How does GR explain twist at the poles

Click For Summary
General relativity (GR) can explain the variation in gravitational acceleration (g) at the equator and poles, but Newtonian mechanics is sufficient for this purpose. The difference in g is primarily due to the Earth's oblate spheroid shape and its rotation, not directly attributable to GR. The curvature of spacetime caused by Earth's mass is greater at the poles, but this does not equate to a direct difference in g. The discussion clarifies that while GR accounts for spacetime distortion, the variation in g can be fully explained using simpler Newtonian principles. Overall, the complexities of GR are not necessary for understanding the gravitational differences observed on Earth.
CRT
Messages
21
Reaction score
2
[Moderator's note: spun off from previous thread on a different topic.]

how general relativity explains the variation in value of g at equator and poles?
why the twist in spacetime is more at poles than equator and not viceversa
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
The difference in gravity is not attributable to GR, it has more to do with the shape of the Earth not being perfectly spherical.
 
rootone said:
The difference in gravity is not attributable to GR

Careful. GR can certainly explain it; it's just that GR is overkill for explaining it, since the Newtonian approximation can do so just as well.
 
  • Like
Likes CRT
CRT said:
how general relativity explains the variation in value of g at equator and poles?

By the fact that the Earth is rotating and is not perfectly spherical, so the gradient of the gravitational potential (which is what "g" is) is different at the poles than it is at the equator. As I noted in my response to rootone just now, however, you don't need GR to derive this result; simple Newtonian mechanics is sufficient.

CRT said:
why the twist in spacetime is more at poles than equator and not viceversa

What do you mean by "the twist in spacetime"? What sort of observations do you think show this?
 
sir i read somewhere that massive Earth distorts spacetime as we all know
but distortion is more at poles due to sperical shape of earth.This last line was the main root of confusion.
 
I agree with Sir Donis that Newtonian mechanics is sufficient over GR.Thanks sir
 
CRT said:
i read somewhere that massive Earth distorts spacetime as we all know

Yes, the Earth's mass causes spacetime curvature.

CRT said:
distortion is more at poles due to sperical shape of earth.

Are you just referring to the fact that ##g## is different at the poles? ##g## is not the same thing as spacetime curvature.

Also, the reason ##g## is different at the poles, in Newtonian terms, is that the Earth is not spherical; it's an oblate spheroid which is rotating.