How does Einstein's understanding of gravity work with Lagrange points?

  • Level: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter blank space
  • Start date
3 replies · 170 views · last reply
blank space
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Looking at the models, it looks like Einstein's theory puts objects at the bottom of a well. However when looking at Lagrange points the model looks like a mountain peak with an object hovering in the space its mass creates. How do these 2 models work together?
 
Attachments
  • CNX_UPhysics_13_07_spacetime.webp
    CNX_UPhysics_13_07_spacetime.webp
    42.4 KB · Views: 1
  • Lagrangian_points_equipotential.gif
    Lagrangian_points_equipotential.gif
    2 MB · Views: 1
Lagrange points are stationary points (edit: and not extremae, as I originally wrote - thanks to pbuk for pointing that out) of the effective potential of a two-body system, whereas the diagrams "explaining" relativistic gravity as a rubber sheet are embeddings of the spatial plane of a one-body system. They don't fit together, really, because they're different aspects of different scenarios, despite superficial similarities.

I would suspect that Lagrange points are rather more complicated things in relativistic gravity. Two orbiting bodies emit gravitational radiation and their orbits decay, so I expect that the Lagrange points are only short-term stable (for some extremely long values of short term, with typical astrophysical bodies).
 
Last edited:
I'd also add that both the diagrams you've shown are rather artistically interpreted. If you're going to draw two dimensional slices of space embedded in a 3d space (what the rubber sheet diagram is) or a 3d plot of effective potential in the 2d orbital plane (what the Laagrange point diagram is), adding a 3d planet anywhere is highly misleading. In the rubber sheet diagram it should be marked as a circle on the sheet. In the potential well it arguably shouldn't really be anywhere since that's an abstract graph, but if you're going to plot it, it should be marked as a 2d circle either on the potential surface or on the axis.

I'm afraid this is a rather common problem with diagrams that try to explain this sort of fairly complex mathematical model. People add fancy bells and whistles because they look good, and forget that they're nothing really like the model any more.
 
The animation is not very well drawn: I will explain what I think it is trying to show:
  • L1, L2 and L3 are unstable but they are neither at the top nor at the bottom of a gravity "well": the gravitational potential at these points can be visualised in 2D as a saddle.
  • L4 and L5 are stable: the contours should show a "depression" here in which the objects sit.