How does Zee derive the Green's function in Quantum Field Theory on p. 31?

13 replies · 5K views · last reply
jdstokes
Messages
520
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement



A. Zee Quantum Field theory in a nutshell, p. 31. There is painfully little explanation on this page.

I'm okay with the action:

[itex]S(A) = \int d^4 x \mathcal{L} = \int d^4 x\{ \frac{1}{2}A_\mu [(\partial^2 +m^2)g^{\mu \nu}-\partial^\mu\partial^\nu]A_\nu + A_\mu J^\mu \}[/itex]

where I'm assuming [itex]\partial^2 = \partial^\mu\partial_\mu[/itex], but how does he jump from that to the Green's function

[itex][(\partial^2+m^2)g^{\mu\nu}-\partial^\mu\partial^\nu]D_{\nu\lambda}(x) = \delta^\mu_\lambda \delta^{(4)}(x)[/itex]?

Where did the Kronecker delta and the subscript \lambda come from??
 
It happens that the propagator is the inverse of the operator appearing in the quadratic term in the Lagrangian. I haven't seen a proof, but i believe there exists one. Thus, what you simply have in your equation is

Quadratic term * Propagator = 1

the delta and the lambda are there to satisfy this assumption.
 
Thanks for your reply.

I understand where the equation comes from but I don't understand the presence of the Kronecker delta [itex]\delta^\mu_\lambda[/itex] nor why the green's function is indexed by [itex]\nu,\lambda[/itex].
 
Last edited:
If we put [itex]\lambda = \mu[/itex] we get

[itex][(\partial^2+m^2)g^{\mu\nu}-\partial^\mu\partial^\nu]D_{\nu\mu}(x) = \delta^{(4)}(x)[/itex]

which makes a little more sense since we're now summing over all indices. Is there any reason for summing over the [itex]\nu[/itex] index as opposed to [itex]\mu[/itex] when [itex]\lambda\neq\mu[/itex].

Further question: Fourier transforming gives

[itex][-(k^2-m^2)g^{\mu\nu}+k^\nu k^\mu]D_{\nu\lambda}(k) = \delta^\mu_\lambda[/itex].

I don't see how to get from this to Eq. (3):

[itex]D_{\nu \lambda}(k)= -\frac{g_{\nu\lambda} + k_\nu k_\lambda /m^2}{k^2-m^2}[/itex].

Am I missing something obvious?
 
Last edited:
jdstokes said:
If we put [itex]\lambda = \mu[/itex] we get

[itex][(\partial^2+m^2)g^{\mu\nu}-\partial^\mu\partial^\nu]D_{\nu\mu}(x) = \delta^{(4)}(x)[/itex]

which makes a little more sense since we're now summing over all indices. Is there any reason for summing over the [itex]\nu[/itex] index as opposed to [itex]\mu[/itex] when [itex]\lambda\neq\mu[/itex].

Further question: Fourier transforming gives

[itex][-(k^2-m^2)g^{\mu\nu}+k^\nu k^\mu]D_{\nu\lambda}(k) = \delta^\mu_\lambda[/itex].

I don't see how to get from this to Eq. (3):

[itex]D_{\nu \lambda}(k)= -\frac{g_{\nu\lambda} + k_\nu k_\lambda /m^2}{k^2-m^2}[/itex].

Am I missing something obvious?


To find [itex]D_{\nu \lambda}[/itex] from the equation, write the most general possible form, which is [tex]A(k) k_{\nu} k_{\lambda} + B(k) g_{\nu \lambda}[/tex] and solve for A and B.
 
*Head explodes*. Is there some way you can justify that [tex]D_{\nu\lambda} = A(k) k_{\nu} k_{\lambda} + B(k) g_{\nu \lambda} [/itex]??<br /> <br /> I wish I knew more about Green's functions...<br /> <br /> Is it just because there's some theorem which says that the Green's function must be of the same general form as the operator?[/tex]
 
Last edited:
jdstokes said:
*Head explodes*. Is there some way you can justify that [tex]D_{\nu\lambda} = A(k) k_{\nu} k_{\lambda} + B(k) g_{\nu \lambda} [/itex]??<br /> <br /> I wish I knew more about Green's functions...<br /> <br /> Is it just because there's some theorem which says that the Green's function must be of the same general form as the operator?[/tex]
[tex] <br /> It's simply that [tex]D_{\nu \lambda}[/tex] must be a tensor with two indices (a second rank tensor). the only things you have at your disposal to build D from are k and the metric. So that's the the most general thing you can write down, that's all.[/tex]
 
Hey nrqed,

Thanks. That makes things much clearer. I'm still troubled about how we're supposed to find A(k) and B(k), we have

[itex][-(k^2-m^2)g^{\mu\nu}+k^\nu k^\mu](A(k) k_{\nu} k_{\lambda} + B(k) g_{\nu \lambda}) = \delta^\mu_\lambda[/itex]

But now what? Expanding things out doesn't help much. It seems like we need some conditions on the behaviour of A and B for various k, but we aren't told anything? Where is the extra equation?
 
Let [itex]D_{\nu\lambda}(k) = A(k) g_{\nu\lambda} + B(k) k_\nu k_\lambda[/itex].

[itex][-(k^2-m^2)g^{\mu\nu}+k^\nu k^\mu](A(k) g_{\nu\lambda} + B(k) k_\nu k_\lambda) = \delta^\mu_\lambda[/itex]
[itex][-(k^2-m^2)g^{\mu\nu}+k^\nu k^\mu](A(k) g_{\nu\lambda} + B(k) k_\nu k_\lambda) = 1[/itex]
[itex]-(k^2-m^2)g^{\mu\nu}g_{\nu\mu}A(k) + k^\mu k^\nu g_{\nu\mu}A(k) -(k^2 -m^2)g^{\mu\nu}k_\nu k_\mu B(k) + k^\mu k^\nu k_\nu k_\mu B(k)=1[/itex]
[itex]-(k^2-m^2)A(k) + k^2A(k) -(k^2 -m^2)k^2 B(k) + k^4 B(k)=1 \implies[/itex]
[itex]A(k) = \frac{1}{m^2}- k^2 B(k)\implies[/itex]

[itex]D_{\nu\lambda} = \frac{g_{\nu\lambda}}{m^2} - g_{\nu\lambda}k^\nu k_\nu B(k) + B(k) k_\nu k_\lambda = \frac{g_{\nu\lambda}}{m^2}[/itex]

What am I missing here?
 
Last edited:
You are multiplying 2 matrices together, the first with indices [itex]\mu\nu[/itex] and the second with indices [itex]\nu\lambda[/itex], and you are summing over [itex]\nu[/itex]. You should not set [itex]\mu=\lambda[/itex], because you lose information when you do this.

Then, in your last line, you illegally use the index nu twice in the second term; [tex]g_{\nu\lambda}k^\nu k_\nu[/tex] should be [tex]g_{\nu\lambda}k^\rho k_\rho[/tex].
 
Last edited:
Second attempt:

Assume [itex]A(k) = -\frac{1}{k^2-m^2}[/itex]. Then

[itex][-(k^2-m^2)g^{\mu\nu}+k^\nu k^\mu](A(k) g_{\nu\lambda} + B(k) k_\nu k_\lambda) = \delta^\mu_\nu - \frac{k^\mu k_\lambda}{k^2-m^2} + Bk_\nu k_\lambda[-(k^2-m^2)g^{\mu\nu}+ k^\mu k^\nu][/itex]

[itex][-(k^2-m^2)g^{\mu\nu}+k^\nu k^\mu](A(k) g_{\nu\lambda} + B(k) k_\nu k_\lambda) = \delta^\mu_\nu - \frac{k^\mu k_\lambda}{k^2-m^2} + B[-(k^2-m^2)k^\mu k_\lambda+ k^2k^\mu k_\lambda][/itex]

[itex][-(k^2-m^2)g^{\mu\nu}+k^\nu k^\mu](A(k) g_{\nu\lambda} + B(k) k_\nu k_\lambda) = \delta^\mu_\nu - \frac{k^\mu k_\lambda}{k^2-m^2} + B[k^\mu k_\lambda m^2][/itex]

Therefore [itex]B = \frac{1/m^2}{k^2-m^2}[/itex].

But I hate the fact that I needed to assume the form of A(k). Is there are more elegant way to derive this?
 
You don't have to assume it.

[tex][-(k^2-m^2)g^{\mu\nu}+k^\mu k^\nu](A g_{\nu\lambda} + B k_\nu k_\lambda)=-(k^2-m^2)(A \delta^\mu{}_\lambda +Bk^\mu k_\lambda)+k^\mu(Ak_\lambda+Bk^2k_\lambda)=-(k^2-m^2)A \delta^\mu{}_\lambda +(A+Bm^2)k^\mu k_\lambda[/tex]

This is supposed to equal [tex]\delta^\mu{}_\lambda[/tex], so we must have [tex]-(k^2-m^2)A =1[/tex] and [tex]A+Bm^2=0.[/tex]
 
jdstokes said:
Let [itex]D_{\nu\lambda}(k) = A(k) g_{\nu\lambda} + B(k) k_\nu k_\lambda[/itex].

[itex][-(k^2-m^2)g^{\mu\nu}+k^\nu k^\mu](A(k) g_{\nu\lambda} + B(k) k_\nu k_\lambda) = \delta^\mu_\lambda[/itex]
[itex][-(k^2-m^2)g^{\mu\nu}+k^\nu k^\mu](A(k) g_{\nu\lambda} + B(k) k_\nu k_\lambda) = 1[/itex]
There was no reason to replace the [itex]\delta^\mu_\lambda[/itex] by one on the rhs there!
[itex]-(k^2-m^2)g^{\mu\nu}g_{\nu\mu}A(k) + k^\mu k^\nu g_{\nu\mu}A(k) -(k^2 -m^2)g^{\mu\nu}k_\nu k_\mu B(k) + k^\mu k^\nu k_\nu k_\mu B(k)=1[/itex]
And then you set lambda = mu but you should not have done that.

See Avodyne's post for the full derivation.


As an aside, it is instructive to do the same calculation for a massless A_\mu. Then you find out that there is no solution A(k) and B(k) satisfying the equation! This is because of gauge invariance; one must add a gauge-fixing term to get a solution. Here, it's not a problem because the massive field case does not have that gauge invariance.