m4r35n357
- 657
- 148
Sorry but I can't restrain myself . . ;)
The ship's pilot is a trained, intelligent person, who understands relativity. He calculated the route before traveling, and knew full well that at 0.8c he would age 7.5 years over the course of the trip, even without checking his clock at the destination.
Describing this situation in terms of length contraction is merely inviting the division that seb7 cannot resist the urge to perform (if he knows to divide the numerator by gamma first then he also knows the spacetime interval).
Space does not magically contract at the whim of the traveler. It is merely an illusion. Here's how I would describe the situation:
The Doppler factor is 3, so over the whole journey the traveler sees the home clock advance by 2.5 years (1/3 of his own clock rate), and the destination clock advance by 22.5 years (3 times his own rate).
Before the journey the home clock reads (say) 0 years and the destination reads -10 years (they are synchronized). After the journey the home clock reads 0 years and the destination clock reads 10 years.
So, at the start of the journey, the destination clock jumps (in reality there would be finite acceleration so it wouldn't really be instantaneous) back by 2.5 years (from -10 to -12.5), and at the end of the journey the home clock jumps back 2.5 years (from 2.5 to 0).
Clear as mud? Maybe, but no sleight of hand with space "compressing" (I just hope I've got the maths right).
The ship's pilot is a trained, intelligent person, who understands relativity. He calculated the route before traveling, and knew full well that at 0.8c he would age 7.5 years over the course of the trip, even without checking his clock at the destination.
Describing this situation in terms of length contraction is merely inviting the division that seb7 cannot resist the urge to perform (if he knows to divide the numerator by gamma first then he also knows the spacetime interval).
Space does not magically contract at the whim of the traveler. It is merely an illusion. Here's how I would describe the situation:
The Doppler factor is 3, so over the whole journey the traveler sees the home clock advance by 2.5 years (1/3 of his own clock rate), and the destination clock advance by 22.5 years (3 times his own rate).
Before the journey the home clock reads (say) 0 years and the destination reads -10 years (they are synchronized). After the journey the home clock reads 0 years and the destination clock reads 10 years.
So, at the start of the journey, the destination clock jumps (in reality there would be finite acceleration so it wouldn't really be instantaneous) back by 2.5 years (from -10 to -12.5), and at the end of the journey the home clock jumps back 2.5 years (from 2.5 to 0).
Clear as mud? Maybe, but no sleight of hand with space "compressing" (I just hope I've got the maths right).