Find the Capacitance when given the Power Factor

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
jaus tail
Messages
613
Reaction score
48

Homework Statement


Circuit schematic: a voltage source V on the left in parallel with a branch of a 1 ohm resistor in series with an inductor labelled 1 L, and a capacitor labelled C on the right branch.

w = 1 rad/s
power factor is 0.8 lag

Homework Equations


Using Phasor we can do

The Attempt at a Solution


Phasor diagram with Vc, VL and Vr voltage vectors, currents Ic, Ir and It, and a labeled angle of 36.87 degrees and 45 degrees.

Since pf = 0.8 lag. I source lags V source by 36.87 degrees.
Vc is voltage across Capacitor = Voltage across ( Resistor + inductor)
Handwritten phasor derivation of currents I_R, I_C and I_T in a circuit, with values such as I_R = I_C/(√2 ∠-135°), I_T = I_C[(-0.5 - j0.5)/C] and a final ratio 0.99/0.1414 = (-0.5 - 0.707)/(-0.5 + 0.707).


Solving this I get C = 0.5
But book says C = 0.125
I had actually solved this sum many weeks ago and got right answer then but I cannot find the book now and am struggling to solve again. Can anybody help me?
 
Attachments
  • Phasor diagram with Ir horizontal in red, Vr in red, Vc in green pointing up-right, VL in blue vertical, Ic and It in dark red and labelled, angle 36.87 marked and 45 degrees marked between Vc and the vertical.
    upload_2018-1-25_10-44-58.png
    3.3 KB · Views: 609
  • Phasor diagram with Vc, VL and Vr voltage vectors, currents Ic, Ir and It, and a labeled angle of 36.87 degrees and 45 degrees.
    upload_2018-1-25_10-45-2.png
    3.3 KB · Views: 982
  • Circuit schematic: a voltage source V on the left in parallel with a branch of a 1 ohm resistor in series with an inductor labelled 1 L, and a capacitor labelled C on the right branch.
    upload_2018-1-25_10-45-12.png
    1.6 KB · Views: 1,062
  • Handwritten phasor derivation on lined paper: currents I_R, I_C and I_T written in polar form with angles of -135 degrees and 135 degrees, KCL applied, and real and imaginary parts equated to solve for C, giving 0.99 and 0.1414 terms.
    upload_2018-1-25_11-4-11.png
    54.1 KB · Views: 632
  • Handwritten phasor derivation of currents I_R, I_C and I_T in a circuit, with values such as I_R = I_C/(√2 ∠-135°), I_T = I_C[(-0.5 - j0.5)/C] and a final ratio 0.99/0.1414 = (-0.5 - 0.707)/(-0.5 + 0.707).
    upload_2018-1-25_11-5-14.png
    41.2 KB · Views: 588
Your phasor diagram is correct, but it is difficult to get anything out of it.

Assume the source to be of 1V.
Draw the phasor parallelogram of currents whose one phasor is the current in the RL branch (known) and other side as the capacitor current (unknown). Then you can solve it using simple geometry. The answer is indeed 0.125F.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jaus tail
Phasor diagram of an RC circuit with Vr horizontal in red, Ic and I phasors, Vc at 36.86 degrees, and VL shown in green perpendicular to Vr.

Handwritten working on lined paper: Ir = Ic/(√2 C) at angle -135° (equation 1), a KCL line It = Ir + Ic, and a derivation of It at angle 0 and It at 135° with a red oval around a term containing Ic/(√2 C) at -135° and Ic at 135°.

I also get 0.125 if I make this change above.
In circled part, if I take Ic angle as 0 degrees I get answer, but why should Ic angle be zero. Ir = | Ic/(square root 2) / C |at angle -135 degrees as per equation 1. So when I substitute Ir angle 0, shouldn't I substitute Ic/1.414 / C and the angle -135 degrees as well?
But I get right answer when I substitute only magnitude of Ir and not the angle in the KCL equation. Why?

I also get the right answer if I substitute in KCL equation: Ic angle 135 by 1.414 C Ir angle 135.
But shouldn't it be angle 135 + 135? I'm not able to understand why only magnitude should be substituted and not the phase angle from equation 1... to get the right answer?
 
Attachments
  • Phasor diagram of an RC circuit with Vr horizontal in red, Ic and I phasors, Vc at 36.86 degrees, and VL shown in green perpendicular to Vr.
    upload_2018-1-26_9-27-52.png
    2.6 KB · Views: 498
  • Handwritten working on lined paper: Ir = Ic/(√2 C) at angle -135° (equation 1), a KCL line It = Ir + Ic, and a derivation of It at angle 0 and It at 135° with a red oval around a term containing Ic/(√2 C) at -135° and Ic at 135°.
    upload_2018-1-26_9-29-18.png
    11.8 KB · Views: 512
Last edited:
Can somebody please explain this to me? Why in the red circled part above has the angle not been substituted? If I replace 135 with zero then I get the answer.
 
Sorry for the late reply, I'd almost forgot about this thread.

In your working, why have you multiplied IR by √2? It seems you forgot to multiply Ic by √2 as well, since √2 should not appear in the equations as it is just a scaling factor and gets canceled out on both the sides.
I haven't checked your solution thoroughly, but this is probably why you are having trouble with phase angles (sin 135°=1/√2 and maybe it cancels the √2 in your voltage/current magnitude).

Anyways, I won't recommend this approach for GATE. I believe the phasor approach would be easier and quicker.
All the best!
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: jaus tail