Inelastic collision. Two angle variables.

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves an inelastic collision between two cars of equal mass, where one car travels north and the other at an angle south of east. The objective is to express the final velocity of the combined system in terms of the initial velocity and one angle, while eliminating the other angle from the equations derived from momentum conservation.

Discussion Character

  • Mixed

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the decomposition of final velocity into components and the relationships between the angles and speeds involved in the collision. There are attempts to isolate variables and manipulate equations to eliminate one of the angles.

Discussion Status

Participants are actively exploring different algebraic manipulations and substitutions to simplify the equations. There is recognition of the challenge in eliminating the angle phi, with some suggesting squaring equations and using trigonometric identities. Multiple interpretations of the equations are being examined without a clear consensus on the best approach.

Contextual Notes

Some participants express confusion over the algebraic steps involved, particularly regarding the cancellation of terms when squaring the equations. The discussion reflects the complexity of the problem and the constraints of expressing the final velocity in the desired form.

ttttrigg3r
Messages
48
Reaction score
0
http://session.masteringphysics.com/problemAsset/1007938/22/6318.jpg
Two cars, both of mass m, collide and stick together. Prior to the collision, one car had been traveling north at speed 2v, while the second was traveling at speed v at an angle phi south of east (as indicated in the figure). After the collision, the two-car system travels at speed v_final at an angle theta east of north.

Now I solved Vfinal into its i and j components

i: vicos\phi=2vfcos\theta

j: 2vi-sin\phivi=2(vfsin\theta)

The problem is if I solve for vfinal, I get the answer in terms of Vinitial, phi, and theta. The problem only asks for Vfinal in Vinitial and theta. How do I get rid of phi to only have theta and Vi?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I think you changed the equations.It should be
i: vicosϕ=2vfsinθ
j: 2vi-sinϕvi=2(vfcosθ)
And my sugestion to get rid of phi is to isolate cosϕ on eq.i and use the fundamental relation cos²ϕ+sin²ϕ=1 to find sinϕ, and then substitute sinϕ on eq.j.
 
do you mean isolate cos(phi) and square it, and then isolate sin(phi) and then square it and then sub it into cos^2phi + sin^2phi =1? I did that but then I got an equation Vf and Vf^2 . The fraction looks unsolvable for Vf. Cannot factor or anything.
 
if i am not wrong

you can rearrange it to

2vi - 2vfcos(t) = vsin(phi)

2vfsin(t) = vcos(phi)

square both sides

your right hand side will be vi2 , since c and s cancel

your left hand side will be

4vi2 + 4vf2 - 8vivfcos(t)

this is quadratic, so use -b+- squareroot b^2 - 4ac over 2a.
 
quietrain said:
if i am not wrong

you can rearrange it to

2vi - 2vfcos(t) = vsin(phi)

2vfsin(t) = vcos(phi)

square both sides

your right hand side will be vi2 , since c and s cancel

your left hand side will be

4vi2 + 4vf2 - 8vivfcos(t)

this is quadratic, so use -b+- squareroot b^2 - 4ac over 2a.

I don't see how the sin and cos cancel when you square it? There must be a step I'm missing because if you square the first equation, on the right side you get Vi2sin\phi. On the left side you would get a long quadratic with variables Vi, Vf, and theta.
 
ttttrigg3r said:
I don't see how the sin and cos cancel when you square it? There must be a step I'm missing because if you square the first equation, on the right side you get Vi2sin\phi. On the left side you would get a long quadratic with variables Vi, Vf, and theta.

the aim is to get rid of the phi term right?

so that means you have to express phi in terms of everything else

so squaring both sides of both equations give you

4vi2 - 8vivfcos(t) + 4vf2cos2(t) = vi2sin2(phi)

4vf2sin2(t) = vi2cos2(phi)

so now look at the RHS of both equations, you add them so that the cos and sin (phi) "cancel off" since cos2x + sin2x = 1, so you effectively left with vi2 , i.e, you have factored out vi2

so similarly, for lhs, you combine the sin and cos (t) to get

4vi2 + 4vf2 - 8vivfcos(t) = vi2

so you are now effectively solving for vf in a quadratic equation, without the phi terms
 

Similar threads

Replies
9
Views
3K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
4K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
7K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
6K