How hard is a Phd in Mathematics in mit?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the perceived difficulty of pursuing a PhD in mathematics at MIT or other Ivy League universities. Participants explore various aspects of the application process, the challenges of the program itself, and personal experiences related to graduate studies in mathematics.

Discussion Character

  • Debate/contested
  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants assert that getting into a PhD program at MIT is significantly more challenging than at many other institutions, emphasizing the competitive nature of admissions.
  • Others suggest that the difficulty of completing a PhD is subjective and varies from person to person, depending on individual effort and passion for the subject.
  • A participant shares their personal experience of completing a PhD in three years, highlighting the intensity of the process and the need for dedication.
  • Concerns are raised about the admission process, with some participants noting that factors beyond an applicant's control can influence acceptance into a program.
  • Several contributions emphasize the importance of strong letters of recommendation, suggesting that these can significantly impact an applicant's chances of admission.
  • One participant mentions that maintaining a good academic record can still lead to acceptance into a reputable program, even with less stellar letters.
  • There is a mix of light-hearted commentary and references to pop culture, which diverges from the main topic but reflects the community's informal tone.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree that gaining admission to a PhD program is competitive and challenging, but there is no consensus on the overall difficulty of completing the program, as experiences and perceptions vary widely.

Contextual Notes

Participants express differing views on the factors influencing admission and success in PhD programs, indicating a lack of uniformity in experiences and expectations. The discussion includes personal anecdotes that highlight the subjective nature of the PhD journey.

OhNoYaDidn't
Messages
25
Reaction score
0
My question is pretty much what i wrote in the title, I'm wondering how hard a phd in mathematics from mit or an ivy league univ would be.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Getting any PhD from a decent math program, including MIT, is challenging. I don't think this is something that we can easily compare between two schools (as definition of "harder" differs from a person to another person).

Getting INTO a PhD program in mathematics at MIT, on the other hand, is significantly harder than many math PhD programs in US.
 
in general i think it is hard, but doable, to get a phd from any school that admits you, if they do a good job of vetting their applicants. i got into univ of utah in 1974 and finished there in 3 years in 1977, although they thought i should have finished in two. It was the hardest thing i have ever done, but it did eventually work out.

In other words, I presume most phd programs admit you thinking that you will probably finish, if you give it absolutely every ounce of effort that you have. To be more more specific, it is about as hard as anything could possibly be. You have to really enjoy your work to persist in such a task.
 
PieceOfPi said:
Getting INTO a PhD program in mathematics at MIT, on the other hand, is significantly harder than many math PhD programs in US.

That is the question that I worry about; that is, what program (if any) will I be able to gain admission to? I worry less about succeeding once I'm accepted. Not out of any misplaced confidence, but simply because I have some measure of control over that outcome whereas being accepted to a PhD program seems to be, to a certain extent, out of my hands. (Or at least strongly influenced by factors that I have little control over.)
 
I think the most important part of your application is your letter of recommendations. If you want to get into any particular graduate school, the best way to increase your odds is to have an excellent letter written by someone who is well known (and liked) by that institution. Most anything can be overlooked with strong enough letters.

I have just been accepted into graduate school, so I'm no authority. In my defense I became very close to my advisor and learned a lot about the process from his experience.
 
you are ignoring the gist of my comment about vetting. namely schools take people that seem likely to succeed. hence by making yourself more qualified, you increase the likelihood of admission.
 
mathwonk said:
you are ignoring the gist of my comment about vetting. namely schools take people that seem likely to succeed. hence by making yourself more qualified, you increase the likelihood of admission.

I see my confusion, I mixed up Mallus with the OP who referred only to being accepted. In any case, I think it's easier to convince the search committee that you will succeed in their program if someone they know (and trust) vouches for you.
 
OhNoYaDidn't said:
My question is pretty much what i wrote in the title, I'm wondering how hard a phd in mathematics from mit or an ivy league univ would be.
Seven.
 
I think that you already know the answer. Notice how you didn't word the question, "How easy would a phd in mathematics from mit or an ivy league univ be?" but "how hard would it be?"

I'm 16, but even I know that you're going to have to work your *** off, and that it could easily be the most difficult thing that you'll have to do in your life. Maybe not for everybody, but judging by the fact that you have self-doubt about your capabilities, then I doubt it will just be a breeze for you.

In the end, you'll never know until you apply, either get rejected/accepted, and actually go through the program. Second-hand accounts will never be able to apply for you, because other people AREN'T you. Your abilities are different from theirs, as is your work ethic, etc. First hand experience is going to be the best answer to your question.
 
  • #10
Timo said:
Seven.
No no no. It is over Nine Thousand...
 
  • #11
Sankaku said:
It is over Nine Thousand...

Lol. I do remember when my friend spammed that phrase every 5 minutes. >.<

For people who don't know, it's from a parody of DBZ.
 
  • #12
Nano-Passion said:
Lol. I do remember when my friend spammed that phrase every 5 minutes. >.<

For people who don't know, it's from a parody of DBZ.

Followed by Vegeta getting crapped on by Goku of course.
 
  • #13
I second the advice about letters of recommendation. Especially because there are extremely terrific applicants of very different shapes, the letters indicating a good fit for the program are the most crucial thing, once you have good coursework, grades, and scores. I have seen applicants of various resumes get rejected from universities like MIT. Aside from the very few true prodigies out there, I think aside from having spectacular awards or publications, most of us are in the same boat admissions-wise aside from the letters. Keep in mind it's not just how good your letters are, but how they are received by admissions (hence a lot of variables that you have no control over -- apply to a good number of schools that you could be happy at, and you'll probably be fine).

However, simply maintaining a great record from a terrific undergraduate mathematics program with strong but not stellar letters can still get you into a great program for PhD.
 
  • #14
DeadOriginal said:
Followed by Vegeta getting crapped on by Goku of course.

I remember it going the other way in that particular fight actually. Just saiyan.
 
  • #15
clope023 said:
I remember it going the other way in that particular fight actually. Just saiyan.

Just saiyan. lol I like that. Vegeta was getting killed until he went ape. Then yea... Goku ate monkey poo.


To the OP: Work hard everyday and everyday it'll be a little easier to get into MIT because everyday you'll be strengthening your foundation.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
4K
Replies
25
Views
7K
  • · Replies 53 ·
2
Replies
53
Views
9K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
4K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
6K