Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the concept of using magnetic fields to propel charged ions in a cylindrical setup, exploring the feasibility of this approach compared to traditional ion thrusters that utilize electric fields. Participants examine the behavior of charged particles in magnetic fields and the implications for generating thrust.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant proposes a design involving a vertical cylinder with charged ions flowing down, questioning how to determine their velocity and whether this would generate enough force to lift the cylinder.
- Another participant points out the complexity of charged particle motion in magnetic fields, referencing the Lorentz Force and suggesting that ion thrusters produce minimal force.
- A participant requests a sketch of the proposed setup to better understand the design.
- The original poster describes the setup as a toilet paper tube with wire wrapped around it to create a coil, expressing interest in predicting the speed of the ions based on the current in the coil.
- One participant argues that in the proposed configuration, ions would either experience no force or be pushed into the walls of the tube, questioning the acceleration of ions along the tube.
- Another participant reinforces that the magnetic field is parallel to the particle velocity, indicating that no force would act on the ions, and suggests studying electromagnetism and ion thrusters for better understanding.
- There is a challenge regarding the expectation of a downward force on ions, especially if they are at rest, with some participants asserting that no such force exists.
- One participant concludes that using an electric field seems necessary to accelerate the ionized particles, noting that magnetic fields do not provide the required push.
- Further discussion includes thoughts on using electric fields, with a participant mentioning volt converters and questioning the optimal length of the electric field in relation to the setup.
- Another participant warns against using the converters due to safety concerns, suggesting a lack of necessary knowledge for safe operation.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express multiple competing views regarding the feasibility of using magnetic fields for propulsion, with significant disagreement on the expected forces acting on the ions and the necessity of electric fields for acceleration. The discussion remains unresolved with no consensus on the proposed approach.
Contextual Notes
Participants highlight limitations in understanding the principles of electromagnetism and the behavior of charged particles in magnetic fields. There are unresolved questions about the design's effectiveness and safety concerns regarding the proposed use of electrical components.