I'm a homesteader/prepper ask me anything

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ftheog
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary
The discussion revolves around the distinction between homesteading and survivalism, emphasizing a proactive, community-oriented approach rather than a fear-based mindset. Participants express a desire to thrive and prepare for various challenges, focusing on practical skills and self-sufficiency. There is a notable interest in the socio-economic aspects of prepping, with some members questioning whether this trend is predominantly American or present in other cultures. The conversation also touches on the importance of knowledge acquisition, with participants sharing their experiences and resources for learning essential skills. Overall, the thread highlights a commitment to a simpler, more sustainable lifestyle while addressing common misconceptions about preppers.
  • #31
Proton Soup said:
yeah, but were you into this: http://www.countrysidemag.com/

every own any Firefox books, or stuff like that?

I have all originals of firefox as well digital copies, I use to read mother Earth news, but it has become to politicized and bogged down by advertisers, I prefer backwoodshome today
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #32
Ivan Seeking said:
I'm a pepper. I didn't know we were into homesteading now as a group.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gQPN3UKQM-U

I love dr prepper!
 
  • #33
Don't let Ivan fool you, he lives in the wilds and has more guns and ammo than most military bases.
 
  • #34
micromass said:
Good question! How did you come to the decision to start prepping, and why?

we always wanted to get to a more sustainable way of life, but we had a big push in 2005, at the time, my wife and I had some investments in apt buildings. We refinanced one and since we were self employed, the mortgage broker said we would go stated income. I asked him what that was. He responded, just tell me how much you make. My wife and I looked at him and said how many people are doing this, he responded, everyone. We knew at that point things were going to get rough
 
  • #35
Ftheog said:
I grew up on our family farm and somehow got away from it. My wife had surgery on her shoulder in the mid 90's and I went and bought a book on log homes to read during it. In the back was a small section on cordwood building, it listed rob roy in new york as a proponent on that. I called information, got his number and called him. We talked about a hour and he said he had a book on the method and also had one on underground homes, I ordered both, read them from front to back for 2 years straight planning our home. When my daughter was born in 97, We were living outside philly and didn't want to raise her in a urban setting, so it grew from there

The way you describe things to me actually implies that you just wanted to be self-sufficient and more in touch with nature. Which is always a good thing. I can understand now why it is more a lifestyle then actually preparing for something bad.

When reading the forums where you came from, I saw some people who I would describe as (excuse me) a bit obsessed with prepping. I read statements like "I like people who prep, it will save me bullets down the road". I don't think such a people are very good advertisement for preppers, it makes you look crazy and obsessed... That's why I really appreciate normal people like you explaining things in a normal non-obsessed manner.
 
  • #36
Ftheog said:
I don't walk around with a billboard, but I try and show as many people as I can what we are doing. One of the complaints from our side of the table on the show was opsec. My position is knowledge has to start somewhere. I figure if I can change one persons perspective, it was worth it. Funny thing, when we were building our house, when I would show people, I would get one of two reactions. people that got it, or people thought I was insane. The people that got it were all over 50 and remembered times, the other group was all 40 and under and knew nothing more than instant gratification and the buy it now on credit group.

my wife is totally onboard, she has the same concerns as me. my daughter thought I was crazy, we didn't push anything on her, she just couldn't understand why we had a huge pantry and her friends didn't. Until the swine flu scare 2 years ago. We had outbreaks in the surrounding school districts and her school sent home papers about what to do in case of a outbreak, it listed 2 weeks of food, water supply ect. She came home, looked at the pantry and said, I guess we are all set, I said yep, she said, I'll never question you again dad
My wife and I have months of food stored away, both prepared and basic raw foods. We don't do this because we are convinced that horrible things are going to happen to us. We do this because that's how our families prepared for their own futures, year-to-year. When your parents have been through the great depression, they instill some attitudes in you that tend to stick. My grandmother had a HUGE pantry loaded with staples, and the French-Canadian great-aunts on my mother's side were just as fanatical about keeping staples on-hand. If you asked any of them for a few pounds of sugar, salt, a quart or two of vinegar, molasses, etc, they would look at you like you were asking if they had a penny in their pocket. After the great depression came the rationing imposed by the war effort in WWII. Those women weren't going to be restricted from cooking their traditional foods by political pressures.

As I said on another thread, I always have boxes of coarse non-iodized salt around because I like making pickles. My grandmother and great-aunts had LOTS more salt around because they salted down meats and made sauerkraut.
 
  • #37
Math Is Hard said:
I'm a mini-prepper since I live in earthquake country. Maybe more of a micro-prepper. Maybe just preppish tendencies. I guess I'm a prepper AND a Pepper, with a stack of Diet DP 12-packs in the kitchen corner.

I don't have a chainsaw, but I do have a crossbow. When civilization falls apart there will still be good eatin' Chez MIH, if you like baked beans and squirrel-on-a-stick.


that's the thing, the show glamorized and highlighted what they were looking for, some of the people on the show have come forward and said things were staged. If it's reality tv, why do they need writers? What you need in EQ country is different than what I need in my area, but who has the right to tell us what we need to make us feel safe?
 
  • #38
Evo said:
It sounds like we do what you do, but because we think it's an enjoyable normal lifestyle, we like to be self sufficient, like to see the results of our labors, not that we're afraid of anything.

This is our natural choice. We choose to be informed and self sufficient. We don't do it because we fear a doomsday scenario.

That's where I see a difference. If things got bad, we'd shared and help anyone we could, not kill them.

Our choices aren't driven by fear.

my goal is to help the community in time of needs, it's why we planted 20 fruit trees not just 2, it's why we keep adding raise beds each year, a lot of people on this side have the same mindset, but at the end of the day you need to make sure you and your family is taken care of in times of need
 
  • #39
Ftheog said:
that's the thing, the show glamorized and highlighted what they were looking for, some of the people on the show have come forward and said things were staged. If it's reality tv, why do they need writers? What you need in EQ country is different than what I need in my area, but who has the right to tell us what we need to make us feel safe?
I think a major problem with the show is that a lot of it was, we're not sharing! This is ours and anyone that needs anything, we're going to kill them! It's OURS! And then these people have their own youtube videos instructing people on how to arm themselves and be prepared to kill people, not hunt for food, kill humans. They can't blame their websites on the show.

That's why I am giving you the opportunity to say you are not like these people, you don't own guns to kill people that need help.

Think back to the Great Depression, did you see neighbors murdering each other? How about the potato famine in Ireland, they didn't kill each other. During the great famine during the little Ice Age in Europe (14th-15th century), people didn't kill each other. These people all did what little they could to help. They changed their agriculture, they moved. but they didn't become hoarding murderers. I think that is what the average person cannot accept.
 
Last edited:
  • #40
micromass said:
The way you describe things to me actually implies that you just wanted to be self-sufficient and more in touch with nature. Which is always a good thing. I can understand now why it is more a lifestyle then actually preparing for something bad.

When reading the forums where you came from, I saw some people who I would describe as (excuse me) a bit obsessed with prepping. I read statements like "I like people who prep, it will save me bullets down the road". I don't think such a people are very good advertisement for preppers, it makes you look crazy and obsessed... That's why I really appreciate normal people like you explaining things in a normal non-obsessed manner.

you also have to realize the media it is on, the internet offers anonymity that we have never had in the history of the world, someone says something 50 years ago, they were right in front of you and you could respond, now it's just words on a screen. There is a lot of people that talk up the truth on the internet to impress people no matter where you are on the intertubes
 
  • #41
turbo-1 said:
My wife and I have months of food stored away, both prepared and basic raw foods. We don't do this because we are convinced that horrible things are going to happen to us. We do this because that's how our families prepared for their own futures, year-to-year. When your parents have been through the great depression, they instill some attitudes in you that tend to stick. My grandmother had a HUGE pantry loaded with staples, and the French-Canadian great-aunts on my mother's side were just as fanatical about keeping staples on-hand. If you asked any of them for a few pounds of sugar, salt, a quart or two of vinegar, molasses, etc, they would look at you like you were asking if they had a penny in their pocket. After the great depression came the rationing imposed by the war effort in WWII. Those women weren't going to be restricted from cooking their traditional foods by political pressures.

As I said on another thread, I always have boxes of coarse non-iodized salt around because I like making pickles. My grandmother and great-aunts had LOTS more salt around because they salted down meats and made sauerkraut.

how did we go from this to everything needed now, right at this instant, instant gratification, no one knows how to cook anymore or even where their food comes from it, it's sad
 
  • #42
Evo said:
I think a major problem with the show is that a lot of it was, we're not sharing! This is ours and anyone that needs anything, we're going to kill them! It's OURS! And then these people have their own youtube videos instructing people on how to arm themselves and be prepared to kill people, not hunt for food, kill humans. They can't blame their websites on the show.

That's why I am giving you the opportunity to say you are not like these people, you don't own guns to kill people that need help.

Think back to the Great Depression, did you see neighbors murdering each other? How about the potato famine in Ireland, they didn't kill each other. During the great famine during the little Ice Age in Europe (14th-15th century), people didn't kill each other. These people all did what little they could to help. They changed their agriculture, they moved. but they didn't become hoarding murderers. I think that is what the average person cannot accept.

don't get me wrong evo, I own guns, and there is a difference between someone coming for help and someone coming to take, if you have a chance google ferfal, he's a blogger living in argentina and went through the socio-economic collapse there in 2001, he has a lot of first hand experience of how bad it could get
 
  • #43
Those are macro (economic) -social problems (unrest after any collapse) to be solved by government and various social organizations.

I am not convinced that ammunition stock solves that problem, on contrary it might worsen the problem.
 
  • #44
rootX said:
Those are macroeconomic and social problems (unrest after any collapse) to be solved by government and various social organizations.

I am not convinced that ammunition stock solves that problem, on contrary it might worsen the problem.

we'll agree to disagree
 
  • #45
and why the heck is my post count stuck on 31?
 
  • #46
People in South America tend to have a different mindset than Americans. If I lived there I'd probably think differently.

Basically, many of the people on this forum live close to the land if possible, just because they enjoy it and for no other reason.

Obviously college kids don't have that option. But those of us that are older and settled prefer to do things for ourselves, share with our neighbors, and help strangers in need, even if it means we have less for ourselves.

When I think back to WWII and all of the people that lost their lives to take in and protect complete strangers, it brings tears to my eyes. I don't know if I would ever have that much courage.
 
Last edited:
  • #47
Ftheog said:
and why the heck is my post count stuck on 31?

Posts in general discussion don't count for post count. :frown:
 
  • #48
Ftheog said:
we'll agree to disagree

Unless you want to provide some solid evidence behind your arguments. :smile: Otherwise, I am happy not to discuss it further.
 
  • #49
Ftheog said:
you also have to realize the media it is on, the internet offers anonymity that we have never had in the history of the world, someone says something 50 years ago, they were right in front of you and you could respond, now it's just words on a screen. There is a lot of people that talk up the truth on the internet to impress people no matter where you are on the intertubes

I understand that perfectly well, but I'm just saying that it doesn't do you good. Let's say I was trying to find more information for preppers because I might become one. I go on that forum and I see statements about killing people because they are in the way. I'd be disgusted and I would leave, and I would think preppers are crazy (which they are most definitely not).

Anyway, another question. I would think that preppers are mostly right-wing in politics. Am I correct on that?
 
  • #50
rootX said:
Those are macro (economic) -social problems (unrest after any collapse) to be solved by government and various social organizations.

I am not convinced that ammunition stock solves that problem, on contrary it might worsen the problem.

actually, I'll tell you a quick story. Last summer my wife and daughter were away at her parents. I got off work late and missed deadliest catch(rip phil harris) I decided to stay up till 12:00 to watch the late showing. About half way thru my eyes started getting tired, so I decided to get to bed. I went in the bathroom and started brushing my teeth. At that moment I heard our side buzzer go off, we have a driveway alarm there, because with being a earthen bermed house, we can't see if someone is coming around. I figured it was my father coming home.About 10 seconds later my dog starts going insane, I walk out the bathroom and the front motion light is on but no one is out there. I look in my fathers room and he's sitting there on the computer. I switch the tv over to security cameras and see someone coming towards our front door with a screwdriver in his hand. He was turning towards our front door, when my dog started going nuts, and then ran off into the woods. I called 911. "911 what is your emergency?" I just had a intruder on my property and it looked like they were trying to come in the front door. " Is your property posted sir?" excuse me? " is your property posted sir?" yes, but what the heck does that have to do with anything? "just checking, we'll send someone right out"

The police and govt are not a protective force, they are a responsive force, it is up to us as individuals to make sure our loved ones are taken care of and safe
 
  • #51
rootX said:
Unless you want to provide some solid evidence behind your arguments. :smile: Otherwise, I am happy not to discuss it further.

I would, but I have a feeling it would be deleted quick (I'm looking at you evo)
 
  • #52
that was a joke, don't ban me

[PLAIN]http://images.sodahead.com/polls/001847503/467500348_come_to_the_dark_side_we_have_cookies_208415_answer_2_xlarge.jpeg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #53
As far as living through disasters, I lived in Houston, TX the first half of my life. I lived through a Cat 5 hurricane, my aunt and uncle were visiting and my mother insisted they leave the apartment his job had put them in and stay with us. They had a second floor apartment, after the storm, there was no second floor. We cooked on a tiny grill set on the toilet of the hall bath under a window, we lived in a pine forest and most of it ended up on top of our house.

I've lived through many othjer hurricanes, floods, I had to canoe to a 7-11 to buy formula for my baby. I've been through the blizzard of the century in upstate NY in 1993, only to move to the flood of the century a month later. My youngest was born during a blizzard.

I've had to heat a room with candles during blizzards where electricity and communications where knocked out, I put a couple of bricks in the fireplace and rigged a wire mesh to make a grill so I could cook food for my kids. I was never scared, and I made it a fun time for them. My only worry was that it would warm up and the food in my freezer might go bad. I had enough prepared food to feed an army because I like to buy lots when stuff is on sale, I'm frugal.
 
  • #54
Ftheog said:
actually, I'll tell you a quick story. Last summer my wife and daughter were away at her parents. I got off work late and missed deadliest catch(rip phil harris) I decided to stay up till 12:00 to watch the late showing. About half way thru my eyes started getting tired, so I decided to get to bed. I went in the bathroom and started brushing my teeth. At that moment I heard our side buzzer go off, we have a driveway alarm there, because with being a earthen bermed house, we can't see if someone is coming around. I figured it was my father coming home.About 10 seconds later my dog starts going insane, I walk out the bathroom and the front motion light is on but no one is out there. I look in my fathers room and he's sitting there on the computer. I switch the tv over to security cameras and see someone coming towards our front door with a screwdriver in his hand. He was turning towards our front door, when my dog started going nuts, and then ran off into the woods. I called 911. "911 what is your emergency?" I just had a intruder on my property and it looked like they were trying to come in the front door. " Is your property posted sir?" excuse me? " is your property posted sir?" yes, but what the heck does that have to do with anything? "just checking, we'll send someone right out"

The police and govt are not a protective force, they are a responsive force, it is up to us as individuals to make sure our loved ones are taken care of and safe
If you are in an area that draws certain types, and/or it's know that you are a prepper so could have lots of cash, guns, and other valuables stockplied, you would be a target. This is especially true if you are not part of a close knit community where everyone has your back.
 
  • #55
micromass said:
I understand that perfectly well, but I'm just saying that it doesn't do you good. Let's say I was trying to find more information for preppers because I might become one. I go on that forum and I see statements about killing people because they are in the way. I'd be disgusted and I would leave, and I would think preppers are crazy (which they are most definitely not).

Anyway, another question. I would think that preppers are mostly right-wing in politics. Am I correct on that?

you are correct on that, there are people on the fringe of all groups, that's why I search out homesteading, animal husbandry, ect. Unfortunately there is a gray area between what I believe and what the hardcore survivalist believes. Don't get me wrong, there are some people like the ones portrayed in the show, but it is unjustified to paint everyone with the same stroke of the brush
 
  • #56
micromass said:
I

Anyway, another question. I would think that preppers are mostly right-wing in politics. Am I correct on that?

forgot this part, yes I would agree a lot of preppers are conservative and want a small govt and less intrusion on personal rights and freedoms. I don't get wrapped up in the whole republican versus democrat, they both serve their own interests.
 
  • #57
Evo said:
As far as living through disasters, I lived in Houston, TX the first half of my life. I lived through a Cat 5 hurricane, my aunt and uncle were visiting and my mother insisted they leave the apartment his job had put them in and stay with us. They had a second floor apartment, after the storm, there was no second floor. We cooked on a tiny grill set on the toilet of the hall bath under a window, we lived in a pine forest and most of it ended up on top of our house.

I've lived through many othjer hurricanes, floods, I had to canoe to a 7-11 to buy formula for my baby. I've been through the blizzard of the century in upstate NY in 1993, only to move to the flood of the century a month later. My youngest was born during a blizzard.

I've had to heat a room with candles during blizzards where electricity and communications where knocked out, I put a couple of bricks in the fireplace and rigged a wire mesh to make a grill so I could cook food for my kids. I was never scared, and I made it a fun time for them. My only worry was that it would warm up and the food in my freezer might go bad. I had enough prepared food to feed an army because I like to buy lots when stuff is on sale, I'm frugal.

I knew you were a prepper, doth protest to much.


seriously though, I just take it to the next level, I plan for outages for a month or more. We had a ice storm that left us without power for 6 weeks
 
  • #58
It's almost time for me to watch the new ridiculous tv reality cooking show. I need soemthing to laugh at. I think they have run out of ideas.

Rock the Block: Chefs must cook with unmarked canned goods when they're dropped off in a neighborhood in Newhall, Cal. Later, they must knock on residents' doors to gather cooking materials, and prepare hot appetizers on the block of a car engine

Thanks ftheog for sharing. I'd like to hear more about your garden, your farm animals, I expect you can and preserve most of your food? Turbo does all of his own, he does not eat processed food. He catches fish in the wild, hunts for wild animals, he lives off the land. He does all of his own butchering and preserving. So, we'd love to hear about what you do.

Myself, I want to have goats and cows and make my own cheese. My grandmother had her own cows, chickens, etc... She lived in an ancient stone lodge in the Alps and cooked on a wood stove. No bathtubs, no showers, you heated water on the stove, then poured some into a basin. No running water, no toilets. I was never happier than when I was there. No tv, no telephone, no means of communication. Just working in the garden, collecting eggs, and helping around the house. I'm an expert egg candler, learned that as soon as I could hold an egg.
 
  • #59
Evo said:
If you are in an area that draws certain types, and/or it's know that you are a prepper so could have lots of cash, guns, and other valuables stockplied, you would be a target. This is especially true if you are not part of a close knit community where everyone has your back.

I live in a rural new england town of 3000 people. It's not known what we have, just that we try and live self sustainable and garden and raise animals. We recognized the person, it was the town managers son who has a drug problem and has been arrested numerous times for breaking and entering. Let's be real here, people are getting shot for 10 dollars, you see that in the news all the time.
 
  • #60
actually. I got to let the dogs out and put the pigs and chickens up for the night, i'll check back on this later, peace