Freshwater (industrial scale) from seawater, on sunlight

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the concept of producing freshwater from seawater using solar energy, specifically focusing on a proposed method involving off-the-shelf components. Participants explore the feasibility of this idea for agricultural and other uses, while addressing various engineering challenges and historical context.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant proposes a method using PVC tubing to preheat seawater and evaporation chambers made from black plastic funnels to produce freshwater.
  • Another participant highlights that the idea is not new and points out significant technical challenges, including corrosion and saltwater residue management.
  • Some participants request a detailed list of technical challenges, expressing belief in the potential of the idea despite its historical context.
  • Concerns are raised about the costs associated with implementing solutions to the identified challenges, suggesting that while solutions exist, they may not be economically viable for large-scale applications.
  • Historical references are made to past solar distillation methods and their long-standing use, indicating that the concept has been tested over time.
  • One participant mentions alternative methods, such as using tides to replace pumps, but notes the limitations this imposes on location.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a mix of agreement on the potential of the idea and disagreement regarding its practicality and the challenges involved. There is no consensus on the feasibility of the proposed method or the best way to address the technical challenges.

Contextual Notes

Participants note various unresolved technical challenges, including corrosion, saltwater residue management, and pumping seawater. The discussion reflects a range of assumptions about the economic viability of solutions and the historical context of solar desalination methods.

ReneVeerman
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
i have this idea to produce fresh water for farming and all the other uses of fresh water, from seawater, on sunlight, using mostly/only off-the-shelf parts..

i am currently not able to pursue this idea myself due to financial constraints, so i thought i'd float the idea here looking for some constructive feedback.. I'm also not a mechanical engineer, i have studied software engineering, so i have a couple of specific hurdles with the engineering that i'd like your feedback on..

it starts with pvc tubing bringing seawater to a desert/climatically-hot area.. the pvc tubing does not need to be raised above ground level but rather be just laid on the ground to preheat the seawater.
at the conversion site, you'd have multiple evaporation chambers made out of black plastic funnels, one normally upright beneath one inverted (so narrow part pointing straight up) and tied together using black ducktape perhaps.

problem 1 is maintaining a stable water level in the lower (upright, narrow part of the funnel pointing down) funnels, and bringing new seawater to those lower funnels over terrain that varies in height as well (potentially for several miles)..

problem 2 is the condensation of vaporized freshwater from the 2-funnels devices back into liquid form for transportation to a farming area (which is suspect are pentiful), any area that could be farmed if it would receive a stable freshwater supply..

this idea is copylefted and donated to humanity by me. you are free to implement it entirely on your own and perhaps even turn it into a business where you take a modest percentage of revenue (the food output) to make the thing economically sustainable and interesting-to-scale-up..
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
ReneVeerman said:
this idea is copylefted and donated to humanity by me.
No, this idea is over 100 years old, probably over 1000. And there are various technical challenges which don't make it practical on an industrial scale in most places.

Corrosion is a huge issue, how to get rid of the salt water residue is one, how to pump seawater into the system is one, ...
 
Please list all the technical challenges in as detailed a manner as you can, ok.
I believe this idea to be worth the effort of making it work.
 
ReneVeerman said:
Please list all the technical challenges in as detailed a manner as you can, ok.
Various publications and reports did that, you can check those.
ReneVeerman said:
I believe this idea to be worth the effort of making it work.
Do you really think such a simple and obvious idea would not have been tested many times? There are not many systems around using it. What does that tell you?
 
mfb said:
...probably over 1000

Yup.
per wiki
Solar desalination
History
Methods of solar distillation have been employed by humankind for thousands of years. From early Greek mariners to Persian alchemists, this basic technology has been utilized to produce both freshwater and medicinal distillates. Solar stills were in fact the first method used on a large scale to process contaminated water and convert it to a potable form.
In 1870 the first US patent was granted for a solar distillation device to Norman Wheeler and Walton Evans. Two years later in Las Salinas, Chile, Charles Wilson, a Swedish engineer, began building a direct method solar powered distillation plant to supply freshwater to workers at a saltpeter and silver mine. It operated continuously for 40 years and produced an average of 22.7 m3 of distilled water a day using the effluent from mining operations as its feed water.

ReneVeerman said:
Please list all the technical challenges in as detailed a manner as you can, ok.
"detailed"? Ummmm... no.
Wiki lists a couple of problems: Problems with Thermal Systems

mfb said:
Corrosion is a huge issue
Plastic pipe:
Eliminating Corrosion
GF Piping Systems was called in as a possible source to supply a solution to the plant’s saltwater corrosion problem. GF recommended polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) and polyethylene (PE) piping systems as the solutions for eliminating the saltwater corrosion. These thermoplastics are highly resistant to salt solutions...
, how to get rid of the salt water residue is one,
Harvest the salt!
how to pump seawater into the system is one
Find a manufacturer who specializes in seawater pumps: Warren

When in doubt, let someone else solve your problem.
 
@OmCheeto: There are solutions to all those issues, sure, but they all increase the costs.
 
thanks for the details provided.. i'll certainly look into them within a week and possibly continue this thread
 
mfb said:
@OmCheeto: There are solutions to all those issues, sure, but they all increase the costs.
Well, the title includes the phrase "industrial scale", so I figured money was no object.
But, as my second reference points out; "The project never received enough funding, and the company was declared insolvent in 2014."
So, yes. Costs are important.
I think we covered some cost cutting measures in Ivan's "Algae to the rescue" thread.
I believe I mentioned that tides can replace pumps. But that somewhat limits the location.
As I responded

OmCheeto said:
"detailed"? Ummmm... no.

There are a billion and one "technical challenges". Ain't nobody got time for that.

And since this isn't a local problem
Om said:
Fact #6: Portlanders only consume 20 billion gallons of water per year.
Fact #7: We dump 220 billion gallons of excess water into our river, because we have too much.
[ref]

I ain't going to worry about it, no more.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
5K
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 52 ·
2
Replies
52
Views
8K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
7K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
4K
  • Poll Poll
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
6K
Replies
20
Views
9K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
4K
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
6K