Finding Hydrogen eigenfunction u(2,0)

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
unscientific
Messages
1,728
Reaction score
13
Taken from Physics of Quantum Mechanics, by James Binney.

Textbook page excerpt: text introducing dimensionless ladder operator A_l = (a0/sqrt2)(i/hbar p_r - (l+1)/r + Z/((l+1)a0)), equation (8.13a), and section 8.1.2 Radial eigenfunctions.


I try to calculate ##u_{n}^{l=n-2}##, something goes wrong:

Starting, we define operator A by:

[tex]A_{n-2} = \frac{a_0}{\sqrt 2}\left(\frac{i}{\hbar}p_r + \frac{1-n}{r} + \frac{Z}{(n-1)a_0}\right)[/tex]

Substituting ##p_r = -i\hbar (\frac{\partial}{\partial r} + \frac{1}{r})##:

[tex]A_{n-2} = \frac{a_0}{\sqrt 2}\left( \frac{\partial}{\partial r} + \frac{2-n}{r} + \frac{Z}{(n-1)a_0}\right)[/tex]

Thus, we want to solve:

[tex]\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial r} + \frac{2-n}{r} + \frac{Z}{(n-1)a_0} \right) u_{n}^{l=n-2} = 0[/tex]

Solving by integrating factor method, we obtain:

[tex]u_n^{l=n-2} = A r^{n-2} e^{\frac{Z}{(n-1)a_0}r}[/tex]

Normalizing,

[tex]u_n^{l=n-2} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{[2(n-1)]!}} \left(\frac{2Z}{(n-1)a_0}\right)^{\frac{3}{2}} \left(\frac{2Z}{(n-1)a_0}\right)^{n-2} e^{-\frac{Z}{(n-1)a_0}r}[/tex]

This is similar to ##u_n^{l=n-1}##, simply replace n by n-1:

Equation (8.28): normalised hydrogen radial wavefunction u^(n-1)_n(r) = [1 / sqrt((2n)!)] (2Z/(n a0))^(3/2) (2Zr/(n a0))^(n-1) e^(-Zr/(n a0)).


But when I substitute n = 2, so l = 0, I get ##u_2^0 = \frac{1}{\sqrt 2} \left(\frac{2Z}{a_0}\right)^{\frac{3}{2}} e^{-\frac{Z}{a_0}r}##

I get a completely different result from the book:

Table 8.1 of radial eigenfunctions u_n^l(r) for hydrogen with a_Z = a_0/Z, for n = 1 to 3 (columns) and l = 0 to 2 (rows), written as fractions of exponentials and powers of r; for example, n=2, l=0 is 2e^(-r/2a_Z) over (2a_Z)^(3/2) times (1 - r/(2a_Z)).


I'm not sure what's wrong with my derivation?
 
The copy of Binney I'm looking at is slightly different from yours, so bear with me, but the equation you're trying to use,

An-1|n, n-1> = 0

is only for (as he says) "the radial wavefunction of the circular orbit with angular momentum ℓ = n - 1." That is, it gives the wavefunctions along the diagonal in Table 8.1. To get the other wavefunctions you need to start with one of these wavefunctions and one or more times apply A†. This will step you up in the table, along one of the columns.

"Applications of A† should generate the wavefunctions for ℓ < n - 1."
 
Bill_K said:
The copy of Binney I'm looking at is slightly different from yours, so bear with me, but the equation you're trying to use,

An-1|n, n-1> = 0

is only for (as he says) "the radial wavefunction of the circular orbit with angular momentum ℓ = n - 1." That is, it gives the wavefunctions along the diagonal in Table 8.1. To get the other wavefunctions you need to start with one of these wavefunctions and one or more times apply A†. This will step you up in the table, along one of the columns.

"Applications of A† should generate the wavefunctions for ℓ < n - 1."

Ah, so by applying A† to ##u_n^{l=n-1}## it will give ##u_n^{l=n-2}##?
 
unscientific said:
Ah, so by applying A† to ##u_n^{l=n-1}## it will give ##u_n^{l=n-2}##?
That's my understanding. Try it and see!
 
Bill_K said:
That's my understanding. Try it and see!

It's mentioned right below the screenshot, I can't believe I missed it..

I tried it, and normalized and it came out right!