LED flashlight, how dangerous are they?

  • Thread starter OrbitalPower
  • Start date
  • #1
OrbitalPower
Ordered this:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000OGABWM/?tag=pfamazon01-20

Got this warning

Warning

"Always wear ANSI approved safety goggles when using this product. Before using this product, the user should read the operating instructions to understand everything about this product. Normal everyday use of this product is likely to expose the user to dust and microscopic particles containing lead and other chemicles known in the State of California to cause cancer, birth defects and other reproductive harm. Always wear the appropriate clothing and safety equipment when operating this product. Wash hand thoroughly after the use and handling of this product." (I assume if you held the flashlight in both hands, you would wash both hands thoroughly. You usually don't wash one hand without washing the other.)

What kind of risk is this? My flashlight did not come with any "operating instructions" either. I just bought it, and other supplies, because we've been experiencing our own "rolling blackouts" in my area: we lose power from time to time even in the middle of the day, with no bad weather going on (I assume this is to happen more often - shifting global climate and increased demand is a lot of fun). So I don't plan to use it everyday, but when I do, I imagine I won't be using those goggles, what kind of risk am I in? I'm guessing my bed clothing isn't appropriate for using this flashlight either.

Why do they feel the need to say "known in the state of California to cause cancer"; these chemicals haven't been shown anywhere else to cause cancer? Does it really matter where it was the chemicals were causing cancer?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
67
165
Ordered this:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000OGABWM/?tag=pfamazon01-20

Got this warning

Warning

"Always wear ANSI approved safety goggles when using this product. Before using this product, the user should read the operating instructions to understand everything about this product. Normal everyday use of this product is likely to expose the user to dust and microscopic particles containing lead and other chemicals known in the State of California to cause cancer, birth defects and other reproductive harm. Always wear the appropriate clothing and safety equipment when operating this product. Wash hand thoroughly after the use and handling of this product." (I assume if you held the flashlight in both hands, you would wash both hands thoroughly. You usually don't wash one hand without washing the other.)

What kind of risk is this? My flashlight did not come with any "operating instructions" either. I just bought it, and other supplies, because we've been experiencing our own "rolling blackouts" in my area: we lose power from time to time even in the middle of the day, with no bad weather going on (I assume this is to happen more often - shifting global climate and increased demand is a lot of fun). So I don't plan to use it everyday, but when I do, I imagine I won't be using those goggles, what kind of risk am I in? I'm guessing my bed clothing isn't appropriate for using this flashlight either.

Why do they feel the need to say "known in the state of California to cause cancer"; these chemicals haven't been shown anywhere else to cause cancer? Does it really matter where it was the chemicals were causing cancer?

California has stricter standards than the EPA in many areas.

Look at a can of paint thinner, there will be a California warning on it, but no federal EPA warning.
The EPA thinks that casual exposure is not harmful, the state of California think that it is.

Even automobiles must meet stricter pollution standards in California.
 
  • #3
russ_watters
Mentor
19,855
6,276
Normal everyday use will expose you to lead? Uh, no.

And the safety goggles are only if you plan on poking yourself in the eye with it.
 
  • #4
2,985
15
Lol, what a bunch of idiots in KALIFORNA government.

You're not seriously asking if this is a health risk, are you? :rolleyes:
 
  • #5
67
165
Rubber gloves are required to handle an LED flashlight in california. Awnold says so.
 
  • #6
695
6
You sure you read that right? being exposed to LEDs as opposed to LEAD?
Wouldn't that be funny? the guy who wrote the warnings might be new, but he knows led is bad for you.
 
  • #7
lisab
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
1,887
616
omg...LED = Lead Emitting Diodes!

Run, run for your lives!
 
  • #8
695
6
You could get LED poisoning. Why the heck would anyone want a flashlight made out of that stuff anyway? Must be made in china.
 
  • #9
russ_watters
Mentor
19,855
6,276
Heh - didn't even consider the possibility they got the wrong led.
 
  • #10
OrbitalPower
Yes, the product actually is made in China. It says "lead and other chemicals..." It is an "LED flashlight gun metal" carrying such a warning.

My own general blueprint I have for designing things is, where it concerns the building and cost analysis, to make it safe as possible. So if there was a huge cost benefit to making it slightly dangerous I may design it that way, but if there is only a minor difference I would design it the safe way and if the difference is truly miniscule you might as well still err on the safe side. It's a good algorithm.

The thread was serious, but I really wasn't worried that much because i don't plan on using it everyday. I've had family members get checked for cancer recently and younger neighbors have died around here from cancer. I know a lot of products from China have shown to be harmful.

I'm not a medical doctor or an engineer with an understanding of safety guidelines, so I don't know. I just thought it was worded a little weird and wanted to see the nature of the warning.
 
  • #11
OrbitalPower
Rubber gloves are required to handle an LED flashlight in california. Awnold says so.
Yes, I'm aware of California's stricter safety standards. I would have worded it something like "and there has been concern in California that it causes..." blah blah blah. The way it was worded seems to mock the California but it could have been written by someone speaking English as a second language, like the manuals for a lot of computer hardware are.
 
  • #12
695
6
keep it out of your mouth and don't worry about it
 
  • #13
2,985
15
Yes, the product actually is made in China. It says "lead and other chemicals..." It is an "LED flashlight gun metal" carrying such a warning.

My own general blueprint I have for designing things is, where it concerns the building and cost analysis, to make it safe as possible. So if there was a huge cost benefit to making it slightly dangerous I may design it that way, but if there is only a minor difference I would design it the safe way and if the difference is truly miniscule you might as well still err on the safe side. It's a good algorithm.

The thread was serious, but I really wasn't worried that much because i don't plan on using it everyday. I've had family members get checked for cancer recently and younger neighbors have died around here from cancer. I know a lot of products from China have shown to be harmful.

I'm not a medical doctor or an engineer with an understanding of safety guidelines, so I don't know. I just thought it was worded a little weird and wanted to see the nature of the warning.
Yeah, a little worried..... more like paranoid. Let's get real here. An aluminum flashlight is going to give you cancer?

Lets please use some critical thinking here....

For the bold, what products? Some have had lead in it, but I haven't heard of anyone getting cancer or dying. People are too paranoid about lead. When I work on model airplanes I have a nice solid CHUNK of lead that I use as a weight, its the size of your palm and weighs about a pound or two. I guess I better wear safty googles. :rofl:
 
Last edited:
  • #14
russ_watters
Mentor
19,855
6,276
I agree that people are too paranoid about lead. Lead is a problem if you have a lot of exposure to it - like if you cake lead powder on your face or eat it. Handling lead fishing weights or lead-based solder would not be enough to cause a problem.

And this flashlight - cyrus is right - it probably doesn't have any lead in it.
 
  • #15
246
6
In California, I think you have to label any chemical that has been shown to raise the likelihood of developing cancer by a certain degree, even if the chemical, in the form it is presented is inert.

For example, even if the chemical is contained in such a way that it is virtually impossible that, during normal use of a product, someone could be exposed to such a chemical, it still needs a warning label.

To avoid running afoul of the law, a lot of public buildings will post the warning on the front, even if they do not actually contain any chemicals that require a warning, so the warning is not very effective in most cases.
 
  • #16
mgb_phys
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
7,774
13
California have just added Galium to the list of warning required chemicals.
A lot of LEDs use Ga, the labels say "Lead or other chemicals" because lead was the first chemical you have to warn about and instead of having to change the label everytime a new substance was added they just have this broad warning.
The eye protection is required for all tools, if you make tools it's easier to put it on everything (I have seen it on dust masks!) than have to decide for each product.

Of course the whole thing makes the workplace less safe - since any office with a laser printer now has a warning notice people will learn to disregard them. so when you come accross a big vat of proper nasty chemical you ignore those warnigns as well.
 
  • #17
695
6
Almost every job will have a book of MDFS sheets for every chemical you may come into contact with at your work. I don't know if everybody has this, but I've seen one for distilled water.
 
  • #18
918
16
I'm not worried. My LED flashlight comes with a red warning light in case the levels of LED increase beyond a safe level. Also, there is a metal cap covering the red warning light just in case. I think the cap is made of lead for extra protection.
 
  • #19
695
6
My flashlight has an opaque lens to prevent accidental blindness.
 
  • #20
chemisttree
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
3,450
491
Are there any PVC components like electrical wires or a bezel? Lead octoate is often used as a plasticizer and warnings about exposure to lead from that source have been included in electronics recently. My christmas lights had such a warning.

Bad ju ju!
 
  • #21
Chi Meson
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
1,789
10
Almost every job will have a book of MDFS sheets for every chemical you may come into contact with at your work. I don't know if everybody has this, but I've seen one for distilled water.
I work at a high school. As well as the MSDS, everything in the chemical closet has the three numerical risk codes for flamability, health, and whatever the other is. It is department policy that all safety measures be taken (goggles, aprons, covered footwear, etc) whenever anything from the chem closet is used. This includes:

distilled water
sand
salt
Alka Seltzer
baking soda
vinegar
corn oil
corn syrup
tin
steel
copper
cotton
sandpaper
paraffin candles

the list goes on
 
  • #22
2,985
15
I work at a high school. As well as the MSDS, everything in the chemical closet has the three numerical risk codes for flamability, health, and whatever the other is. It is department policy that all safety measures be taken (goggles, aprons, covered footwear, etc) whenever anything from the chem closet is used. This includes:

distilled water
sand
salt
Alka Seltzer
baking soda
vinegar
corn oil
corn syrup
tin
steel
copper
cotton
sandpaper
paraffin candles

the list goes on
Do you have to wear goggles when you do a number 2?
 
  • #23
Moonbear
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
11,490
52
Do you have to wear goggles when you do a number 2?
Don't laugh...our custodians get all worried about the possibility of being exposed to some sort of pathogen if they have to clean the anatomy lab. When I heard this, I just blinked a few times and asked, "What do they think happens here that's worse than the bathroom?"
 
  • #24
turbo
Gold Member
3,077
46
While I was a process chemist for a pulp mill, one of my duties included supervising the operation (under my state certification) of the mill's industrial waste-water treatment plant AND the operation of the mill's sanitary treatment plant (waste from toilets, sinks, etc). Guess which one I had to get TONS of preventive inoculations for? I was responsible for compliance testing, so raw and treated waste and I got up-close and personal on a regular basis.
 
  • #25
chemisttree
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
3,450
491
I work at a high school. As well as the MSDS, everything in the chemical closet has the three numerical risk codes for flamability, health, and whatever the other is. It is department policy that all safety measures be taken (goggles, aprons, covered footwear, etc) whenever anything from the chem closet is used. This includes:

distilled water
sand
salt
Alka Seltzer
baking soda
vinegar
corn oil
corn syrup
tin
steel
copper
cotton
sandpaper
paraffin candles

the list goes on
http://www.jtbaker.com/msds/englishhtml/w0600.htm" [Broken] My favorite part of the sheet is, "For Water: LD50 Oral Rat: >90 ml/Kg. Investigated as a mutagen." What a great job that must have been! Just that nagging control experiment though...

I wonder how many labs are in compliance with this MSDS?


http://www.jtbaker.com/msds/englishhtml/s0722.htm" [Broken]
An NFPA rating of 3-0-1! Rating 3 (severe) for Health because it is a carcinogen. That's a worse NFPA rating than something really nasty like http://las.perkinelmer.com/content/MSDS/MSDS_N9300107_US_EN.pdf" [Broken] (3-0-0)
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Related Threads on LED flashlight, how dangerous are they?

  • Last Post
5
Replies
100
Views
7K
  • Last Post
Replies
24
Views
4K
  • Last Post
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
46
Views
4K
  • Last Post
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
18
Views
2K
Replies
60
Views
4K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
39
Views
7K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
11
Views
2K
Top