Fixed Variables in Partial Derivatives

Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
1 reply · 2K views
transmini
Messages
81
Reaction score
1
My physics book is showing an example of why it matters "what variable you hold fixed" when taking the partial derivative. So it asks to show that
##(\frac{\partial{w}}{\partial{x}})_{y} \neq (\frac{\partial{w}}{\partial{x}})_z##
where ##w=xy## and ##x=yz## and the subscripts are what variable is held fixed.

I'm just not sure what it means by holding a variable "fixed" since all other variables except the two in question are treated as constants, so why would it matter whether ##w## is a function of ##(x, y)## or a function of ##(x, z)##
I mean I see that the partial derivatives don't match up, but don't really see why the variables make a difference since they are the same function.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The condition ##x=yz## describes a surface in three dimensions. Now, you can use different sets of variables to parametrise this surface. One choice is to use x and y and another to use x and z. Varying x in the first parametrisation is generally going to give you a displacement in the surface that will be different from the one you obtain if you vary x in the same way in the second parametrisation. The "keeping these variables fixed" essentially tells you what parametrisation is used and therefore exactly what variations should be considered.