Heat wave? bring me the freeze ray

  • Thread starter Thread starter nopunyntended
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Heat Ray Wave
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the concept of heat and its relationship with electromagnetic waves, particularly in the context of whether heat can be "ruled out" or nullified using electromagnetic methods. Participants explore theoretical ideas about wave interference, energy transfer, and cooling mechanisms, with a focus on the feasibility of creating a "freeze ray" or similar device.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants propose that heat acts as a wave and can be nullified by inverse waves, while others argue that heat is the transfer of energy and not a wave itself.
  • A participant suggests that if heat waves could be summed with their inverses, it might create negative energy, raising questions about the validity of this idea.
  • There is a discussion about the randomness of infrared waves and the challenges in canceling them effectively.
  • Some participants mention the potential of using reflective surfaces to redirect thermal energy, likening this to a "freezer ray" concept.
  • Questions arise about whether temperature can rise with wavelengths other than infrared, with some clarification that energy carried by photons is what matters.
  • Concerns are raised about the practicality of nullifying thermal radiation emitted from devices like CPUs, with explanations about how cooling typically occurs through energy transfer rather than cancellation.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the nature of heat and whether it can be nullified through electromagnetic means. There is no consensus on the feasibility of creating a device to cancel heat or thermal radiation, and the discussion remains unresolved.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight limitations in their understanding of heat, energy, and electromagnetic radiation, with some acknowledging the complexity of the concepts involved. The discussion reflects varying degrees of familiarity with the underlying physics.

nopunyntended
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
i understand that heat acts as a wave,it has some variations depending on the frequency i believe.we all know we can build machines to create such waves.my understandings of physics tell me that waves can be nulled out by other inverse wave.my question:can heat be electromagnetically ruled out?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
nopunyntended said:
i understand that heat acts as a wave,it has some variations depending on the frequency i believe.

This is incorrect. Heat is the transfer of energy from a hotter to colder object. The energy transfer can happen from direct contact or by EM radiation. EM waves have a frequency because they are waves, but heat is not a wave.

we all know we can build machines to create such waves.my understandings of physics tell me that waves can be nulled out by other inverse wave.my question:can heat be electromagnetically ruled out?

EM waves will interfere with each other, forming a diffraction pattern of peaks and nulls, but there is no way to turn this into a freeze ray.
 
yeah but, heat waves can be polarized right? i know there is no such thing as a freeze ray, freeze waves do not exist. only heat waves do.and the rise of temperature that we feel is due to energy that flows in the infra red spectrum. my ideia is to fight fire with fire.if you can sum the heat wave for its inverse that the energy of that sum will be zero.and, if i multiply them up they will overlap and create NEGATIVE energy. can this be done? or my understadings of physics just plain suck?
 

Attachments

  • heatpolarization.png
    heatpolarization.png
    17.8 KB · Views: 544
Last edited:
nopunyntended said:
yeah but, heat waves can be polarized right? i know there is no such thing as a freeze ray, freeze waves do not exist. only heat waves do.

There is no such thing as a heat wave. Infrared radiation is made up of electromagnetic waves.

and the rise of temperature that we feel is due to energy that flows in the infra red spectrum. my ideia is to fight fire with fire.if you can sum the heat wave for its inverse that the energy of that sum will be zero.and, if i multiply them up they will overlap and create NEGATIVE energy. can this be done? or my understadings of physics just plain suck?

You cannot create negative energy. Even when two EM waves interfere destructively and create a null, you merely have zero energy being transported to that spot, not a negative amount. Also, remember that energy is transferred through all wavelengths of EM radiation, not just the infrared part.
 
Drakkith, I am not sure you are getting the point. I think the OP realizes that there is no such thing as a heat wave, he has just poorly chosen words. Everywhere you look infrared waves are striking matter. I think what the OP wants to know is if there is a way to cancel these waves. It goes without saying that if the effect of these waves were nullified then the matter would have a tendency to cool.
-
Short answer is this: The infrared waves that strike the matter in our environment are way to random and out of control to begin with for a scheme like this to work.
-
However, there is something that has been done for years that involves wave cancellation and reinforcement. The laser. Building a laser is a very precise operation.
 
thank you supernova.i think you made my point a lot clearer.i also assumed that randomness would be an issue.but if you have a specific device that is a hot object let's say a cpu, the electrons passing through it will create infrared waves. if you analyze those waves for frequency, and distance, i mean if you can accurately determine its characteristics, can you use the same type of wave (modified of course) to nullify the infra red waves and also,heat.
 
Drakkith said:
Also, remember that energy is transferred through all wavelengths of EM radiation, not just the infrared part.
does temperature rise with other types of wavelengths?
 
Since the thermal energy is transferred as broadband randomly phased radiation, you cannot generate an exact directional, amplitude and phase correct replica.

There is a trick, you can use the energy itself to generate a close to perfect replica by using a highly conductive surface to make a reflective mirror. The incident energy reaching the mirror generates an opposite wave that cancels almost all the forward traveling energy and so reflects the incident energy back at the angle of reflection.

So, a freezer ray will be a mirror, aimed to reflect energy you do not want, to where you want it.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black-body_radiation
 
nopunyntended said:
thank you supernova.i think you made my point a lot clearer.i also assumed that randomness would be an issue.but if you have a specific device that is a hot object let's say a cpu, the electrons passing through it will create infrared waves. if you analyze those waves for frequency, and distance, i mean if you can accurately determine its characteristics, can you use the same type of wave (modified of course) to nullify the infra red waves and also,heat.

Are you trying to cool the CPU?
 
  • #10
nopunyntended said:
does temperature rise with other types of wavelengths?

Temperature doesn't depend on the wavelength. Amount of energy carried by a photon does.

If your question is "is it possible to heat something with radiation other than IR", answer is yes (although there are plenty of fine details that can make it "no" in particular situations).
 
Last edited:
  • #11
Drakkith said:
Are you trying to cool the CPU?
dude,im just thinking outside the box. the only way we have now to cool stuff down is by absortion of heat. i use cpu as an example because it's a body that emits heat, its thermal energy can be studied and too much heat goes against the cpu function.if you can use those EM to nullify the thermal waves emitted by it than you would find another way to cool equipments
 
Last edited:
  • #12
Baluncore said:
Since the thermal energy is transferred as broadband randomly phased radiation, you cannot generate an exact directional, amplitude and phase correct replica.

There is a trick, you can use the energy itself to generate a close to perfect replica by using a highly conductive surface to make a reflective mirror. The incident energy reaching the mirror generates an opposite wave that cancels almost all the forward traveling energy and so reflects the incident energy back at the angle of reflection.

So, a freezer ray will be a mirror, aimed to reflect energy you do not want, to where you want it.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black-body_radiation

you are telling me, we can use a conductive surface to work a mirror for heat?which we can redirect to wherever? =D
 
  • #13
Yes. Have you never wondered why aluminium foil makes a good thermal insulator ?
 
  • #14
nopunyntended said:
dude,im just thinking outside the box. the only way we have now to cool stuff down is by absortion of heat. i use cpu as an example because it's a body that emits heat, its thermal energy can be studied and too much heat goes against the cpu function.if you can use those EM to nullify the thermal waves emitted by it than you would find another way to cool equipments

Okay, that's what I thought you meant, I just wasn't certain. Unfortunately this won't work. You can't nullify the thermal radiation emitted from it, nor would you want to, as thermal radiation is one way the CPU cools itself.

As I've been saying, heat is the transfer of energy. The CPU is hot, and therefor has a lot of thermal energy it needs to get rid of to cool off. A heat sink and fan usually do this by absorbing energy through direct contact with the CPU and then transferring it to the air. In addition, some of the energy is radiated away from the heat sink as thermal radiation, increasing the cooling rate. Note that thermal radiation is simply a specific way of generating EM radiation. Thermal radiation is not "heat waves".

The reason I keep saying that there is no such thing as heat waves is because I feel you have a misunderstanding about what heat and energy are. The thermal energy of the CPU cannot be nullified at all. It must be transferred somewhere else, either through conduction, convection, or radiation (of EM waves). Does that make sense?

nopunyntended said:
you are telling me, we can use a conductive surface to work a mirror for heat?which we can redirect to wherever? =D

To be clear, it will reflect a large percentage of EM radiation falling on it. Survival blankets are shiny and reflective so that they reflect the infrared radiation from your body back onto yourself, slowing the transfer of thermal energy from your body to the outside, keeping you warm.
 
  • #15
okay.i get what you mean.thanks for being so patient.damn =C
 

Similar threads

Replies
9
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 26 ·
Replies
26
Views
3K