Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Has Doctor Who Jumped the Shark?

  1. Dec 14, 2013 #1
    I've been a big fan of Doctor Who but not particularly the 11th Doctor, Matt Smith. It seems to me Doctor Who may have jumped the shark when he rebooted the universe. It seems they have over emphasized some aspects of the traditional Doctor Who to grotesque proportions.
  2. jcsd
  3. Dec 14, 2013 #2


    User Avatar
    Science Advisor

    Huh?? What do you regard as "traditional Dr Who"? William Hartnell?

    I rather liked Matt Smith -- more than David Tennant. I would have said they "jumped the shark" when Rose Tyler (Billie Piper) departed. Couldn't stand Donna Noble (Catherine Tate). :yuck:

    TBH, I wish they'd bring back a companion like Leela (Louise Jameson). :blushing:
  4. Dec 14, 2013 #3
    I prefer William Hartnell, Jon Pertwee, Tom Baker, Peter Davison and David Tennant all beyond Matt Smith. Primarily because of the writing with respect to Matt Smith. I just think they have gone overboard on some of the cheese factor and have turned Doctor Who into a bit of a caricature.
  5. Dec 15, 2013 #4
    Has Dr Who jumped the shark...

    I'd have to say no. at least in my opinion it hasn't.

    Will it ever, I don't know.

    One thing many people seem to forget is that DR who is a Children's program (technically Family Horror) in the UK, and holding it the standard of a serious science fiction show is a mistake.
  6. Dec 16, 2013 #5
    I agree that Smith has increased the silly quotient of the show quite heavily. But has the show jumped the shark...I think not. Anything after Tennant and RTD is going to look slightly lackluster. Yes, there has been some overt display of eccentricity which before was simply a layer of the painting but it also has had some excellent plot devices and support from background characters.

    The one thing I don't like about the 11th is he's too brash and too cocksure, yes, the 10th was confident of himself too but he didn't have that 'come at me if you dare' kind of attitude:
    (yes, I like the speech; its just that it doesn't fit well with the character)
    P.S. Anyone have any idea about 'Who nose'?
  7. Dec 16, 2013 #6


    User Avatar
    Science Advisor

    I thought Patrick Troughton increased the silliness of the show quite heavily when he took over from WH. And I was a kid back then -- I was quite indignant that my beloved "serious" show had gone silly. :smile:
  8. Dec 16, 2013 #7
    I really don't think it's been a children's programme for a very long time.

  9. Dec 16, 2013 #8


    User Avatar
    Science Advisor

    Yeah. If one wants a children's program, try the "K-9" spinoff. :smile:
  10. Dec 17, 2013 #9
    I agree, it is not a children's show. Perhaps some don't regard it as serious science fiction because it has other elements besides science fiction. I don't think all science fiction has to be like Star Trek. I take it seriously - thank you.

    On the other hand the Matt Smith Doctor Who can be pretty silly.
  11. May 10, 2014 #10
    Doctor Who has not jumped the shark, it has begun playing on the event horizon of suck but has not crossed it yet. What needs to happen is there needs to be a new showrunner brought in, one who preferably isn't a fanboy, to set things straight. If it does cross that event horizon the only hope it has would be to completely reboot itself I believe, unlikely.

    The fortunate thing about Doctor Who is that it is so inconsistent that it is hard to permanently jump the shark.
  12. May 14, 2014 #11


    User Avatar

    Its true. how do you define jumping the shark when nearly every episode has something impossible happening. In one episode the doctor casually mentioned how his race Invented Black holes. in another the Dalleks scooped up a dozen different planets teleported them across the universe and stuffed them all within spitting distance of each other, with no harm to any of the inhabitants.

    I think Jumping the Shark for this show would be having the doctor solve a mundane crime without any techno babble or sonic screwdriver :D
  13. May 30, 2014 #12


    User Avatar
    Science Advisor

    Personally, I think Dr. Who has gone downhill ever since Tom Baker. My personal favorites have always been Baker and Pertwee.
  14. Jun 1, 2014 #13


    User Avatar
    Science Advisor

    Is the rumour true that Tom tended to "fondle" his female companion actresses off-camera? :uhh:
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook