Finding the correct angle for stress transformation equations

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Start your own thread to ask a follow-up.
8 replies · 4K views · last reply
stpmmaths
Messages
28
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Free-body diagram of a square stress element with x and y axes, a 100 MPa force on the right face, 80 MPa on the top, 45 MPa shear on the top and bottom, and a dashed section line a-a at 60 degrees to the x-axis.


Homework Equations



Three stress transformation equations: sigma x' = (sigma x + sigma y)/2 + (sigma x - sigma y)/2 cos 2 theta + tau xy sin 2 theta; sigma y' = (sigma x + sigma y)/2 - (sigma x - sigma y)/2 cos 2 theta - tau xy sin 2 theta; tau x'y' = -(sigma x - sigma y)/2 sin 2 theta + tau xy cos 2 theta.


The Attempt at a Solution



I'm in doubt the angle that I should be using to solve σx' and Tx'y'. Is 60 degree or -30 degree?
Ps: I know how to determine the principal stresses and max shear. Just the angle that I'm in doubt at.

60
Calculator interface with inputs: normal stress sx 100 MPa, normal stress sy -80, shear stress txy 45, coordinate rotation q 60 deg; answers: new normal stress sx' 3.97 MPa, sy' 16.0 MPa, new shear stress tx'y' -100 MPa.


-30
Calculator screenshot with inputs Normal Stress sx 100 MPa, sy -80, Shear Stress txy 45, Coordinate Rotation q -30 deg, and answers New Normal Stress sx' 16.0 MPa, sy' 3.97 MPa, New Shear Stress tx'y' 100 MPa.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
nvn said:
60 deg

Why is it 60 deg but not -30 deg?

And how you see whether the line a-a is going to be the new x or y-axis?
 
Last edited:
stpmmaths: A plane is defined by its normal vector. The axis normal to the new plane is always x'. We see +x' is +60 deg from the +x axis. Theta is the angle measured from the +x axis to the +x' axis. The y' axis is parallel to line a-a. The +y' axis is +150 deg from the +x axis.
 
nvn said:
stpmmaths: A plane is defined by its normal vector. The axis normal to the new plane is always x'. We see +x' is +60 deg from the +x axis. Theta is the angle measured from the +x axis to the +x' axis. The y' axis is parallel to line a-a. The +y' axis is +150 deg from the +x axis.

So if the question is
Free-body diagram of a square stress element with x and y axes; 80 MPa compressive normal stress on top, 100 MPa tensile stress on the right, 45 MPa shear stress on the top face, and a dashed cutting plane at 60 degrees to the x-axis.


The angle I will be using is 120 or -60 deg, right?
 
stpmmaths: Yes, 120 deg. Also try -60 deg, and see if it gives the same answer. If it gives the same answer, you can use either 120 deg or -60 deg.
 
nvn said:
stpmmaths: Yes, 120 deg. Also try -60 deg, and see if it gives the same answer. If it gives the same answer, you can use either 120 deg or -60 deg.

Thanks a lot! :D

Yup it gives the same answers.