- #1

- 129

- 28

In an electrical circuit, what makes the electrons flow is the fact they they repel each other right? The masses attract each other, so does that make a gravitational circuit impossible?

- Thread starter Tosh5457
- Start date

- #1

- 129

- 28

In an electrical circuit, what makes the electrons flow is the fact they they repel each other right? The masses attract each other, so does that make a gravitational circuit impossible?

- #2

- 15,393

- 685

There's no such thing as negative mass. Think about that for a second.

- #3

sophiecentaur

Science Advisor

Gold Member

2020 Award

- 25,504

- 5,017

That's a gravitational energy circuit.

- #4

- 757

- 0

Pump = voltage source

Orifice = resistor

Long horizontal pipe = inductor+resistor in series

Tank = capacitor

Inductor and Resistor are nonlinear elements.

Mechanical systems are like circuits too:

Mass = inductor

Spring = capacitor

Damper = resistor

Force = voltage source

these are a lot more linear.

- #5

- 226

- 0

That would be a river.

In an electrical circuit, what makes the electrons flow is the fact they they repel each other right? The masses attract each other, so does that make a gravitational circuit impossible?

- #6

sophiecentaur

Science Advisor

Gold Member

2020 Award

- 25,504

- 5,017

What is non-linear about an Inductor or Resistor (assuming they are operating within their design parameters) any more than a Spring (which will have end stops) or a Damper (which can overheat just like a resistor)?Inductor and Resistor are nonlinear elements.

Mechanical systems are like circuits too:

Mass = inductor

Spring = capacitor

Damper = resistor

Force = voltage source

these are a lot more linear.

- #7

FlexGunship

Gold Member

- 369

- 8

He meant that inductors andWhat is non-linear about an Inductor or Resistor (assuming they are operating within their design parameters) any more than a Spring (which will have end stops) or a Damper (which can overheat just like a resistor)?

If you know instantaneous voltage across an ideal resistor you know the instantaneous current through it. This is untrue of ideal inductors and ideal capacitors during any transient.

- #8

sophiecentaur

Science Advisor

Gold Member

2020 Award

- 25,504

- 5,017

That's not what linearity means.

- #9

FlexGunship

Gold Member

- 369

- 8

Strictly speaking you're correct because caps and inductors can only phase shift or attenuate signals. I believe the literal definition of a "linear circuit" (from my college days) is any circuit that doesn't change the fundamental driving frequency at the output. But I think that idea is what he was trying to get at.That's not what linearity means.

- #10

- 757

- 0

Fluid inductor means a long pipe in which the fluid has some KE therefore energy stored into it which is a function of volumetric flow rate. Fluid dynamics is nonlinear in general, especially in a long pipe where the flow is nonuniform with length.What is non-linear about an Inductor or Resistor (assuming they are operating within their design parameters) any more than a Spring (which will have end stops) or a Damper (which can overheat just like a resistor)?

Same thing with fluid resistor, which is an orifice. The pressure drop across an orifice is highly nonlinear with volumetric flow rate, if you recall from fluid dynamics. This is hard to see intuitively either.

Mass-spring-damper systems are much more linear in general. We had some set up in the lab for system dynamics class, and the data that came out is very close to what you predicted from solving the linear systems of ODEs.

- #11

sophiecentaur

Science Advisor

Gold Member

2020 Award

- 25,504

- 5,017

But when someone introduces a new idea / analogy into a thread in an attempt to explain things, the terms should be as strictly correct as possible, surely. There are 'minds' reading these gems of wisdom and drawing all sorts of conclusions. It doesn't help them if we use imprecise terms. A capacitor can distort a signal but such reactive elements produce Linear Distortion.Strictly speaking you're correct because caps and inductors can only phase shift or attenuate signals. I believe the literal definition of a "linear circuit" (from my college days) is any circuit that doesn't change the fundamental driving frequency at the output. But I think that idea is what he was trying to get at.

I think your definition is fair enough - at least it gives a good example of linearity

- #12

FlexGunship

Gold Member

- 369

- 8

Well, if you recall, the original comparison was to fluid dynamics where the term "linear" has a different meaning (i.e. time dependent), so for the comparison of an inductor to an arbitrarily long horizontal flow carrier of finite-diameter calling an inductor non-linear is useful only for comparison purposes. It might have been more helpful in my previous post to put the phrase "non-linear" in quotes.There are 'minds' reading these gems of wisdom and drawing all sorts of conclusions. It doesn't help them if we use imprecise terms. A capacitor can distort a signal but such reactive elements produce Linear Distortion.

- #13

sophiecentaur

Science Advisor

Gold Member

2020 Award

- 25,504

- 5,017

btw, I thought that "non-linear" was a general word to describe a relationship that involved terms with higher order than one or a situation where superposition operated. Though I have heard the term 'non-linear narrative' used to describe stories in which the action is presented out of order. I thought that was just sloppy Non-Scientists at work.