- #1

- 307

- 19

You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

- I
- Thread starter parshyaa
- Start date

- #1

- 307

- 19

- #2

mfb

Mentor

- 35,353

- 11,678

It is not, as your example shows. It is the magnitude of the number.( because root of squared number is the number itself)

- #3

- 3,580

- 1,387

But to be more accurate when you want the square root of a number , you have to state if you want the negative or the positive square root.

When we just say "square root" we mean by convention the positive square root, so it is "a bit more correct" to say that the (positive) square root of (-5)^2 is 5.

- #4

- 22,089

- 3,296

Both answers 5 and -5 are correct for the square root of (-5)^2.

No. This is very wrong. The square root of any number is positive. So the square root of ##(-5)^2## is ##5##.

- #5

Svein

Science Advisor

- 2,143

- 694

As long as you are in the real domain, yes. In the complex domain both +5 and -5 are the square roots of 25 (since there are no "positive numbers").No. This is very wrong. The square root of any number is positive. So the square root of ##(-5)^2## is ##5##.

- #6

- 22,089

- 3,296

As long as you are in the real domain, yes. In the complex domain both +5 and -5 are the square roots of 25 (since there are no "positive numbers").

This is a common definition of the square root in complex numbers, but I don't necessarily agree with it. The problem is that it would make the square root no longer a function, which is undesirable. This is usually fixed by defining a principal square root which only evaluates to ##5## and which has a branch cut (in the same way, our square root in ##\mathbb{R}## is a principal square root too). A nicer solution exists when you go to Riemann surfaces though.

- #7

Svein

Science Advisor

- 2,143

- 694

That was in my mind, yes.A nicer solution exists when you go to Riemann surfaces though.

- #8

- 307

- 19

Okk I got it, answer is +/- 5 but we take 5 because of conventional use

- #9

FactChecker

Science Advisor

Gold Member

- 6,184

- 2,390

It is standard to use the positive square root of a positive number. In complex analysis, that is called the "principle value" of the square root. The negative value will work but it is not the principle value.

EDIT: If you are doing your own work and taking a square root, you should often consider both the positive and negative values. If both might work, indicate that with ±√. If only the positive should be considered, indicate that with √. If only the negative should be considered, indicate that with -√. In all cases, √ just indicates the positive value.

EDIT: If you are doing your own work and taking a square root, you should often consider both the positive and negative values. If both might work, indicate that with ±√. If only the positive should be considered, indicate that with √. If only the negative should be considered, indicate that with -√. In all cases, √ just indicates the positive value.

Last edited:

- #10

Svein

Science Advisor

- 2,143

- 694

But [itex] z^{2}=25\Leftrightarrow z^{2}-25=0 \Leftrightarrow (z+5)\cdot (z-5)=0[/itex]...This is a common definition of the square root in complex numbers, but I don't necessarily agree with it. The problem is that it would make the square root no longer a function, which is undesirable. This is usually fixed by defining a principal square root which only evaluates to ##5## and which has a branch cut (in the same way, our square root in ##\mathbb{R}## is a principal square root too). A nicer solution exists when you go to Riemann surfaces though.

- #11

SammyS

Staff Emeritus

Science Advisor

Homework Helper

Gold Member

- 11,361

- 1,028

If you had asked more symbolically, "What is ##\ \sqrt{(-2-3) ^2\,}\, ?\,##" then assuming your context was real rather than complex numbers, the answer would be simply, ##\ \sqrt{(-2-3) ^2\,}=5\ .\ ## In the context of real numbers, the ##\ \sqrt{\ \ } \ ## symbol represents the "principle value" of the square root, as pointed out by FactChecker and others.Root of (-2-3) ^2 = -5 ( because root of squared number is the number itself) but also the square of (-2-3) is 25 and its root is (+5) /(-5). Therefore what is the correct answer and reason . I think it is -5(google answer is Also -5) but I don't have any reason. Please help me

Moreover, ##\ \sqrt{x^2\,}=|x| \ ## and not ##\ x\ .\ ## This is often surprising to students. So, the square root of a squared number is not necessarily the number itself.

- #12

pwsnafu

Science Advisor

- 1,080

- 85

"Find the square root of 25" and "Find all numbersBut [itex] z^{2}=25\Leftrightarrow z^{2}-25=0 \Leftrightarrow (z+5)\cdot (z-5)=0[/itex]...

Share: