- #1
Hippasos
- 75
- 0
Jun3-03, 03:02 PM
C0mmie
"... logic is not an attribute of the universe, but instead is our means of understanding the universe, while the universe itself has nothing to do with logic. For expample, imagine a person who for the first time in his life is exposed to Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. To that person, until he comes to accept QM, the universe would seem illogical. Notice the word seem, as logic only exists in human perception and is not a universal fact."
Some thoughts (I'm totally in the woods here.:):
a. If this is a true statement - I am asking how can we ever define universe to ourselves with human logic?
b. Every physical theory is based in logic i.e. human perception while they have nothing to do with universal facts?
c. From where and which point does this human logic emerge (i.e. condradicting that human him-/herself is a part of universe)?
d. Is it a universal fact that logic only exists in human perception?
e. logic (while nothing to do with universal facts) = human means (or even maybe grammar?) for understanding the universal facts? !
The thread I'm referring is to be found here:
https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=2740
C0mmie
"... logic is not an attribute of the universe, but instead is our means of understanding the universe, while the universe itself has nothing to do with logic. For expample, imagine a person who for the first time in his life is exposed to Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. To that person, until he comes to accept QM, the universe would seem illogical. Notice the word seem, as logic only exists in human perception and is not a universal fact."
Some thoughts (I'm totally in the woods here.:):
a. If this is a true statement - I am asking how can we ever define universe to ourselves with human logic?
b. Every physical theory is based in logic i.e. human perception while they have nothing to do with universal facts?
c. From where and which point does this human logic emerge (i.e. condradicting that human him-/herself is a part of universe)?
d. Is it a universal fact that logic only exists in human perception?
e. logic (while nothing to do with universal facts) = human means (or even maybe grammar?) for understanding the universal facts? !
The thread I'm referring is to be found here:
https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=2740