How do I draw all forces on a stone sinking in water?

11 replies · 4K views · last reply
Karagoz

Homework Statement



How do I draw all forces on a stone sinking in water? And what are the names of the forces? And will the stone reach terminal velocity and be sinking in constant velocity?

Homework Equations



In some websites they just draw buoyant force and gravity force. But in other websites they say that both buoyant force and fluid drag force that push the object upwards. Is it only the buoyant force that push it upwards, or both buoyant force and fluid drag force that push it upwards?

The Attempt at a Solution


Free-body diagram of a grey circle in blue water, with arrows showing forces: one long upward arrow and one long downward arrow through the centre, plus shorter inward arrows around the circle.
[/B]
 
Attachments
  • Free-body diagram of a grey circle in blue water, with arrows showing forces: one long upward arrow and one long downward arrow through the centre, plus shorter inward arrows around the circle.
    SinkingObject.png
    1.2 KB · Views: 903
If it is continuing to fall, there is fluid drag as well as the buoyant force acting upwards while the weight acts down.
 
Dr.D said:
If it is continuing to fall, there is fluid drag as well as the buoyant force acting upwards while the weight acts down.

Then is this the correct way to draw the force vectors?
Free-body diagram of a grey circle sinking in blue fluid, with blue arrows pointing inward around its edge labelled buoyant forces, an orange upward arrow labelled fluid drag force, and a dark red downward arrow labelled gravity force.
 
Attachments
  • Free-body diagram of a grey circle sinking in blue fluid, with blue arrows pointing inward around its edge labelled buoyant forces, an orange upward arrow labelled fluid drag force, and a dark red downward arrow labelled gravity force.
    Draft2 - Copy.png
    3.1 KB · Views: 1,527
You would normally just draw one upward arrow for the buoyancy force.

If it is falling at a constant (terminal) velocity then the net vertical force is zero so

Fgravity + Fboyancy + Fdrag = 0

If it's still accelerating then the sum won't be zero.
 
What you have labeled "buoyant forces" are actually the pressure loads. The true buoyant force is the vector sum of the pressure loads.
 
How much difference will vortex shedding affect drag ?
 
Nik_2213 said:
How much difference will vortex shedding affect drag ?

This is a part of the overall drag, so the answer to your question is simply, "some."
 
Dr.D said:
What you have labeled "buoyant forces" are actually the pressure loads. The true buoyant force is the vector sum of the pressure loads.

I have used pressure loads instead of buoyant force. Then this is the correct?
Free-body diagram of a grey circle submerged in blue fluid, with inward blue arrows labelled pressure loads, an upward orange arrow labelled fluid drag force and a downward red arrow labelled gravity force.


Is the fluid drag force bigger than the buoyant force when the object is in terminal speed?
 
Attachments
  • Free-body diagram of a grey circle submerged in blue fluid, with inward blue arrows labelled pressure loads, an upward orange arrow labelled fluid drag force and a downward red arrow labelled gravity force.
    Draft2 - Copy.png
    3.1 KB · Views: 1,236
Last edited by a moderator:
Karagoz said:
I have used pressure loads instead of buoyant force. Then this is the correct?
View attachment 215327

Is the fluid drag force bigger than the buoyant force when the object is in terminal speed?
Consider two cases.
1. There is a bowling ball with a density of 1.01 times that of water settling slowly to the bottom of a swimming pool. Is the buoyant force greater than or less than the drag force?

2. There is a very small small lead pellet (density approximately 11 times that of water) settling slowly to the bottom of a swimming pool. Is the buoyant force greater than or less than the drag force?
 
There is more than one way to draw the forces depending on what you are interested in. If you were interested in the forces that effect the velocity of the stone then I would draw a Free Body Diagram something like this... The buoyancy force is equal to the weight of the fluid (eg water) displaced by the stone.

If the stone sinks at a constant velocity the three forces (vector) sum to zero..

Fg + Fb + Fd = 0

Free-body diagram of a grey circle representing a stone, with a downward red gravity force arrow, an upward pink buoyancy force arrow, and an upward orange fluid drag force arrow, on a blue background.
 
Attachments
  • Free-body diagram of a grey circle representing a stone, with a downward red gravity force arrow, an upward pink buoyancy force arrow, and an upward orange fluid drag force arrow, on a blue background.
    FBD.png
    2.7 KB · Views: 1,011
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Karagoz
Minor correction: By convention Free Body Diagrams only show ONE object and the forces acting on that object. So as we are only interested in the forces on the stone it's not quite correct/bad practice to show the water as well.