Magnetic Field Due to a Curved Wire Segment

4 replies · 2K views · last reply
member 731016
Homework Statement
Please see below
Relevant Equations
Please see below
For this problem,
Textbook heading reading Example 29.2 Magnetic Field Due to a Curved Wire Segment, followed by the problem: calculate the magnetic field at point O for a wire segment with two straight portions and a circular arc of radius a subtending angle θ.

The solution is,
Textbook solution page for Example 29.2 with a diagram of a curved wire arc AC about point O, and the Biot-Savart integration steps ending in B = mu0 I theta / (4 pi a).

However, why did they not use limits of integration for the integral in red? When I solved this, I used
Definite integral from 0 to a theta of ds, written with the upper limit a theta and the lower limit 0.

as limits of integration.

I see that is not necessary since you get the same answer either way, but is there a deeper reason?

Many thanks!
 
The text says "integrate over the curved path AC", so it was not essential to write that in the algebra. Also, one does not always have to specify the integration domain as a pair of endpoints. They could have defined S as the curve AC and written ##\int_S##.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: MatinSAR and member 731016
haruspex said:
The text says "integrate over the curved path AC", so it was not essential to write that in the algebra. Also, one does not always have to specify the integration domain as a pair of endpoints. They could have defined S as the curve AC and written ##\int_S##.
Thanks for your help @haruspex ! That second notation you mention makes more sense than their single integral over ds. I think another way to avoid implicitly defining an integration domain is by using a line integral
Handwritten-style closed line integral symbol with ds, showing a circle on the integral sign followed by ds.
to denote that we are summing the length elements over the path, correct?
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten integral sign with a subscript S beneath it, denoting a line integral over the path S.
    1673676644883.png
    963 bytes · Views: 181
Callumnc1 said:
Thanks for your help @haruspex ! That second notation you mention makes more sense than their single integral over ds. I think another way to avoid implicitly defining an integration domain is by using a line integral View attachment 320352to denote that we are summing the length elements over the path, correct?
No, that symbol is for integrating around a closed loop.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: hutchphd and member 731016
haruspex said:
No, that symbol is for integrating around a closed loop.
Oh, thank you for your help @haruspex !