# Forces of gravity on protons and electrons

Homework Statement

1.Assuming that only gravity is acting on it, how far does an electron have to be from a proton so that its acceleration is the same as that of a freely falling object at the earth's surface

2.Suppose the earth were made only of protons but had the same size and mass it presently has. What would be the acceleration of an electron released at the surface?

3.Is it necessary to consider the gravitational attraction as well as the electrical force?
yes or no?

## The Attempt at a Solution

i have read through my chapter and none of the examples help me at all, I thought #1 could be zero but the online homework thing rejected that. I dont know if you could help me with the answer and also give a short explain why that would be greatly appreciated!! Thankyou!

Homework Statement

1.Assuming that only gravity is acting on it, how far does an electron have to be from a proton so that its acceleration is the same as that of a freely falling object at the earth's surface

2.Suppose the earth were made only of protons but had the same size and mass it presently has. What would be the acceleration of an electron released at the surface?

3.Is it necessary to consider the gravitational attraction as well as the electrical force?
yes or no?

## The Attempt at a Solution

i have read through my chapter and none of the examples help me at all, I thought #1 could be zero but the online homework thing rejected that. I dont know if you could help me with the answer and also give a short explain why that would be greatly appreciated!! Thankyou!

1) It's asking for when the acceleration = 9.81 m/s^2. You know about F = ma, right? This applies to all forces, including electrical ones. Mass, acceleration, and the two charges are known (proton's charge = electron's charge). Using what two formulas will give you everything but the distance (which can be easily solved for)?

2) First, find the number of protons that can make up Earth. There will be a total charge here. The net force ( F = ma) will be the sum of TWO force vectors in the same direction, the eletrical force and the gravitational force. The distance in your equations will be the radius of the earth.

3) Think. Everything with a charge has an electrical field. Everything with mass has a gravitational field.

Dick
Homework Helper
You need to get some equations and show us an attempt. For example, the force between two charges is F=k*q1*q2/r^2, F=ma, the acceleration at the earth's surface is 9.8*m/s^2. Try and put those together to answer the first one.

for the first one I used f=ma and f=(Gm1m2)/r^2, im pretty sure the masses could be assumed they are close to zero so the answer would be 1?

for the first one I used f=ma and f=(Gm1m2)/r^2, im pretty sure the masses could be assumed they are close to zero so the answer would be 1?

nevermind its wrong let me try again

for the first one I used f=ma and f=(Gm1m2)/r^2, im pretty sure the masses could be assumed they are close to zero so the answer would be 1?

You assume the net force (m*a) is only comprised of the gravitational force. What other force could possible contribute to a nonzero net force?

And zero divided by anything is always zero, so 1 would still be wrong.

Dick
Homework Helper
F=G*m1*m2/r^2 is the force due to gravity. You want the force due to the electric charge. And you do need to know the masses of the electron and proton. You can't assume them away because they are small. Better look them up.

You assume the net force (m*a) is only comprised of the gravitational force. What other force could possible contribute to a nonzero net force?

And zero divided by anything is always zero, so 1 would still be wrong.

so would I do.... Fe +Fg = ma? and solve from there?

Dick
Homework Helper
so would I do.... Fe +Fg = ma? and solve from there?

You could. But the force due to gravity is completely insignificant compared with the electrical force. You should check this but ignore it for now.

You could. But the force due to gravity is completely insignificant compared with the electrical force. You should check this but ignore it for now.

ok but with the electrical force they dont list either of the charge values, do I need them or are they the same value, ect???

Dick
Homework Helper
ok but with the electrical force they dont list either of the charge values, do I need them or are they the same value, ect???

If they don't list them then you'll need to look them up. They are both the same but with opposite signs.

With my online system, the website provides the constants that it wants us to use. Check to see if your system already has the constants just in case you use a number too exact or rounded (mine was in the Help section).

i did....

(k*q1*q2)/(m*9.8) = r^2

still couldnt find the answer but is this the right direction it it f=ma and fe together, big thing also is you can take a negative square root... i am to confused

What's wrong with that equation? In this case, positive and negative charges mean nothing, so don't make the force negative.

Dick
Homework Helper
Ignore the sign. That just tells you which direction the force is acting. It doesn't affect the magnitude of the acceleration. Take the square root of the magnitude.

i did....

(k*q1*q2)/(m*9.8) = r^2

still couldnt find the answer but is this the right direction it it f=ma and fe together, big thing also is you can take a negative square root... i am to confused

ok still isnt working... one thing for the mass, do i add both the mass of the electron and proton together for m cause that is what I am doing and is the only thing I can think of that Im doing wrong.

No, only the mass of the electron needs to be calculated.

However, maybe the system is so exact as to want you to factor in the force of gravity? I'm not sure how much it will affect your answer (if at all), so maybe you will have to use Fe + Fg = ma.

No, only the mass of the electron needs to be calculated.

However, maybe the system is so exact as to want you to factor in the force of gravity? I'm not sure how much it will affect your answer (if at all), so maybe you will have to use Fe + Fg = ma.

nope did that this online system(my hw site not this site) is jacked up, Thanks all for helping though

Dick
Homework Helper
nope did that this online system(my hw site not this site) is jacked up, Thanks all for helping though

Fg would only affect your answer if you were carrying the results out to about 40 decimal places. Hope your hw site feels better soon.

hi,1st post ..i m learning too

izzit by taking the nett forces?
Fg + Fe = ma

i.e

Gm1m2/r^2 + Q1Q2/4(pi)(epsilon zero)r^2 = ma

epsilon zero = permittivity of vacuum

Dick
Homework Helper
hi,1st post ..i m learning too

izzit by taking the nett forces?
Fg + Fe = ma

i.e

Gm1m2/r^2 + Q1Q2/4(pi)(epsilon zero)r^2 = ma

epsilon zero = permittivity of vacuum

Sure, but the first term is so much smaller than the second, it's ridiculous. Drop it.

gabbagabbahey
Homework Helper
Gold Member
F=G*m1*m2/r^2 is the force due to gravity. You want the force due to the electric charge. And you do need to know the masses of the electron and proton. You can't assume them away because they are small. Better look them up.

That's not what I got out of the original problem statement:

1.Assuming that only gravity is acting on it, how far does an electron have to be from a proton so that its acceleration is the same as that of a freely falling object at the earth's surface Dick
Homework Helper
That's not what I got out of the original problem statement: OOOOOOPS. Apparently my reading skills are even worse than my math skills. Thanks for catching that.

gabbagabbahey
Homework Helper
Gold Member
OOOOOOPS. Apparently my reading skills are even worse than my math skills. Thanks for catching that.

No worries m8; I make mistakes like that all the time 