Finding the eigenvalues of a 3x3 matrix

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around finding the eigenvalues of a 3x3 matrix, specifically the matrix A given as: 7 -5 0 -5 7 0 0 0 -6. The original poster expresses difficulty in obtaining the correct eigenvalues, which they believe to be 12, 2, and -6, after attempting to calculate the determinant.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Mathematical reasoning, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the calculation of the determinant and the resulting cubic equation. There are requests for the original poster to show their cubic equation after algebraic manipulation. Some participants suggest that there may be arithmetic errors in the calculations and encourage checking the polynomial again.

Discussion Status

The discussion is ongoing, with participants providing guidance on simplifying the determinant calculation and factoring techniques. There is a recognition of potential arithmetic errors, and suggestions are made for alternative methods to solve the cubic equation. Multiple interpretations of the calculations are being explored.

Contextual Notes

Participants note that the original poster is under exam conditions where calculators are not allowed, which adds a constraint to their problem-solving approach. There is also mention of the need to manipulate the determinant matrix to find the eigenvalues.

uzman1243
Messages
80
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


A =
7 -5 0
-5 7 0
0 0 -6

Can you please show your method aswell. Every time I try I get the wrong answer.

FYI Eigen values are 12.2,-6

The Attempt at a Solution


so far I got:
det =
7-λ -5 0
-5 7-λ 0
0 0 -6-λ

Im unsure what to do next. I tried doing this
(7-λ) [(7-λ)*(-6-λ)] - (-5)(-5(-6-λ)) + 0 = 0
but when I expand and get a cubic equation and solve it, i don't get the right answer which is 12,2,-6
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Show us your cubic equation in λ after you have done the algebra and collected all the terms. You may have made a mistake in your calculations.
 
SteamKing said:
Show us your cubic equation in λ after you have done the algebra and collected all the terms. You may have made a mistake in your calculations.

continuing from (7-λ) [(7-λ)*(-6-λ)] - (-5)(-5(-6-λ)) + 0 = 0


(7-λ) [(7-λ)*(-6-λ)] + 5 (30+5λ) = 0
(7-λ) [(7-λ)*(-6-λ)] +150 + 25λ = 0
(7-λ) [-42-λ+λ^2] + 150 + 25λ = 0

294 - 7λ + 7λ^2 + 42λ + λ^2 - λ^3 + 150 +25λ = 0

444 + 60λ +8λ^2 - λ^3 = 0

So i checked that with the calculator and the answer is completely off.
Also in my first semester exam we aren't allowed to use the calc. so i need to find another way to solve the cubic equation OR instead do some sort of manipulation of the initial det matrix and get the answer from there.

Any ideas?
and thank you
 
uzman1243 said:
continuing from (7-λ) [(7-λ)*(-6-λ)] - (-5)(-5(-6-λ)) + 0 = 0


(7-λ) [(7-λ)*(-6-λ)] + 5 (30+5λ) = 0
(7-λ) [(7-λ)*(-6-λ)] +150 + 25λ = 0
(7-λ) [-42-λ+λ^2] + 150 + 25λ = 0

294 - 7λ + 7λ^2 + 42λ + λ^2 - λ^3 + 150 +25λ = 0

444 + 60λ +8λ^2 - λ^3 = 0

So i checked that with the calculator and the answer is completely off.
Also in my first semester exam we aren't allowed to use the calc. so i need to find another way to solve the cubic equation OR instead do some sort of manipulation of the initial det matrix and get the answer from there.

Any ideas?
and thank you

Looks to me like you should have:

-144 + 60λ +8λ^2 - λ^3 = 0
 
uzman1243 said:
continuing from (7-λ) [(7-λ)*(-6-λ)] - (-5)(-5(-6-λ)) + 0 = 0


(7-λ) [(7-λ)*(-6-λ)] + 5 (30+5λ) = 0
(7-λ) [(7-λ)*(-6-λ)] +150 + 25λ = 0
(7-λ) [-42-λ+λ^2] + 150 + 25λ = 0

294 - 7λ + 7λ^2 + 42λ + λ^2 - λ^3 + 150 +25λ = 0

444 + 60λ +8λ^2 - λ^3 = 0

So i checked that with the calculator and the answer is completely off.
Also in my first semester exam we aren't allowed to use the calc. so i need to find another way to solve the cubic equation OR instead do some sort of manipulation of the initial det matrix and get the answer from there.

Any ideas?
and thank you

Check your cubic polynomial again. You have an arithmetic error in calculating the constant term.

Here's a tip: when you have something like (7-λ)(7-λ)(-6-λ), evaluate the two identical terms first (7-λ)(7-λ) = 49 - 14λ + λ^{2}, since you should be able to write the square of a monomial by doing a mental calculation.

Alternately, when you want to calculate the determinant of a matrix with several zeroes in a single row or column, like the matrix in this problem, using minors might save you considerable calculation.

In any event, when you obtain the proper cubic characteristic equation, you can use several different methods to find the solutions: you can guess a solution, you can use the rational root theorem, or you can plot the equation.
 
uzman1243 said:
continuing from (7-λ) [(7-λ)*(-6-λ)] - (-5)(-5(-6-λ)) + 0 = 0

The factor (-6-λ) is in both terms. So you can simplify this to
[ (7-λ)(7-λ) - (-5)(-5) ] (-6-λ) = 0
and save a lot of work.

And (7-λ)(7-λ) - (-5)(-5) is of the form ##a^2 - b^2##, so you should be able to factorize it without multiplying everything out.
 
The Electrician said:
Looks to me like you should have:

-144 + 60λ +8λ^2 - λ^3 = 0

Oh yeah. But sill I used the values you got and I checked with an online cubic calculator, and this is what I got

attachment.php?attachmentid=68174&stc=1&d=1396247658.png


The answer is quite close. x1 should be 12 and x2 should be -6.

can you explain why this is so??
 

Attachments

  • Untitled.png
    Untitled.png
    7.1 KB · Views: 621
AlephZero said:
The factor (-6-λ) is in both terms. So you can simplify this to
[ (7-λ)(7-λ) - (-5)(-5) ] (-6-λ) = 0
and save a lot of work.

And (7-λ)(7-λ) - (-5)(-5) is of the form ##a^2 - b^2##, so you should be able to factorize it without multiplying everything out.

That is awesome. But i don't get how you were able to factorize it WITHOUT multiplying it out?
 
AlephZero said:
And (7-λ)(7-λ) - (-5)(-5) is of the form ##a^2 - b^2##, so you should be able to factorize it without multiplying everything out.

uzman1243 said:
That is awesome. But i don't get how you were able to factorize it WITHOUT multiplying it out?
AlephZero explained where the factorization comes from. If a = 7 - λ and b = -5, then (7-λ)(7-λ) - (-5)(-5) = a2 - b2, so you can factor it as (a - b)(a + b) or as (7 - λ - (-5))(7 - λ + (-5)).
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: 1 person

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
11K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 12 ·
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K