Length contraction numerical problem

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
Pushoam
Messages
961
Reaction score
53

Homework Statement


Printed textbook problem 4-4 asking how long a proton with energy 10^19 eV takes to cross a galaxy 10^5 light-years across, as measured in (a) the galaxy's rest frame and (b) the particle's rest frame.


Homework Equations


1) k.e. = (1/2)mv2, non- relatvistic

2)K.E. = m0 c2 (ϒ -1), relativistic

3) L=L0/ϒ , Length contraction

The Attempt at a Solution


(A) Taking 1019 eV to be the kinetic energy of the proton,
Non- relativistic calculation
(1/2)mv2 = 1019 eV = 1.6

v = √[ (3.2/1.67)* 1027 ] = 4.3 * 1013 m/s

How is kinetic energy defined relativistically?

K.E. = m0 c2 (ϒ -1)

We can't take 1019 eV as total energy of the proton as if we take so then we won't be able to calculate speed of the proton.

So, for calculating speed of the proton, I have to take 1019 eV as the kinetic energy of proton.

So,
ϒ2 = [ {1019 eV/ m0 c2}+1]2

m0 c2 = 939 MeV

Solving it gives,
1 - v2/c2 = [939 * 10-13]2

v ≈ c

Hence, w.r.t. galaxy frame the proton will take 105 years to cross the galaxy.
B)

W.r.t. the proton frame,
the length of the galaxy is shortened to 105 [939 * 10-13] light years.Hence, the time taken = 105 [939 * 10-13] yearsIs this correct?
 
Pushoam said:
Hence, the time taken = 105 [939 * 10-13] years
Hi Pushoam:

Your work looks OK to me. However, I suggest converting the (B) answer to seconds.

Regards,
Buzz