Discussion Overview
The discussion focuses on setting up a triple integral to find the volume of a solid bounded by specific equations in the first octant. Participants explore different bounds and integrals related to the equations z = 4 - x^2 and y = 4 - x^2, as well as z = 4 - y^2.
Discussion Character
- Technical explanation, Debate/contested, Mathematical reasoning
Main Points Raised
- One participant proposes the volume integral setup as V = ∫₀² ∫₀⁴⁻ˣ² ∫₀⁴⁻ʸ² dz dy dx, detailing the bounds for z, y, and x.
- Another participant suggests an alternative setup with z = 4 - y² and discusses the implications of the bounds in the first octant.
- There is a correction regarding the equations used, with a participant noting a typo in their earlier post, clarifying that z = 4 - x² should be used instead of z = 4 - y².
- Multiple participants mention using Wolfram Alpha (W|A) to evaluate the integral, with differing results: one participant claims W|A gives I = 64/35, while another states the textbook answer is 256/15.
- Discrepancies in the results from W|A and the textbook answer are highlighted, with participants questioning the accuracy of their setups and calculations.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express disagreement regarding the correct volume calculation, with multiple competing views on the setup of the integral and the resulting values from evaluations. No consensus is reached on the correct answer.
Contextual Notes
Participants note potential confusion due to similar problems and the importance of correctly identifying the equations and bounds for the integral setup.