Formulea in Heat and Thermodynamics

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around various problems in the context of Heat and Thermodynamics, including the change in internal energy during phase changes, the behavior of gases under different conditions, entropy changes in humans, and energy loss in electrical systems.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants explore the calculation of internal energy changes for a melting ice block and question the application of latent heat.
  • There is discussion on the change in internal energy and work done for argon gas under constant volume and pressure, with participants questioning the appropriate values for specific heat capacities.
  • One participant expresses uncertainty about calculating the rate of entropy change for a sedentary person and seeks guidance on relevant formulas.
  • Another participant examines the energy loss from a light bulb and questions the efficiency of power plants, leading to discussions about energy calculations and assumptions.

Discussion Status

Participants are actively engaging with each other's reasoning, offering corrections and clarifications. Some guidance has been provided regarding specific heat capacities and the interpretation of energy equations, but there remains a lack of consensus on certain calculations and assumptions.

Contextual Notes

Some participants note the absence of specific values, such as the heat capacities for the human body and the need for assumptions regarding ideal gas behavior. There is also mention of the complexities involved in calculating entropy changes and the implications of efficiency in energy systems.

Gamma
Messages
355
Reaction score
11
I have forgotten most of the formulea in Heat and Thermodynamics. I would appreciate if some one can check the following for me please.

1. A 2.2 Kg. block of ice melts to water at 0 degree celsius. By how much has the internal energy of the ice changed? Neglect the small change in volume.

Q = M L where L is the latent heat of water = 3.33810^5 J/Kg
Is this correct?

================================================
2. Suppose that 2.3 mol of argon gas is heated from -45 degrees to 90 degrees celsius. Find the change in internal energy of the gas and the work it does if the heating occurs at a.) constant volume and b.) constant pressure

At constant volume,
-------------------

work done, dW= p dV = 0

From first law of TD,
du = dq-w = dQ

This is how I found dQ.
dQ= M Cv (Tf - Ti) where M = number of moles * molecular weight of Ar.

I found in the internet Cv(Ar)= 12.5 J/K at 15 degree celsius & 1 atm.
Since Cv is a function of temperature, what value do I use for Cv in my problem?

For constant pressure
---------------------
From pv=nRT, I have work done, W = PdV = nR dT = nR (T2-T1)
To find the change in internal energy,
du = Q - W = M Cp (T2-T1) - nR (T2-T1)
I believe I can use Cp- Cv = R to find Cp.
===================================

3. An average adult person generally emits energy at the rate of approximately 105 W while sedentary. At what rate is the persons entropy changing?
No idea what formula to use. Any advise??

======================================
4. Suppose you leave a 100 W light bulb on continuously for 'h' hours. If the electricity generated and delivered by the power company to the bulb at 30% efficiency, how much thermal energy does the power plant exhaust to the environment due to you oversight?

Does this mean power plants loose 70% energy to the environment? :cry:
This is how I worked out this problem

Power * Time (in sec) * 70% = 180 MJ! This seems so unreal. Am I right

Thanks,

Regards,
GAmma.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
Gamma said:
I have forgotten most of the formulea in Heat and Thermodynamics. I would appreciate if some one can check the following for me please.

1. A 2.2 Kg. block of ice melts to water at 0 degree celsius. By how much has the internal energy of the ice changed? Neglect the small change in volume.

Q = M L where L is the latent heat of water = 3.33810^5 J/Kg
Is this correct?
That looks fine, but remember you're solving for delta U, which equals Q, not Q itself.
================================================
Gamma said:
2. Suppose that 2.3 mol of argon gas is heated from -45 degrees to 90 degrees celsius. Find the change in internal energy of the gas and the work it does if the heating occurs at a.) constant volume and b.) constant pressure

At constant volume,
-------------------

work done, dW= p dV = 0

From first law of TD,
du = dq-w = dQ

This is how I found dQ.
dQ= M Cv (Tf - Ti) where M = number of moles * molecular weight of Ar.

I found in the internet Cv(Ar)= 12.5 J/K at 15 degree celsius & 1 atm.
Since Cv is a function of temperature, what value do I use for Cv in my problem?
That seems right. Since you are dealing with argon, which is a monatomic gas that behves close to idealy, they may want you to assume c_v=3/2R. For a diatomic perfect gas this would be c_v=5/2R
Gamma said:
For constant pressure
---------------------
From pv=nRT, I have work done, W = PdV = nR dT = nR (T2-T1)
To find the change in internal energy,
du = Q - W = M Cp (T2-T1) - nR (T2-T1)
I believe I can use Cp- Cv = R to find Cp.
Alright, here you made a mistake. You have constant pressure and you want to integrate dW=PdV. You can just pull P outside the integral. You made an algebra mistake as well.

To find delta U you do not have to find Q and W separately.
du=c_vdT+(\frac{\partial U}{\partial v})dv
But the second term equals 0 for a perfect gas so you could just integrate
dU=Mc_vdT
You'll get the same answer.
===================================
Gamma said:
3. An average adult person generally emits energy at the rate of approximately 105 W while sedentary. At what rate is the persons entropy changing?
No idea what formula to use. Any advise??
There does not seem to be enough information to answer this question. I don't know what to tell you.
Gamma said:
======================================
4. Suppose you leave a 100 W light bulb on continuously for 'h' hours. If the electricity generated and delivered by the power company to the bulb at 30% efficiency, how much thermal energy does the power plant exhaust to the environment due to you oversight?

Does this mean power plants loose 70% energy to the environment? :cry:
This is how I worked out this problem

Power * Time (in sec) * 70% = 180 MJ! This seems so unreal. Am I right

Thanks,

Regards,
GAmma.
That last answer isn't right. If you are getting 100W at 30% efficiency then they must be sending 100/.3=300W. 70% of this is lost to heat, or 210W. Now just multiply by time and convert to seconds.
 
Last edited:
Thank You very much for your expert opinions.

Alright, here you made a mistake. You have constant pressure and you want to integrate dW=PdV. You can just pull P outside the integral. You made an algebra mistake as well.

I can't understand where the mistake is. Did you mean that I have to plug in P = nRT/V in the integrant? I did not do this since Volumes are not given. But initial and finalt temps are given.

dW = PdV
W = int(P dV) = int (nR dT) = nR (T2-T1).

Can you please point out where the algebra mistake is?

I am trying to understand your answer to constant volume problem. As I said before I have forgotten all the formulea.

Thank You.

gamma.
 
Gamma said:
Thank You very much for your expert opinions.
I can't understand where the mistake is. Did you mean that I have to plug in P = nRT/V in the integrant? I did not do this since Volumes are not given. But initial and finalt temps are given.

dW = PdV
W = int(P dV) = int (nR dT) = nR (T2-T1).

Can you please point out where the algebra mistake is?
I didn't notice that you switched between dV and dT- sorry that was my mistake.
Gamma said:
I am trying to understand your answer to constant volume problem. As I said before I have forgotten all the formulea.
These are just formulas. For an ideal monatomic gas:
c_v=\frac{3}{2}R; c_p=\frac{5}{2}R
For an ideal diatomic gas:
c_v=\frac{5}{2}R; c_p=\frac{7}{2}R
 
For the 3rd question, I figured the following.

Rate of energy emitted by an average man is given. ie. dQ/dt.

Can I do this?

dQ = M Cv (T2 - T1)

T2 = dQ/ MCv + T1 --------------(1)

where M is the average man's mass and I would take
T1 as his body temparature at normal conditions (~ 32 +273 K)

Assuming constant volume, dQ = Cv dT = T dS

ie. Cv dT = T dS

Intergrating both side,

delta(S) = Cv ln (T2/T1)

Knowing T2 and T1, one can therefore find delta(S)

What is Cv for a human?Does this look stupid way of solving the problem?
 
Gamma said:
For the 3rd question, I figured the following.

Rate of energy emitted by an average man is given. ie. dQ/dt.

Can I do this?

dQ = M Cv (T2 - T1)
Actually you can't do this. Q is not a state function. Imagine you had a container that was thermally isolated from the surroundings so that Q=0. A chemical reation could still go on that would raise the temperature of the system.
Gamma said:
Assuming constant volume, dQ = Cv dT = T dS
You can't always write that dQ=TdS. Remember that the definition of entropy was
dS=\frac{dQ_{rev}}{T}
Specifying the reversible path is very important. But I think you may be on to something with this. If the temperature of the surroundings is the same as the temperature of the bidy then the heating is reversible. Now, it appears that we are assuming the rate of heat transfer to be independent of the temperature, so the Q=Q_rev. This means that we can use the equaiton you gave. Just divide by dt (where t is time) to get the answer.
 

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
7K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
6K
  • · Replies 40 ·
2
Replies
40
Views
5K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
5K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K