Help with Physics Problem: Finding Distance d for Ball to Strike Peg

  • Thread starter chuxingli
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Physics
In summary, the question involves finding the distance d below the point of support at which the peg should be placed for the ball to swing along an arc and hit the peg. The solution involves using conservation of energy and solving for the speed at which the ball leaves the circular path. The angle above the horizontal at which the ball leaves the circle can also be calculated and used to determine the horizontal and vertical components of the velocity. The final part of the problem involves treating the motion of the ball as a 2-dimensional projectile to find the distance d. This can be a challenging problem and may require the use of mathematical software such as Maple.
  • #1
chuxingli
9
0
the question:

You have a supporting point and a ball connected by a
string of length 100cm. There is a peg at a distance d
below the supporting point. You release the ball from
rest at an instance when the ball is totally
horizontal to the point, it swings along an arc. When
the string catches on the peg, the ball swings upward
but does not complete a circular path around the peg.
Instead, the abll leaves its circular path, and
strikes the peg.

1) Find the distance d below the point of support at
which the peg should be placed for this to happen.

2) You have to find a function d(theta) at which the
peg needs to be placed for this to happen.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Perhaps the reason this question has not been replied to is that the final part is not clear. How does the ball strike the peg? Could you post a picture showing the situation?
 
  • #3
This is a tough problem.

Finding the speed of the ball at the bottom is easy (use E conservation).

after string hits peg, the ball motion is circular up past horizontal,
but you don't know the effective length of the string L = (1[meter] - d).

Call theta the angle above the horizontal at which ball leaves the circle.
ball is a 2-d projectile after that, from (x = L cos theta , y = L sin theta)
with velocity components (- v sin theta , v cos theta) , to peg at (0,0),

This is much easier problem in the forward direction (given d, where does ball cross x=0 line) . maybe you program it into a calculator or spreadsheet, then change d until it hits peg ...?
 
  • #4
i agree with Integral...

chuxingli said:
the question:
You have a supporting point and a ball connected by a
string of length 100cm. There is a peg at a distance d
below the supporting point. You release the ball from
rest at an instance when the ball is totally
horizontal to the point, it swings along an arc. When
the string catches on the peg, the ball swings upward
but does not complete a circular path around the peg.
Instead, the ball leaves its circular path, and
strikes the peg.
1) Find the distance d below the point of support at
which the peg should be placed for this to happen.
2) You have to find a function d(theta) at which the
peg needs to be placed for this to happen.

wouldn't the diameter of the ball and the peg matter?
i can picture a solution with peg of 1 cm diameter and ball of 2 cm diameter, and the peg 96 cm vertically below the "supporting point"...
:rofl:
 
  • #5
plusaf, the peg and ball are considered points
 
  • #6
there are 3 concepts involved:

1. conservation of energy at the point when the ball leaves the smaller circle

2. speed at the point when the ball leaves the smaller circle.

3. freefall.

can someone who knows physics work it out for me. the concepts are quite simple. But the algebra i did was extremely messy.
 
  • #7
Integral, obviously, there is no outside fore so there is only one way the ball could hit the peg...
 
  • #8
Did you define the angle above the horizontal that the circle becomes parabola?

you should know the speed there will depend on L and d.
I think that 2/3 d = L sin theta , and v^2 (at transition) = L g sin theta .
I had to solve a quadratic in sin^2 theta , to hit the peg.
So there are two angles, for a 1-meter string, if I've not made a sign mistake.
(yeah, the algebra stinks. Some problems are best done on computer ...
say, do you have access to Maple ...?)
 
  • #9
i'm on it

lightgrav said:
after string hits peg, the ball motion is circular up past horizontal,
but you don't know the effective length of the string L = (1[meter] - d).
Call theta the angle above the horizontal at which ball leaves the circle.
ball is a 2-d projectile after that, from (x = L cos theta , y = L sin theta)
agree
lightgrav said:
with velocity components (- v sin theta , v cos theta) , to peg at (0,0),
somehow i couldn't agree. i imagined the ball stopped vertically at one point above the peg. and that makes the velocity components (vy=0, vx= something). and from that, i worked out that
d=100 - {(2*vx^2*sin(theta))/([cos(theta)]^2*g)}

i'm working the vx. I'm trying to understand how the energy conservation work. when the vertical component of velocity is zero, the horizontal is not.
 
  • #10
ehm... when i say theta, i mean
"the angle between the horizontal line along the peg and the point where the ball starting to leave the circular path.
and also, i was assuming that the peg was "straight" below the supporting point
 
Last edited:
  • #11
the peg and the ball problem

First let us imagine the string does not break(it is not mentioned in the problem, but if u imagine this it is relatively simpler). now at certain angle above the horizontal this happens. the angle can be foundby equating the gravity force (downward) and the upward component of mv^2/r at that point. also v can be calculated from energy considerartion. Now treating it as a projectile problem the hitting of the peg can be understood. you can try this way. I have not done thew mathematics myself. So, i don't know how rigorous it is.
 

What is the best way to approach a physics problem?

The best way to approach a physics problem is to first identify what is given and what is being asked, then draw a diagram and label all known values. Next, choose the appropriate equation(s) to solve for the unknown variable(s), and finally plug in the known values and solve for the unknown.

How do I know which equation to use for a specific physics problem?

To determine which equation to use, first identify the known and unknown variables in the problem. Then, look for an equation that includes both the known and unknown variables. If there are multiple equations that fit this criteria, choose the one that is most relevant to the situation described in the problem.

What should I do if I am stuck on a physics problem?

If you are stuck on a physics problem, try breaking it down into smaller, more manageable parts. Focus on one aspect of the problem at a time and try to apply the concepts and equations you know to that specific part. You can also try looking for similar problems in your textbook or online and using their solutions as a guide.

What are some common mistakes to avoid when solving physics problems?

Some common mistakes to avoid when solving physics problems include not carefully reading and understanding the problem, using the wrong units or not converting units correctly, and making algebraic errors. It is also important to check that your answer makes sense in the context of the problem.

Can I use a calculator when solving physics problems?

Yes, you can use a calculator when solving physics problems. However, it is important to make sure you are using the correct units and entering the values correctly. It is also helpful to double check your calculations by using estimation or using a different method to solve the problem.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
5K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
953
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
10K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
22K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
5K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
14K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
9
Views
636
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
797
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
4K
Back
Top