Finding value of unknown charge

  • Thread starter member 731016
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Charge Value
2 replies · 2K views · last reply
member 731016
Homework Statement
Please see below
Relevant Equations
Please see below
For this problem,
Text of problem 18: two charged particles on the x axis, a charge +Q at x = -a and an unknown charge at x = +3a; the net field at the origin has magnitude 2k_eQ/a^2. Asks how many values the unknown charge can take and what they are.

The solution is,
Handwritten-style solution to an electric field problem: a field at the origin from charge +Q at x=0 and unknown charge q at x=3a, with equations k_eQ/a^2 and 2k_eQ/a^2, concluding q = -9Q or q = +27Q.

However, why did they assume that the electric field produced by charge q is always pointing to the left at the origin?

Many thanks!
 
Callumnc1 said:
Homework Statement:: Please see below
Relevant Equations:: Please see below

For this problem,
View attachment 320613
The solution is,
View attachment 320612
However, why did they assume that the electric field produced by charge q is always pointing to the left at the origin?

Many thanks!
They are not assuming that the electric field is pointing to the left.

Think about it.

If ##q## is a positive charge, then indeed, the electric field at the origin, due to ##q##, is to the left (negative).

What if ##q## is negative? Then you have a negative number multiplied by a negative number. In what direction is the electric field, due to ##q##, pointing in this case?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: member 731016
SammyS said:
They are not assuming that the electric field is pointing to the left.

Think about it.

If ##q## is a positive charge, then indeed, the electric field at the origin, due to ##q##, is to the left (negative).

What if ##q## is negative? Then you have a negative number multiplied by a negative number. In what direction is the electric field, due to ##q##, pointing in this case?
Thank you for your reply @SammyS !

If ##q## is negative, then the electric field due to the charge will be pointing to the right as a positive test charge would be attracted to the negative charge.