MHB IGCSE Probability Question [ either / or ]

  • Thread starter Thread starter shoshuban
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Igcse Probability
AI Thread Summary
Captain Ahab's probability of seeing a dolphin is 9/10, a whale is 2/3, and a turtle is 1/5. The calculated probability of seeing either a dolphin or a whale is 29/30, which raises questions as the sum of the individual probabilities exceeds 1. This discrepancy occurs because adding the probabilities directly counts the overlap of seeing both a dolphin and a whale twice. The mark scheme's methods correctly account for this overlap by subtracting the joint probability of seeing both. Understanding these methods clarifies the calculations and resolves the confusion regarding the total probability exceeding one.
shoshuban
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Captain Ahab sails The Laertes along the south coast of Madeira. On any day, the probability of him seeing a dolphin is 9/10 , the probability of him seeing a whale is 2/3 and the probability of him seeing a turtle is 1/5.
Q. Calculate the probability that on any day Captain Ahab will see either a dolphin or a whale.

The answer, according to the mark scheme, is 29/30.

Weirdly, if we add the three probabilities, it shows a value more than 1 ! ( 9/10 + 2/3 + 1/5 = 53/30 ! )

I have tried doing this. Trial 1 :
P( dolphin or whale) = 9/10 + 2/3 = 47/30, which is obviously not correct.

Trial 2:
P [(dolphin and no whale) or (whale and no dolphin)]
= (9/10 x 1/3) + ( 2/3 x 1/10 ) = 11/30 ( which doesn't agree with the mark scheme )

The methods shown in the mark scheme is :
Method 1 -> ( 9/10 x 1/3 ) + 2/3 = 29/30.
Method 2 -> 1-(1/10 x 1/3) = 29/30

Please explain me what's happening here.
1) Why is the total probability more than one in the first place
2) how do the mark scheme methods make sense?
3) What was I doing wrong in my Trial 2?
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
To explain why the 2 probabilities simply added is more than 1, let's look at a Venn Diagram:

View attachment 5014

The probability we want is the sum of the 3 colored areas. If we add the probabilities represented by the two circles, we are adding the green area twice, which represents the probability of seeing both a whale and a dolphin, so we need to subtract it out:

$$P(X)=\frac{9}{10}+\frac{2}{3}-\frac{9}{10}\cdot\frac{2}{3}=\frac{9}{10}\left(1-\frac{2}{3}\right)+\frac{2}{3}=\frac{9}{10}\cdot\frac{1}{3}+\frac{2}{3}=\frac{29}{30}$$

This was the first method used on the marking scheme.

The second method relies on the fact that it is certain either a dolphin or a whale will be spotted OR neither will be spotted, which we may state as:

$$P(X)+\frac{1}{10}\cdot\frac{1}{3}=1$$

Solving for $P(X)$, we then obtain:

$$P(X)=\frac{29}{30}$$
 

Attachments

  • dolphinwhale.png
    dolphinwhale.png
    1,005 bytes · Views: 112
Seemingly by some mathematical coincidence, a hexagon of sides 2,2,7,7, 11, and 11 can be inscribed in a circle of radius 7. The other day I saw a math problem on line, which they said came from a Polish Olympiad, where you compute the length x of the 3rd side which is the same as the radius, so that the sides of length 2,x, and 11 are inscribed on the arc of a semi-circle. The law of cosines applied twice gives the answer for x of exactly 7, but the arithmetic is so complex that the...
Back
Top