Is there a pattern of research sabotage at Yale?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Greg Bernhardt
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Research Yale
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The discussion centers on incidents of research sabotage at Yale University, particularly involving postdoc Koziol in Antonio Giraldez's developmental biology lab. Koziol's experiments with transgenic zebrafish failed repeatedly after being marked with her initials, while unmarked fish thrived, indicating deliberate tampering. This incident parallels a 2010 case at the University of Michigan, where postdoc Bhrigu confessed to sabotaging a colleague's work after being caught on hidden cameras. Both cases highlight the extreme competitiveness and unethical behavior present in scientific research environments.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of transgenic organism research, specifically zebrafish.
  • Familiarity with laboratory safety protocols and ethical standards in scientific research.
  • Knowledge of experimental design and the importance of control groups.
  • Awareness of the implications of research misconduct and its impact on scientific integrity.
NEXT STEPS
  • Research the ethical guidelines set by the American Psychological Association regarding research integrity.
  • Learn about the use of surveillance in laboratories to prevent research misconduct.
  • Investigate the psychological effects of competition in academic research environments.
  • Explore case studies on research sabotage and their consequences on scientific careers.
USEFUL FOR

This discussion is beneficial for researchers, academic administrators, and ethics committees focused on maintaining integrity in scientific research, as well as anyone interested in the dynamics of competition within academic environments.

Messages
19,865
Reaction score
10,851
Unfortunately the main story appears to be under a "Science" pay wall. Here is a commentary and short summary on the disturbing event.

http://observationdeck.io9.com/holy-****-this-sabotage-story-is-the-stuff-of-researc-1538150751

Koziol's studies of how the genome switches on after an egg is fertilized had begun failing mysteriously in July 2011, a month after she started her postdoc in the developmental biology lab of Antonio Giraldez. In August, she began producing transgenic zebrafish; they all died, not once, but time after time. A lab technician assured her she was doing everything right, and colleagues' fish were fine. So Koziol produced a new batch of fish and divided them in two groups. One she put in a container labeled with her initials, MK, as she had done before. She left the other half unmarked. Sure enough, the labeled fish died; the others were fine...
 
Last edited:
Biology news on Phys.org
Absolutely horrible, especially the way that it was handled. Good thing she moved to another lab. Unfortunately I've heard stories like this before, such as people tampering with chemicals to mess up people's experiments. The hard world of competition in science..
 
I read the entire article last week, and I could not understand why her supervisor turned against her, considering that he and the school were the ones who helped set up the hidden camera to catch the saboteur. All I got was that he wanted her to keep the incident under wraps, which was odd considering he might need to use it to explain to the funding agency on why they were not getting any results.

Zz.
 
A similar case happened in 2010 to a graduate student at the University of Michigan:
At 4:00 a.m. on Sunday 18 April, officers installed two cameras in the lab: one in the cold room where Ames's blots had been contaminated, and one above the refrigerator where she stored her media. Ames came in that day and worked until 5:00 p.m. On Monday morning at around 10:15, she found that her medium had been spiked again. When Ross reviewed the tapes of the intervening hours with Richard Zavala, the officer assigned to the case, she says that her heart sank. Bhrigu entered the lab at 9:00 a.m. on Monday and pulled out the culture media that he would use for the day. He then returned to the fridge with a spray bottle of ethanol, usually used to sterilize lab benches. With his back to the camera, he rummaged through the fridge for 46 seconds. Ross couldn't be sure what he was doing, but it didn't look good.

Zavala escorted Bhrigu to the campus police department for questioning. When he told Bhrigu about the cameras in the lab, the postdoc asked for a drink of water and then confessed. He said that he had been sabotaging Ames's work since February.
http://www.nature.com/news/2010/100929/full/467516a.html
 
Anyways, here's a photo montage that includes photos of victim plus the two scumbags as well as other individuals.
http://www.yale.edu/giraldezlab/Photos.html
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
4K