Finding Constant A for Independent Electric Field between Two Spheres

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
yoni162
Messages
16
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


We have a sphere with radius b, within that sphere there's another sphere with radius a. Between the two spheres we have an electric charge with density A/r. Also, we have a charge Q in the center. We need to find the constant A so that the field between a and b is independent of r (meaning, it's constant for a<=r<=b).


Homework Equations


Gauss' law.



The Attempt at a Solution


I added the scanned pages I've written, it should be understandable. As I said, I used Gauss' law to calculate the field, using a sphere with radius r (a<=r<=b) to calculate the electric flux. After finding the electric field as a function of r, I calculated d(E(r))/dr and demanded that it would be=0, but I can't seem to get a solution for A that's independent of r.
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of concentric spheres: a small blue point charge labelled Q at the centre, an inner white sphere of radius a and a shaded blue outer shell out to radius b, with arrows marking the radii a and b.
    charge_between_two_spheres.png
    6.9 KB · Views: 495
  • Handwritten derivation applying Gauss's law to a spherical charge distribution, with the Hebrew label 5 and the integral of E dot dA equal to Q_in over epsilon zero, followed by E(r) times 4 pi r squared and Q_in = (A/r)[(4/3)pi r^3 - (4/3)pi a^3] + Q.
    001.jpg
    10.3 KB · Views: 398
  • Handwritten derivation applying Gauss's law: E(r)·4πr² = 4πA/(3rε₀)(r³ − a³) + Q/ε₀, then E(r) = A(r³ − a³)/(3r³ε₀) + Q/(4πε₀r²), expanded into terms, and E′(r) = 0 set up as −Aa³/(3ε₀)·(−3/r⁴) + Q/(4πε₀)·(−2/r³) = 0.
    002.jpg
    13.3 KB · Views: 405
In your work, you had

[tex]Qin = \frac{A}{r} \left[ \frac{4}{3}\pi r^3 - \frac{4}{3}\pi a^3 \right] + Q[/tex]

That's not right. You're going to need to re-evaluate the volume integral. The [tex](4/3)\pi r^3[/tex] terms only makes sense if the charge distribution is uniformly distributed about the sphere. You can't just multiply them by A/r. It doesn't work that way. You'll have to re-do the volume integral, integrating A/r' from r' = a to r in spherical coordinates (be careful to use the correct volume differential when performing the integral -- it's not simply dr') .

Once you have an expression for the electric field, E, don't worry about taking the derivative. Instead, find the electric field at r = a, and call that Ea. Then find Eb, the electric field at r = b. Set Ea and Eb equal to each other and solve for A.
 
collinsmark said:
In your work, you had

[tex]Qin = \frac{A}{r} \left[ \frac{4}{3}\pi r^3 - \frac{4}{3}\pi a^3 \right] + Q[/tex]

That's not right. You're going to need to re-evaluate the volume integral. The [tex](4/3)\pi r^3[/tex] terms only makes sense if the charge distribution is uniformly distributed about the sphere. You can't just multiply them by A/r. It doesn't work that way. You'll have to re-do the volume integral, integrating A/r' from r' = a to r in spherical coordinates (be careful to use the correct volume differential when performing the integral -- it's not simply dr') .

Once you have an expression for the electric field, E, don't worry about taking the derivative. Instead, find the electric field at r = a, and call that Ea. Then find Eb, the electric field at r = b. Set Ea and Eb equal to each other and solve for A.

How did I not notice that..thanks, that solved it.