Finding the Complement of a Set

  • Thread starter Thread starter Keen94
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Set
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
2 replies · 1K views
Keen94
Messages
41
Reaction score
1
1. Find P'={x I ~px} for the given open sentences px.
#25. x2≥4.
(Problem from 1.10, Principles of Mathematics by Allendoerfer and Oakley.
Solution offered at the back of the book: {x I -4<x<4}.

Homework Equations


If P={x∈ℝ I px} then P'={x∈ℝ I ~px}[/B]

The Attempt at a Solution


x2≥4 ⇒ x≤-2 or x≥2.
P={x∈ℝ I x≤-2 or x≥2}. P'={x∈ℝ I -2<x<2}[/B]
The original proposition is true when a number is equal to or less than -2. It is equally true when it is equal to or greater than 2. If we negate the proposition then the elements of this set will be the ones not found in the original set. This leaves the interval (-2,2). I don't understand why the interval would be (-4,4) as the solution found at the back of the book suggests. BTW First Post!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Keen94 said:
1. Find P'={x I ~px} for the given open sentences px.
#25. x2≥4.
(Problem from 1.10, Principles of Mathematics by Allendoerfer and Oakley.
Solution offered at the back of the book: {x I -4<x<4}.

Homework Equations


If P={x∈ℝ I px} then P'={x∈ℝ I ~px}[/B]

The Attempt at a Solution


x2≥4 ⇒ x≤-2 or x≥2.
P={x∈ℝ I x≤-2 or x≥2}. P'={x∈ℝ I -2<x<2}[/B]
The original proposition is true when a number is equal to or less than -2. It is equally true when it is equal to or greater than 2. If we negate the proposition then the elements of this set will be the ones not found in the original set. This leaves the interval (-2,2). I don't understand why the interval would be (-4,4) as the solution found at the back of the book suggests. BTW First Post!
Hello Keen94. Welcome to PF !

The book must have a typo. Your analysis is correct !
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Keen94
SammyS said:
Hello Keen94. Welcome to PF !

The book must have a typo. Your analysis is correct !
Thank you for the speedy reply!