How to interpret the integral of the absolute value?

10 replies · 2K views · last reply
SeM
This is rather basic, and may be a misconception of the notation, however, I can't make the following sum up:

The following is given:

x_n(t) = 1 -nt , (if 0 <= t <= 1/n) and 0, (if 1/n < t <= 1)

However, this part I can't grasp this part in the book:

\begin{equation}
||x_n||^2 = \int_0^1 |x_n(t)|^2 dt = \frac{1}{3n}
\end{equation}

I tried it, and got a different answer, where i integrated ##|x_n(t)|^2=(1-nt)^2 = 1-2nt-n^2t^2##:

\begin{equation}
||x_n||^2 = \int_0^1 1-2nt-n^2t^2 dt = t - nt^2 -n^2t^2/3 = 1 - n - n^2/3
\end{equation}

The right answer is however given in the first integral. What did I do wrong here?

Thanks!
 
It should be $$
||x_n||^2 = \int_0^{1/n} 1-2nt+n^2t^2 dt
$$
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Delta2 and SeM
Ok! Thanks! Then its a typo.
 
Attachments
  • Textbook page 568 showing a proof that the derivative operator is unbounded, with a piecewise definition of x_n(t) and a plot labelled Fig. 69 of a function dropping from 1 at t=0 to 0 at t=1/n.
    Untitled.jpg
    21.8 KB · Views: 671
SeM said:
That's what I thought, then either the book is wrong (which I doubt), or this is a different notation. Let me scan it and upload it here in the next reply.

Wait, how did you get books answer ?
 
Buffu said:
Wait, how did you books answer ?
Attached
Textbook page 568 showing the proof that the derivative operator is unbounded, with the function x_n(t) equal to 1 minus nt on [0, 1/n] and 0 beyond, and a small graph of x_n against t dropping from 1 at t = 0 to 0 at t = 1/n.
 
Attachments
  • Textbook page 568 showing the proof that the derivative operator is unbounded, with the function x_n(t) equal to 1 minus nt on [0, 1/n] and 0 beyond, and a small graph of x_n against t dropping from 1 at t = 0 to 0 at t = 1/n.
    Untitled.jpg
    21.8 KB · Views: 558
SeM said:
This is rather basic, and may be a misconception of the notation, however, I can't make the following sum up:

The following is given:

x_n(t) = 1 -nt , (if 0 <= t <= 1/n) and 0, (if 1/n < t <= 1)

However, this part I can't grasp this part in the book:

\begin{equation}
||x_n||^2 = \int_0^1 |x_n(t)|^2 dt = \frac{1}{3n}
\end{equation}

I tried it, and got a different answer, where i integrated ##|x_n(t)|^2=(1-nt)^2 = 1-2nt-n^2t^2##:

\begin{equation}
||x_n||^2 = \int_0^1 1-2nt-n^2t^2 dt = t - nt^2 -n^2t^2/3 = 1 - n - n^2/3
\end{equation}

The right answer is however given in the first integral. What did I do wrong here?

Thanks!
There is a sign error, since ##(1-nt)^2=1-2nt+n^2t^2## and as @Buffu said: ##||x_n||^2 = \int_0^1 = \int_0^{\frac{1}{n}}##.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: SeM and Buffu
fresh_42 said:
There is a sign error, since ##(1-nt)^2=1-2nt+n^2t^2## and as @Buffu said: ##||x_n||^2 = \int_0^1 = \int_0^{\frac{1}{n}}##.

Yes, I also copied the error. Now corrected it in my post.
 
Thanks! I have corrected it in the book. It's Kreyszig Introduction to Functional Analysis, as part of the discussions with George Jones.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Buffu said:
Wait, how did you get books answer ?

Hi Buffu, something is odd with the step "and the quotient" yielding the answer >n. Here I got: n/1/3n = 3n^2. but the book says differently again. It appears as an error, can you see if this is yet another error?
 
SeM said:
Hi Buffu, something is odd with the step "and the quotient" yielding the answer >n. Here I got: n/1/3n = 3n^2. but the book says differently again. It appears as an error, can you see if this is yet another error?

You forgot to take the square root. The integral gives norm squared; you need ratio of norms not of norms squared.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: SeM