Intersection of A & B: Answer to Puzzling Question

  • Thread starter Thread starter Panphobia
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Intersection
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
4 replies · 1K views
Panphobia
Messages
435
Reaction score
13

Homework Statement


Set A has twice the number of elements as Set B, 1/3 of the elements of Set A are the same as in Set B, the union of A and B is 42, what is the intersection?

The Attempt at a Solution



This was one of my exam questions, and I just want to see what the correct answer was. What I tried to do was
use the inclusion exclusion principle so

|AUB| = |A| + |B| - (1/3)*|A|
42 = |A| + 1/2|A| - (1/3)|A|
42 = (1/6)|A| + (3/6)*|A| - (2/6)*|A|
42 = (1/3)|A|

And 42 is the intersection, but that makes absolutely no sense, can anyone show me the correct way to get the answer?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Panphobia said:

Homework Statement


Set A has twice the number of elements as Set B, 1/3 of the elements of Set A are the same as in Set B, the union of A and B is 42, what is the intersection?

The Attempt at a Solution



This was one of my exam questions, and I just want to see what the correct answer was. What I tried to do was
use the inclusion exclusion principle so

|AUB| = |A| + |B| - (1/3)*|A|
42 = |A| + 1/2|A| - (1/3)|A|
42 = (1/6)|A| + (3/6)*|A| - (2/6)*|A|
42 = (1/3)|A|

And 42 is the intersection, but that makes absolutely no sense, can anyone show me the correct way to get the answer?
$$42 = |A \cup B| = |A| + |B| - |A \cap B| = 2|B| + |B| - (1/3)\underbrace{(2 |B|)}_{|A|} = (3 - 2/3) |B| = (7/3) |B|$$.
 
Panphobia said:

Homework Statement


Set A has twice the number of elements as Set B, 1/3 of the elements of Set A are the same as in Set B, the union of A and B is 42, what is the intersection?

The Attempt at a Solution



This was one of my exam questions, and I just want to see what the correct answer was. What I tried to do was
use the inclusion exclusion principle so

|AUB| = |A| + |B| - (1/3)*|A|
42 = |A| + 1/2|A| - (1/3)|A|
42 = (1/6)|A| + (3/6)*|A| - (2/6)*|A|
42 = (1/3)|A|

And 42 is the intersection, but that makes absolutely no sense, can anyone show me the correct way to get the answer?

I think if you had added 1+1/2-1/3 correctly you would have had it.
 
Wow elementary math mistakes everywhere haha, yea my mistake. I got it now.