Finding atomic diameter from molecular diffusion proportionality

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
4 replies · 2K views
ProPatto16
Messages
323
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Find the diameter of one atom of argon given that Dp = 2 where D is diffusion and p is pressure.

The Attempt at a Solution



molar mass of argon is 40g/mol
using that for one atom can find mass in kgs.
but that's its!

im not given V, T or p. can put V in terms of d so that gives me one. need 2 so i can solve for the last one.

the relevant equation seems to be
$$Dp=\frac{1}{\pi d^3\sqrt{m}}(\frac{2kT}{\pi})^\frac{3}{2}$$

good luck finding d.
 
on Phys.org
The diffusion constant has units m^2/s, pressure has units N/m^2 = kg /(m s^2). The product of both cannot be a dimensionless number ("2").
I think there is something missing here.

Unrelated: if you just need T, room temperature is a good value.
 
It's not a constant. Diffusion D and pressure p are inversely proportional. The info I'm given is as pressure increases the product of diffusion and pressure is 2. So the 2 is the x in D=x/p hence dimensionless. I'm fairly sure that this means T is constant.
Sorry probably a poor worded question.
Given a figure of a graph of Dp vs p for argon and it's a line parallel to x-axis with the value 2.
Question says find diameter of argon. So I don't have particular values for p and D either...
 
Hmm but I see what you mean... It still needs units... But even then with units it won't make a difference.

And I think there's something missing too.

And I actually have the answer as d=3.1*10^-10m out of the book but that corresponds to a T of about 330K
but there's no way to find T with the info given..
 
ProPatto16 said:

Homework Statement



Find the diameter of one atom of argon given that Dp = 2 where D is diffusion and p is pressure.
Is that the full, exact problem statement?
If yes, I think you really have to assume that it happens at room temperature, and I still doubt that the units match.