Finding n for Constant*s^n: Homework Help

  • Thread starter Thread starter raphile
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Homework
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
3 replies · 2K views
raphile
Messages
23
Reaction score
0
Hey, I suspect that this is probably quite simple, but I'm a bit stuck on it, or the 2nd part at least.

Homework Statement



The displacement s of a particle moving in a straight line as a function of time t is given by s^3 = t. Find the value of n if at any time t:

constant * s^n

represents: (i) the speed of the particle; (ii) the force acting on the particle.

The Attempt at a Solution



For (i), I tried to derive a differential equation by writing:

ds/dt = k*s^n (where k is constant)
=> ds = k*t^(n/3) dt

By integrating both sides:
s = [k/((n/3)+1)] t^((n/3)+1) + c

I then hypothesised that we wanted ((n/3)+1) to be 1/3, because s=t^(1/3).
Hence, n = -2 is my answer. Is it right, or am I off-track?

For part (ii), I don't know. I know we can write force = mass * acceleration, hence F = m*s'' (s differentiated twice) but that doesn't seem to give me an equation I can solve. I know acceleration can be written in other ways, so should I write it as dv/dt or possibly v*dv/ds?

Thanks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
As for the first answer, your approach should lead you to the correct answer, but isn't. Check your solution again.

A better solution would be to write a function like:

[tex] s = t^\frac{1}{3}[/tex]

and then differentiate it. The thing is, you won't have to deal with Differential Equations at all. You can differentiate it once and twice giving the answer to your questions.
 
Thanks, but using that method, I still get n = -2. Here's what I did:

Start with s=t^(1/3)
Differentiate: ds/dt = (1/3)t^(-2/3)

We want speed to be k*s^n and k*s^n = k*t^(n/3) because s=t^(1/3), hence:

k*t^(n/3) = (1/3)t^(-2/3)
=> So we have n/3 = -2/3 => n = -2.

I also tried differentiating a second time to get the second part as you suggested:

d2s/dt2 = (-2/9)t^(-5/3)

We want force (= mass * acceleration) to be k*s^n, hence:

k*s^n = k*t^(n/3) = (-2m/9)t^(-5/3)
=> So we have n/3 = -5/3 => n = -5.

Where am I going wrong?
 
As for the first question, n = -2 is the correct answer. I got confused thinking that v = kt^n rather than v = ks^n. Sorry 'bout that.

And yes, n = -5 is the right answer too.