allisrelative
- 26
- 3
Is there some rule I should know about first? All of the good threads seem to be locked and what can I do to avoid starting a debate just to get it locked?
I'm new and want to post but there's so many threads locked
- Thread starter allisrelative
- Start date
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Start your own thread to ask a follow-up.
5 replies · 2K views
Discussion
Motore
- 220
- 222
Hello and welcome to PF.
I suggest you follow these rules and your thread should be fine:
https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/physics-forums-global-guidelines.414380/
I suggest you follow these rules and your thread should be fine:
https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/physics-forums-global-guidelines.414380/
Science Advisor
- 8,740
- 4,863
As long as there is relevant discussion, threads are usually kept alive. Many of the initially good threads were locked when they started to run in circles or got off-topic.
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
- 8,715
- 2,172
allisrelative said:
As mentioned, check out the posting rules. In the quantum sections, these tend to be enforced a bit more strictly within PF.
NOT TO WORRY! There is PLENTY of room for discussion within the rules. I might suggest that you wade in during your first posts. Learn the lay of the land. Don't get emotional about replies to your posts. The intellectual swords swing mightily here, but it's all for everyone's good. You will sharpen your quantum thinking quickly by reading what others have to say - regardless of whether you agree or even understand their reasoning.
- 2,188
- 2,694
In PF, there are three main reasons of locking a thread:allisrelative said:
1. It has deviated from the main topic, or the same thing was being discussed in circles without coming to any conclusion, as stated in post #3,
2. It violates the guidelines.
3. Locked because of inactivity, as stated in post #4.
There are a lot of threads that are open for discussion. In addition, you are welcome to create your own threads.If you have a question/want to discuss something you found in a locked thread, you can create a new thread, put a reference to the locked thread (or a specific post therein), and start off. However, note that your new thread should follow the guidelines, otherwise it may be closed by the moderators. In the past, the rules were less strict, so you may find old threads that violate the current guidelines but are locked due to inactivity instead of violation of rules. You should not start a discussion on such threads. If you are unsure whether the topic that you want to discuss is allowed or not, you can contact a moderator privately before posting the thread.
As a rule of thumb, anything in mainstream STEM is allowed.