B Heat exchange after thermal equilibrium

Click For Summary
Systems A and B, initially separated by an adiabatic wall, exchange energy with system C through a diathermic wall until they reach thermal equilibrium. Once in equilibrium with C, A and B can exchange energy via a diathermic wall, while energy exchange with C is prevented by an adiabatic wall. The discussion emphasizes that systems in thermal equilibrium do not exchange heat energy, aligning with the 0th law of thermodynamics. However, it notes that while there is no net heat exchange, energy fluctuations can occur, averaging to zero in large systems. The diagram referenced serves to illustrate the principles of thermal equilibrium and the Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics.
vcsharp2003
Messages
913
Reaction score
179
TL;DR
Can there be any heat exchange between two systems that are in thermal equilibrium?
In screenshot below, systems A and B are separated by an adiabatic wall initially while each of them exchanges energy with system C via a diathermic wall. Once A and B reach thermal equilibrium with C, then A,B are allowed energy exchange via a diathermic wall, and energy exchange between A and C as well as B and C is prevented by using an adiabatic wall.

To my knowledge systems that are in thermal equilibrium should not exchange heat energy. Is this true or they could exchange heat depending on circumstances? May be expandable ideal gas systems at different pressures and joined by a common diathermic movable piston could exchange heat as the piston moves from high pressure side moves towards the lower pressure side.

CamScanner 01-17-2023 18.22_5.jpg
 
Last edited:
Science news on Phys.org
The 0th law of thermodynamics states that if A is in thermal equilibrium with C and B is in thermal equilibrium with C, then A is in thermal equilibrium with B. My guess is that the figure is used to illustrate this principle.

Note that while there is no net exchange of heat energy between two systems in equilibrium (2nd law), there are energy fluctuations (A and B will exchange energy back and forth, and this averages to 0). For a large enough system (or in the thermodynamic limit), these fluctuations are too small to be measured.
 
  • Like
Likes vcsharp2003
DrClaude said:
My guess is that the figure is used to illustrate this principle.
Yes, this was a diagram used to explain Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics in the textbook.

Thankyou for the detailed answer. It's clear to me now.
 
Hello, We have a thermal camera and its purpose is to detect hot spots at different distances. We made an experiment with a JPEG picture and we noticed the following: At the same distance, one object at 600 degrees and an object at 38 degrees (human body) have the same pixel intensity (255 in grayscale). The image adjusted when the 600 degrees object exited the scene (parts of the human body and background became brighter). We will make a detection algorithm and we need to make sure only...