which part is A##\cap##B'? It would help if you would shade A in one direction and B' in another direction and clearly show what A##\cap##B' is. The equality from the Venn diagram looks wrong. There may be more mistakes. You should look carefully at each step more carefully before proceeding.
 
  • Like
Likes chwala
##A## intersection ##B^{'}## is the shaded region...it follows that ##B## is the unshaded...
 
Let me check on this after my lunch .
 
chwala said:
##A## intersection ##B^{'}## is the shaded region...it follows that ##B## is the unshaded...
No, it is not. Much of that shaded area is not in A. And that would not be how you decide what B is anyway. You are correct that B is all of the inside of the B circle, but that is always true no matter what the rest of the Venn diagram looks like.
 
Ok give me a moment, let me check again...
 
My approach was wrong, the correct way is as follows;
##P(B/A)= \frac {P(B). P(A/B)}{P(A)}##
##0.8= \frac {P(B). P(A/B)}{0.75}##
##0.6=P(B). P(A/B)##

Also,
##P(B/A^{'})= \frac {P(B). P(A^{'}/B)}{P(A^{'})}##
##0.6= \frac {P(B). P(A^{'}/B)}{0.25}##
##0.15=P(B). P(A^{'}/B)##

we know that,
##P(A/B)+P(A^{'}/B)=1##
##\frac {0.6}{P(B)}##+##\frac {0.15}{P(B)}##=##1##
on cross multiplication by ##P(B)##,
##0.6+0.15=P(B)##
##0.75=P(B)##...with this found the other part is easy...
Bingo from Africa!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top