Gravitational Energy by breaking down volcanoes / mountains?

  • Thread starter Gerinski
  • Start date
  • #1
313
11

Main Question or Discussion Point

For centuries we have been using the gravitational potential energy of water courses by building watermills and dams with hydroelectric plants. The weather does the job of bringing the water back 'upstairs' for free so conceptually that's a wonderful energy source. The problem is (I guess) that we have far too few convenient water courses to produce the required energy output.

From here, several ideas arise:

1) what about building artificial convenient water courses? Study were there is a lot of precipitation on high altitude areas, in geographically convenient areas (altitude gradients etc) and build huge water lakes to be used for hydroelectric energy production (rather than just using naturally occurring water courses).

2) force / accelerate the water flow by melting the snow from very high permanently snowed mountains such as the Himalayas, for example using solar mirrors to warm up the snow. I guess that this would not alter the natural equilibrium significantly, since the cold and new snow precipitations would restore the melted snow?

3) what about using mountains and their soil / rocks instead of water? Very simply stated, imagine we build a huge ramp from the top of a mountain to the deepest point in a sensibly close distance. Then we put a bulldozer on the top of the mountain which gradually breaks down the stuff at the top of the mountain and throws it into the ramp, where it would fall and could be used similarly as water to power some kind of turbines.

4) of course that would have no natural mechanism bringing the stuff back to high altitude (unless we wait millions of years for mountain rising), but volcanoes do naturally raise 'stuff' from the Earth up. If a similar system would be placed near the top of an active volcano, just far enough from the erupting crater to avoid the whole thing getting melted, that could also be a possibility.

Probably crazy?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
SteamKing
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
12,798
1,666
For centuries we have been using the gravitational potential energy of water courses by building watermills and dams with hydroelectric plants. The weather does the job of bringing the water back 'upstairs' for free so conceptually that's a wonderful energy source. The problem is (I guess) that we have far too few convenient water courses to produce the required energy output.

From here, several ideas arise:

1) what about building artificial convenient water courses? Study were there is a lot of precipitation on high altitude areas, in geographically convenient areas (altitude gradients etc) and build huge water lakes to be used for hydroelectric energy production (rather than just using naturally occurring water courses).
If you think building a dam is expensive, try building a river instead.

It doesn't really matter that much where the hydropower is generated. That's why electricity is so convenient: the power generated in a plant can be transmitted thru power lines for great distances, so everyone doesn't have to build a power plant or dam in their backyard.

2) force / accelerate the water flow by melting the snow from very high permanently snowed mountains such as the Himalayas, for example using solar mirrors to warm up the snow. I guess that this would not alter the natural equilibrium significantly, since the cold and new snow precipitations would restore the melted snow?
The top of a mountain is a pretty difficult place to install a bunch of mirrors. And the weather there is not always sunny and clear.

3) what about using mountains and their soil / rocks instead of water? Very simply stated, imagine we build a huge ramp from the top of a mountain to the deepest point in a sensibly close distance. Then we put a bulldozer on the top of the mountain which gradually breaks down the stuff at the top of the mountain and throws it into the ramp, where it would fall and could be used similarly as water to power some kind of turbines.
And what do you do when all the mountains are laid flat? Not to mention that avalanches are hard to extract energy from without wrecking your machinery.
4) of course that would have no natural mechanism bringing the stuff back to high altitude (unless we wait millions of years for mountain rising), but volcanoes do naturally raise 'stuff' from the Earth up. If a similar system would be placed near the top of an active volcano, just far enough from the erupting crater to avoid the whole thing getting melted, that could also be a possibility.

Probably crazy?
The only problem with the volcano approach is that all that rock and stuff is what keeps the lava, you know, in the volcano in the first place. Once you take the mountain away, the lava flows out and cools, and there's no more volcano, at least not for a long time.
 

Related Threads on Gravitational Energy by breaking down volcanoes / mountains?

  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
824
Replies
5
Views
4K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
23
Views
11K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
4K
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
2K
Top