How far does the block slide? (work, spring, incline)

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves a block sliding down an incline, influenced by a spring and a second mass. The original poster attempts to determine the distance traveled by the block before it comes to rest under two scenarios: one where the second mass approaches zero and another where it is set at 2.5 kg. The context includes concepts of work, potential energy, and forces acting on the block.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • The original poster describes their attempts to analyze the forces acting on the block and calculate potential and kinetic energy states. They express uncertainty about their calculations and interpretations of energy changes. Other participants raise questions about the elastic potential energy of the spring and the role of the pulley system. There are also inquiries about the assumptions made regarding mass and friction.

Discussion Status

Participants are actively engaging with the problem, offering insights and questioning the assumptions made by the original poster. Some guidance has been provided regarding the calculation of elastic potential energy, and there is an ongoing exploration of the forces involved in the system. Multiple interpretations of the problem are being discussed, indicating a productive dialogue.

Contextual Notes

There are mentions of potential missing components in the work-energy analysis and the need to consider the kinetic energy of the block at the moment of release. The discussion also highlights the assumption of a frictionless system and the implications of the spring force not being constant.

magnesium12
Messages
18
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


The system is released from rest with no slack in the cable and with the spring stretched 225 mm. Determine the distance s traveled by the 3.2-kg cart before it comes to rest (a) if m approaches zero and (b) if m = 2.5 kg. Assume no mechanical interference and no friction. The distance s is positive if up the incline, negative if down.
Diagram: https://imgur.com/hniHevB

Homework Equations


W = Fd
W = ΔU + ΔT

The Attempt at a Solution


a)
I drew an FBD of the 3.2kg block, ignoring the other mass entirely. I had a Fs (force of the spring) pointing up the incline, FW (weight of the block) pointing straight down, and N (normal force) pointing upwards normal to the incline.

I defined up the incline to be the positive x-axis. Normal to the incline is the y-axis.

I tried defining the potential energy states (U) and kinetic energy states (T) as it is released and as the block is released (state 1) and after it slides down the incline and comes to a rest (state 2).

U1 = Fs1 = kx1 = (160N/m)(0.225m) = 36N
U2 = Fs2 = kx2 = (160N/m)(s + 0.225m) = (160s)N + 36N
ΔU = U2 - U1 = 160s + 36 - 36 = 160s

T1 = 0.5mv2 = 0 (because v=0 right as it is released)
T2 = 0.5mv2 = 0 (because v=0 when it comes to a rest)
ΔT = 0

W = Fd = Fs(s) + Fws = kss2 + mgs = 160s2 + 3.2kg(9.81)s
= 160s2 + 31.392s

W = ΔU = Fd
160s = 160s2 + 31.392s
Solve for s: 0, 0.80379m (Incorrect Answer)

Can someone point out where I'm going wrong? Is it my interpretation of what s is? Or maybe how I'm calculating the potential and kinetic energies of each state?

b)
I drew another FBD which has the same components as in part a, but with an added uphill tension caused by the force of gravity acting on the second mass (called FT).

Calculating FT from the second mass:
2T + FW,2 = 0
T = FW,2 /2 = 2.5kg(9.81m/s/s)/2 = 12.263I tried defining the potential energy states (U) and kinetic energy states (T) as it is released and as the block is released (state 1) and after it slides down the incline and comes to a rest (state 2).

U1 = Fs1 + FT= kx1 = (160N/m)(0.225m) = 36N + 12.263N = 48.263N
U2 = Fs2 + FT = kx2 = (160N/m)(s + 0.225m) + 12.263N = (160s)N + 48.263N
ΔU = U2 - U1 = 160s + 48.263 - 48.263 = 160s

T1 = 0.5mv2 = 0 (because v=0 right as it is released)
T2 = 0.5mv2 = 0 (because v=0 when it comes to a rest)
ΔT = 0

W = Fd = Fs(s) + Fws + FTs= kss2 + mgs + 12.263 = 160s2 + 3.2kg(9.81)s + 12.263
= 160s2 + 31.392s + 12.263

W = ΔU = Fd
160s = 160s2 + 31.392s +12.263
Solve for s: 0.11056 OR 0.69323m (Incorrect Answers)

I assume I'm doing the same thing wrong here as in part a, but I can't figure out what it is.

Thank you for any help you can give!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What is the elastic PE stored in a spring of constant k and extended or compressed distance x?
 
Is there a mass associated with the pulley? The system is frictionless right? Maybe first define the coordinates of the pulleys and draw free diagram for each one?
 
haruspex said:
What is the elastic PE stored in a spring of constant k and extended or compressed distance x?
Thank you for your help!

Okay, so I figured out the PE of a spring is kx2/2. So for the first case (ignoring the second mass completely), I've now got this:

Potential energy of the block
U1 = kx2/2 = 160(0.225)2/2 = 4.05
U2 = ks2 = 160(s)2/2 = 80s2
ΔU = U2 - U1 = 80s2 - 4.05

Work done on the block by gravity:
Wg = -mgxs = -mgsin(26)s (assuming up the incline is the x-axis)

Work done on the block by the spring:
Ws = Fss = (ks)s = 160s2

ΔU = ΣW
80s2 - 4.05 = 160s2 - mgsin(26)s
0 = 80s2 - 3.2(9.81)sin(26)s + 4.05 <---------------------- gives no solutions.

Is there some other component doing work on the system that I am missing? Or do I need to take into consideration the kinetic energy too? If so, do I need to assume there is a velocity for the block right as the system is released?
 
magnesium12 said:
Work done on the block by the spring:
Ws = Fss = (ks)s = 160s2
You are making the same mistake again. The force the spring exerts is not constant across the range s.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
4K
Replies
6
Views
5K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
4K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
14
Views
4K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K