Genetics, replication of heterozygous diploids – conceptual

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the replication process of heterozygous diploid cells during cellular division, specifically focusing on the behavior of chromatids and alleles. Participants explore concepts related to mitosis, chromatid separation, and the implications for genetic inheritance in diploid organisms.

Discussion Character

  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • One participant describes the basic structure of chromosomes and the process of DNA replication, suggesting that a heterozygous diploid cell would replicate into two homozygous chromosomes.
  • Another participant corrects this understanding by explaining that chromatids are duplicated versions of chromosomes and that diploid organisms have two separate chromosomes from different parents, which can lead to heterozygosity.
  • A participant seeks clarification on the concept of chromatids splitting and how this affects the genetic makeup of daughter cells, questioning how a daughter cell can become heterozygous if it only receives one allele.
  • One participant elaborates on the mechanics of mitosis, emphasizing the role of the mitotic spindle and the separation of chromatids, while also mentioning the potential consequences of errors in this process.
  • Another participant reiterates the concern about how daughter cells can maintain heterozygosity when they only inherit one chromatid from each chromosome pair.
  • Terminology issues are raised regarding the definitions of chromatids and chromosomes throughout the replication process.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the implications of chromatid separation and the maintenance of heterozygosity in daughter cells. There is no consensus on how these processes interact, and the discussion remains unresolved.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight potential misunderstandings regarding terminology and the mechanics of chromosome replication and separation. There are also unresolved questions about the genetic implications of chromatid inheritance in diploid cells.

despues357
So you have two alleles for every one gene, and the chromosome is composed of 2 homologous chromatids that have one of the 2 alleles for the specified gene on each chromatid.

when you have to replicate that chromosome the way I understand DNA replication is is that you have a serious of functioning proteins that make a one-to-one photocopy of that entire chromosome. Despite the minor mutations poss. involved with DNA replication in general. But if I have a heterozygous diploid whose chromosome splits off, both chromatids should just replicate themselves. So the diploid cell will duplicate into 2 individual homozygous chromosomes. (I'm not trying to talk about meiosis right now, just talking about cellular division)
I'm sorry that these are massive run-on sentences
 
Biology news on Phys.org
You have a misconception here:
despues357 said:
So you have two alleles for every one gene, and the chromosome is composed of 2 homologous chromatids that have one of the 2 alleles for the specified gene on each chromatid.

The chromatid is the result of the duplication of a single chromosome before the two sister chromosomes are separated. They are held together for a while at the centromere.
When this happens in a diploid cell, you will have 4 chromatids for each chromosome pair (such as the chromosome 2 pair of chromosomes). For non-paired chromosomes (like an X and Y) there will be only two chromatids for each of the unpaired chromosomes (like the X and Y).

In a diploid organism, there will be two separate chromosomes that are not derived from each other. Normally they will come from different parents and be unrelated.
This is why you can have a heterozygous organism, the chromosomes can be unrelated with different evolutionary histories.

I don't understand what you mean by this (the splitting off part):
despues357 said:
But if I have a heterozygous diploid whose chromosome splits off
 
Sorry I should've clarified,

After telophase individual chromatids from chromosomes were broken apart and delivered to opp. sides leading to newly forming cells. But the confusing part for this diploid to be a replica of the previous cell that it comes from, it should need both chromatids to do this. Otherwise I imagine they singular chromatid of the 2 that was put into that individual cell, replicating itself, therefore, ending up with a chromosome that contains only one allele of the previous 2.

unless something before happens I guess?
 
During mitosis, it is extremely unlikely that two chromatids for a single chromosome would go in the same direction and end up in the same daughter cell.

This is because all the chromosomes line up on the plane between the two poles (metaphase). Each chromosome's pair of chromatids are attached to microtubules in the mitotic spindle from different poles at their joined centromere. Things giggle around until some sensing mechanism (recently discovered, which I don't know much about) decides the tension is equal and then all the chromatid pair's centromeres split apart and the newly separated chromosomes go in different directions.

If this does not work right then you get problems of too many or too few chromosomes in a cell (anuploidy). This can lead to a variety of problems. There is a strong selection against this, so evolution has resulted in mechanisms to prevent it (usually).

When I was studying this, I would draw cartoons over and over until I understood where everything came from and was going to and could always draw it right. For me anyway, drawing is a good method for learning certain aspects of biology. Something like this might be a good drawing to work on.

This is of course different from meiosis where (in the first division) duplicated pairs of chromosomes (four chromatids) are lined up and separated (after crossing over occurs).
 
So I didn't really mean the nonstandard # of chromatids are separated into Difference cells coming from the original cell. I meant in the situation where all things are normal, you have one chromatid for each individual daughter cell. Chromosomes are composed of 2 chromatids, a heterozygous diploid (Aa) will have 2 diff. alleles for a gene. Each one is located on its own chromatid. So when the 2 daughter cells have one of the chromatids each, how are they going to replace the missing allele they no longer have a copy for? A daughter cell with the "a" allele chromatid can't replicate the "a" allele chromatid to get the "A" allele chromatid, so how does it compensate to become heterozygous just like its parent heterozygous diploid cell?
 
Duplicated chromosomes are composed of two chromatids before they are separated into the two daughter cells that result from cell division.
when they separate they are just two separate chromosomes, kind of composed of one chromatid each, except they would not be called chromatids then.
Before DNA replication there is only one chromosome, composed of one chromatid, which would not be called a chromatid then either.
Lots of terminology issues.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
39K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
6K
Replies
12
Views
6K
Replies
4
Views
3K