Law to preserve motion quantity help ( picture included to help describe )

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The problem involves determining the speed of a bullet that strikes a pendulum, represented by a tree piece, which is lifted to a certain height upon impact. The bullet's mass is given as 7.5 g, and the pendulum's mass is 4.3 kg, with the pendulum being lifted by 8.8 cm. The discussion centers around the conservation of momentum and energy principles in this context.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Conceptual clarification, Mathematical reasoning, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss the application of conservation of momentum and energy equations, questioning how to incorporate the height into their calculations. Some express confusion about the timing of energy conversion and the definitions of variables involved.

Discussion Status

Several participants have shared their attempts at formulating equations based on the conservation laws. There is an ongoing exploration of the relationships between the variables, with some suggesting that the kinetic energy of the bullet transforms into potential energy at the peak of the pendulum's swing. No consensus has been reached, but various interpretations and approaches are being examined.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the lack of information regarding angles or additional forces, which complicates their ability to define certain variables. The discussion reflects the constraints of the problem as posed in a homework context.

Akuu
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Speed of a bullet shot into a pendulum ,picture included (dl attch. if pic won't show)

Homework Statement



You're supposed to be able to define the speed of a bullet with the help of a pendulum.
The bullet is shot into a big tree piece ( The pendulum ) with a known mass (weight). The tree piece's center of gravity is lifted upwards when hit by the bullet. What is the speed of the bullet if the bullet's mass (weight) is 7.5g ( 0.0075 kg ), the tree piece's mass (weight) is 4.3 kg and the tree piece is lifted upwards in height of 8.8 cm ( 0.088 m )?


bullet: m1 = 7.5 g = 0.0075 kg :: v (speed) = ? ( This is the question )

tree piece: m2 = 4.3 kg ( it is the pendulum, see picture below )

height: h = 8.8 cm = 0.088 m ( the length that the tree piece is lifted upwards ).

physichelp.PNG


Homework Equations



E(sum) p (before) = E(sum) p (after)

m1v1 + m2v2 = m1u1 + m2u2,

- where m1v1 and m2v2 are 'motion quantity' before the collision whereas m1u1 and m2u2 are the 'motion quantity' after the collision.

I think this is what they want me to use.


The Attempt at a Solution



Ok I've been trying at this for a while now but I can't figure out what to DO with the HEIGHT that is given ( tree piece lifted 8.8 cm ). I can't find a way to define the length the tree piece moves right on the x-plane.

Basically all solutions I've come up with have all been wrong. I tried to use the "Law to preserve energy", the one with E(potential) = E(kinetic) But it didn't work out either.

THE CORRECT ANSWER SHOULD BE: 'v = 4.6 m/s'

Any TIPS on how to solve this? Thanks in advance.
 

Attachments

  • physichelp.PNG
    physichelp.PNG
    687 bytes · Views: 458
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org


Akuu said:

Homework Statement



You're supposed to be able to define the speed of a bullet with the help of a pendulum.
The bullet is shot into a big tree piece ( The pendulum ) with a known mass (weight). The tree piece's center of gravity is lifted upwards when hit by the bullet. What is the speed of the bullet if the bullet's mass (weight) is 7.5g ( 0.0075 kg ), the tree piece's mass (weight) is 4.3 kg and the tree piece is lifted upwards in height of 8.8 cm ( 0.088 m )?bullet: m1 = 7.5 g = 0.0075 kg :: v (speed) = ? ( This is the question )

tree piece: m2 = 4.3 kg ( it is the pendulum, see picture below )

height: h = 8.8 cm = 0.088 m ( the length that the tree piece is lifted upwards ).

Homework Equations



E(sum) p (before) = E(sum) p (after)

m1v1 + m2v2 = m1u1 + m2u2,

- where m1v1 and m2v2 are 'motion quantity' before the collision whereas m1u1 and m2u2 are the 'motion quantity' after the collision.

I think this is what they want me to use.

The Attempt at a Solution



Ok I've been trying at this for a while now but I can't figure out what to DO with the HEIGHT that is given ( tree piece lifted 8.8 cm ). I can't find a way to define the length the tree piece moves right on the x-plane.

Basically all solutions I've come up with have all been wrong. I tried to use the "Law to preserve energy", the one with E(potential) = E(kinetic) But it didn't work out either.

THE CORRECT ANSWER SHOULD BE: 'v = 4.6 m/s'

Any TIPS on how to solve this? Thanks in advance.

Remember you need to consider that there is a conservation of energy.

In this case the Kinetic Energy m*v2/2 will be translated into m*g*h which is the change in height of the combined masses.
 
I get this:

m1v1 = m1u1+m2u2
v1 = u1+(m2u2/m1)

And also this:

v1 = sqr(2gh) (= 1.3139... )

sqr(2gh) = u1+m2u2/m1Now I can't do anything with this because u1 and u2 are still undefined. You need to know the lengths of the ropes or something. Grrr. Wait. When exactly does the Kinetic energy convert? Is it when it HITS the box or when the box is at height 8.8 cm? Should be when it's at 8.8 cm and at the peak of it's swing on the top right, right?

But then again this doesn't help at all. We've got no angles or other Forces except (m1+m2)g at that point. Wth goddamnit. I need to define u1 or u2 before I can know what v1 is, right? But it's impssible, there's too little info. What am I missing??
 
Wait a sec let's see...

m1v1 + m2v2 = m1u1 + m2u2 : v2=0
m1v1 = m1u1 + m2u2 : Is it safe to assume u1 and u2 are the same since they become, like, 1?

then - m1v1 = (m1+m2)u
v1 = (m1+m2)u/m1

Now is it that the Kinetic energy appears at the HIT, and turns into Potential energy when it stops moving. So in face the Kinetic energy of the bullet itself merges with the pendulum and becomes another form of Kinetic energy, thus: (1/2)(m1+m2)u2 = (m1+m2)g*h

so we finally get u = sqr(2gh) which we put in v1 = (m1+m2)u/m1 to get what v is!

Goddamn, seems energy just becomes whenever, quite simple in fact, maybe too simple? With forces you always have to figure out the geometrics but all you needed to figure out here was jus a bit how energy works i guess...
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
7K