Hydrostatic Paradox in Fluid mechanics

  • Level: High School 
  • Thread starter Tiny_Explorer
  • Start date
2 replies · 140 views · last reply
Tiny_Explorer
Messages
18
Reaction score
5
TL;DR
How the hydrostatic Paradox works ? The textbook language seems less descriptive and idealistic. How to understand it ?
The NCERT India Physics Class 11 Physics Textbook says this in chapter " Mechanical Properties of Fluids " , " consider 3 vessels A B and C of different shapes. They are connected at the bottom by a horizontal pipe. On filling with water,the level in the three vessels is the same, though they hold different amounts of water. This is so because water at the bottom has the same pressure below each section of the vessel.
 
If the pressure at the bottom were different in one of the vessels, then water would flow in the horizontal pipe from the high-pressure vessel to the low-pressure vessel.
 
Imagine some arbitrary shaped vessel filled to some level with water. The water surface is flat. Now insert a thin and not necessarily flat wall dividing the vessel in two. In fact, let's build the wall in place in the vessel piece by piece, perhaps using small flat sections that we glue together edge to edge, not necessarily forming a plane.

Suppose that you believe that two connected vessels could have different water levels. When does the water level change happen as we build up our wall? When we add our first piece? When we add the last-but-one piece? (We have to leave one piece out so there's a connection.) How does the water know when to change levels as we build up our wall?

Of course, in practice you would observe that the water level didn't change. But there's no difference between our almost completely divided vessel and two connected vessels, so we conclude that the two connected vessels will have equal water levels.

Formally, you can show that water pressure depends on depth and not cross-sectional shape. Thus (as Dale says) if the two vessels have different depths of water there would be a net force on the water in the connecting tube and water would flow until the pressures are equal.