Integrate x³√(x²+16) using trigonometric substitution

16 replies · 3K views · last reply
Airp
Messages
23
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Integral of $$ x^3\sqrt{x^2+16}dx $$
answer should give
$$ 1/5(x^2+16)^{5/2} -16/3(x^2+16)^{1/2}+C $$

Homework Equations


x=atanθ

The Attempt at a Solution



Handwritten trigonometric substitution work on lined paper: x = 4tanθ, dx = 4sec²θ dθ, √(x²+16) = 4secθ, reducing to 1024 ∫tan³θ sec⁴θ dθ, then u = tanθ, and final result x⁶/4096 terms and x⁴/256 terms.

Mod note: The integral is ##\int x^3 \sqrt{x^2 + 16} dx##
The published answer is ##1/5(x^2+16)^{5/2} -16/3(x^2+16)^{1/2}+C##

To the OP: Using $ $ (i.e., with a space between the $ symbols) causes the browser to not render what's between the $ pairs. For inline LaTeX, you can use # # (no space) at the beginning and end.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten trigonometric substitution work on lined paper: x = 4 tan θ, dx = 4 sec²θ dθ, with the integrand rewritten as 64 tan³θ sec³θ dθ and then split into two integrals in u = tan θ.
    IMG_20150222_141431.jpg
    29.2 KB · Views: 535
Last edited:
I'm trying to find the integral of the equation, but it doesn't give the same answer as the one I'm supposed to get, and I don't know what I'm doing wrong. I'm using trigonometric substitution which let's x=4sinΘ.
 
In the second step after you did the substitution, the whole things becomes,
4*((tan0^2)+1)^(1/2)=4sec0 and not 4sec0^2
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Airp
can you post the question? Like the integral you are trying to find the answer for?
 
Photo of a printed page listing integral problems, including the integral of x^3 times the square root of x^2 + 16 dx, numbered 6, alongside integrals of x^3 dx over the square root of 4 - x^2, dx over x^2 times the square root of 6 + x^2, and dx over (x^2 + 9)^2, and others.


No problem! I tried using Latex, but it doesn't work...It's #6
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten calculus work on lined paper: trig substitution x = 4tan θ for the integral of x³√(x²+16), with integrals in tan θ and sec θ and a substitution u = tan θ, ending in x/24 + x⁴ terms.
    IMG_20150222_141431.jpg
    45.6 KB · Views: 555
I might be able to help you...I love integration...but I don't understand anything from the picture you posted
 
Faris Shajahan said:
can you post the question? Like the integral you are trying to find the answer for?
See my previous post. It's fairly clear which integral the OP is trying to find.
 
Thank You Mark! I'm still learning to use Latex... I changed it and it should appear ok, now!
 
Ok, I'm currently trying, correcting the mistake I made with my sec^2. It looks good!
 
I can officially say that it works now! Thank you Faris! Such a "minor" mistake that really changed everything in the problem!
 
Faris Shajahan said:
I might be able to help you...I love integration...but I don't understand anything from the picture you posted

He meant Question 6 from the picture
 
Your trig substitution is correct. When you square root, you should get 4sec(x) (I'll use x instead of theta for simplicity)
That will leave you with,
64tan3(x) * 4sec(x)

or simply
256tan3(x)*sec(x)

Break the tan3(x) up, you get
256tan2(x)*sec(x)*tan(x)

I won't do the rest for you but I'll give you a clue. It involves a trig identity and a u substitution
 
Thank you! It works now, my mistake was simply that I forgot to take the sqrt of sec^2
 
hey, if trigonometric substitution is not necessary, it is much easier to put x^2+16=t...=>x^2=t-16...dx=dt/2x...x^3=x*x2...
then integral is ##\int { x*(t-16)*\sqrt(t)*dt/2x} ## => ##\int {(t-16)\sqrt(t) dt/2} ## ...now expand normally...